Mafia #18 The Santa Game

[clown-lover]

Out of all those posts the only one that mentions lynching an innocent is talking about discussing it not doing it. I see this as a trap laid down which Mad points out in later posts when he says looking for WHO wants to kill. The one post in question kept that discussion alive to find the evils.

Niko is looking like a pretty strong vote candidate at this time.

Still would like Andis explanation of why she would ask anyone if they were Santa.

I caught this as well and would like an explaination..

 

[Coler]

Just saying that the fact bethkira's vote followed yours so closely, with so much time left in the day is curious. You don't find it odd that you vote for me, and say something like 'it's a best guess' at this point, and she agrees and hops on, with 30 hours until nightfall?

As far as being paranoid, I think you're a little off. You're the one who has been sitting on 'Why did Hooked Newbie vote for me?' for the whole day.

what's curious ? no I don't find it odd...you noticed she retracted it of course...that I find odd some (on her part not hers)

asking HN why he's voting for me is completely legit and you know that - no reason given with the vote, and the vote still stands.

 

[Reefscape]

Out of all those posts the only one that mentions lynching an innocent is talking about discussing it not doing it. I see this as a trap laid down which Mad points out in later posts when he says looking for WHO wants to kill. The one post in question kept that discussion alive to find the evils.

Niko is looking like a pretty strong vote candidate at this time.

Still would like Andis explanation of why she would ask anyone if they were Santa.

So, are you suggesting just lynching an innocent just to wittle away at the numbers with a hope you come up trumps and get an elf or Blitzen?? Very very anti-town IMO..

It was actually a question, hence the question mark at the end, and not me stating a point of fact..

 

[Hooked Newbie]

what's curious ? no I don't find it odd...you noticed she retracted it of course...that I find odd some (on her part not hers)

asking HN why he's voting for me is completely legit and you know that - no reason given with the vote, and the vote still stands.

I answered that and believe I have a few good candidates. I just need to do one more review and pull the posts.

 

[jpappy789]

what's curious ? no I don't find it odd...you noticed she retracted it of course...that I find odd some (on her part not hers)

asking HN why he's voting for me is completely legit and you know that - no reason given with the vote, and the vote still stands.

what? on her part...not hers???

anyways, I agree that the vote is weird but I also find your reaction different from what I have seen from you in the past...mentioning it once would have been fine but you brought it up 4 times so I am curious as to why you were so concerned about it...especially since hn had not posted in a while, its not like he was doging a question...JMO

 

[Coler]

what? on her part...not hers???

anyways, I agree that the vote is weird but I also find your reaction different from what I have seen from you in the past...mentioning it once would have been fine but you brought it up 4 times so I am curious as to why you were so concerned about it...especially since hn had not posted in a while, its not like he was doging a question...JMO

*sigh* so concerned about it...whatever...lengthy silences are always interesting. how is my reaction different please - not saying it is/isn't just would be grateful for your insight, as I'm sure the town would be too.

her/hers correct - that was a typo...I find Bethkiras retraction odd please read 'on her part not yours'...she voted, retracted v quickly...almost like being warned off.

I find bethkiras posting generally is following other people...newbie or being led/trying to blend in...not sure.

 

[Coler]

JL, Judge, Andi, Gupman and to a lesser extent grins...little bit more action would help us out here folks.

 

[Coler]

I retract my vote for madcrawdad

and I vote to lynch Clown Lover

 

[Coler]

I am thinking as follows :

Ice has agreed with or explained Mad and HN...if this means they can talk this is either great news or really really awful news for the town...I don't know yet.

Bethkira is following a lot, poking somewhat and I find her suspicious.

I also find Judgemax suspicious :

well, that was a lot of reading, one or two actually belly laughs, and some moments, when all i can do is go WTF?..so far hoked admitted to being and elf, and plant to santa>?>>.WTF?..

*sniff* - scummy.

and my vote is on clown lover

 

[jpappy789]

I retract my vote for madcrawdad

and I vote to lynch Clown Lover

wow coler, you were constantly mentioning hn not posting a reason for voting you and then you come and do this? not once have you talked about cl as suspicious and now you vote without a reason?

I vote to lynch Coler