THE PLAY: Mafia #16 'Till death do we part...

[joander123]

Yes my vote is a shot in the dark as I have no real idea of what role you are.

The difference is that you've played games and I'm going by your posts and actions.

You're voting for Kuhli well now Liz. 2 players that have a total of 1 full game day under their belts. They haven't even gotten a chance to get feel for the game.
To use the phrase not helping is anti town. How can they help when they aren't sure how to play.

I think Liz has a better feel for the game then Kuhli though unless her earlier posting was actually slips and not a trap she thought would help her out mafia.

If I'm so mafia then why not put your vote on me? You're convinced aren't you? Why pick on the newbs if a vet is screaming mafia to you?

I know you'll switch to me now that I've given you the opening. Still doesn't change that you lynched an innocent and are now chasing newbs.

How i've played in the past!?!? You said earlier in the game for me to not put words in your mouth, because we hadnt played enough together for me to know your style of play... but you can know mine? Thats BS. Also, i have never played like this in any game ever before (the closest was my very first game which i was indeed an innocent wrongly lynched).

Did you not read what liz said? Why am i the only one on her for that?
"oh, i thought Jo was suspicious too, i just didn't think to say anything of it at the time cause i thought it would be bad" what on earth is that? Anyone with half a brain can figure out your supposed to speak your mind and let other people in the game know who you think is guilty, i dont care how new you are.

The reason my vote is not on you is because I'm not so sure your mafia like you are so sure im mafia. No one is SO SURE of anything! My vote is on liz, because of the fact she:
1. Does not seem to help the town by GIVING ANY OF HER THOUGHTS
2. Hasnt posted anything substantive
3. Is not willing to read the other games to know how the games go
4. Is complaining that this thread is to much reading, and doesnt appear to be reading the whole thing.

Another reason why i wont vote you is because if i vote you right now it looks like im panicking, which im not... im not going to give you the satisfaction of an OMGUS vote.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

Hmm, becuase I dont post as you would, yet agree with what everyone else is saying, that makes some sort of point?

I wasnt here when others said the same thing. Charlies was the last post there, so I quoted him.

If youd like to focus on the timing, let the little wheels in your mind keep on turning.

No wheels needed Blue, I've gone digital.

I've got nothing solid to point out, but your posts are quite different than last game and much closer to those of your first. What were you in that game again?

 

[joander123]

As I said, my mistake, however, I still stand by the pushing for DD's lynch while not taking a step back to read what others were saying and think that he could indeed be mistaken.

Is it just a coincidence that you two state that you arent defending each other?

So your vote remains on me simply because i pushed hardest for DD, correct?

Seems weak, i expected more from you...

 

[judgemax]

TWENTY FOUR HOURS TO GO

 

[IceH2O]

How i've played in the past!?!? You said earlier in the game for me to not put words in your mouth, because we hadnt played enough together for me to know your style of play... but you can know mine? Thats BS. Also, i have never played like this in any game ever before (the closest was my very first game which i was indeed an innocent wrongly lynched).

Did you not read what liz said? Why am i the only one on her for that?
"oh, i thought Jo was suspicious too, i just didn't think to say anything of it at the time cause i thought it would be bad" what on earth is that? Anyone with half a brain can figure out your supposed to speak your mind and let other people in the game know who you think is guilty, i dont care how new you are.

The reason my vote is not on you is because I'm not so sure your mafia like you are so sure im mafia. No one is SO SURE of anything! My vote is on liz, because of the fact she:
1. Does not seem to help the town by GIVING ANY OF HER THOUGHTS
2. Hasnt posted anything substantive
3. Is not willing to read the other games to know how the games go
4. Is complaining that this thread is to much reading, and doesnt appear to be reading the whole thing.

Another reason why i wont vote you is because if i vote you right now it looks like im panicking, which im not... im not going to give you the satisfaction of an OMGUS vote.

Where did you get anything about how you've played in the past from my post?

Show me where I mentioned how you've played in the past?


Still trying to put words in my mouth.

 

[Rbishop]

Well RB why don't you start. I haven't really seen any cases built by you or any real ideas on who is what in your opinion.

Any input would be nice. I'm not real big on votes being thrown on 1 person even if they are my top suspect. I could put together a case on Jpap but then I'd be doing others work for them.

So step up to the plate and practice what you're preaching.

That is unless you're trying to seem helpful without really getting into the crowd.

Is it fun just milling around on the outskirts of town and watching? Can't get dirty if you don't get into the mix?

I will, Ice, when I see something or connect enough dots to make a case. I will not just run something into the ground and turn it into a P***ing contest between 2 or 3 individuals because they don't agree with your opinion.

You may not be big on throwing votes on one person but I have seen you berating others in past games as someone doesn't move their vote to the person(s) of your choice as distancing or not supporting the town, kind of like your vote on night one, even after you had stated you liked the two person voting scheme of the previous game. Just an observation.

 

[IceH2O]

Okay I'm going to give you the benefit of the doubt.

I'll clear it up for you.

You've played games so you have experience

I'm going by posts and actions of this game to make my decision.

 

[Blueiz]

no blue, I am pretty sure you said "my mistake" to saying that jo missed the comma first. then you said he agreed with me about it before checking, which is completley incorrect. why didnt you check back since thats what you originally said jo should have done...???

and I am not so much as defending jo, because there is a lot on him anyways to try and do that, more so I am pointing out all of your inconsitancies since you started posting.

Read again, I said MY mistake in a previous post concerning this and stated what my mistake was. Take that or leave it, as you will.

My mistake on you removing the comma Jo, however you DID agree with it without double checking.

You are pointing out a mistake that I have readily said was MY MISTAKE. I got you and Jo mixed up, it was pointed out, and I admitted and accepted that I was wrong. This is exactly what happened with DD, she made a mistake and was persecuted for making it and owning up to it.


My vote still stands on Jo for the reason I voted for him, because of how hard he pushed to have DD lynched, however you are starting to look just as mafia to me as he does.

and I am not so much as defending jo, because there is a lot on him anyways to try and do that, more so I am pointing out all of your inconsitancies since you started posting.

Was the above quote suppose to be an answer to my question

Is it just a coincidence that you two state that you arent defending each other?

It doesnt answer why you and Jo are stating you arent defending each other.

 

[joander123]

going to give me the benefit of the doubt because you know im right? Is that it?

 

[joander123]

I will, Ice, when I see something or connect enough dots to make a case. I will not just run something into the ground and turn it into a P***ing contest between 2 or 3 individuals because they don't agree with your opinion.

You may not be big on throwing votes on one person but I have seen you berating others in past games as someone doesn't move their vote to the person(s) of your choice as distancing or not supporting the town, kind of like your vote on night one, even after you had stated you liked the two person voting scheme of the previous game. Just an observation.

Are you saying im involved in a pissing contest?


RB, i want your opinion. Am i mafia?

Also, good to see that someone else noticed how different ice is playing this game.