Mafia #18 The Santa Game

[IceH2O]

If I had to list, I would say Charlie, Grins or you.

I have already stated reasons for both Charlie and Grins, and you becuase I have begun to notice a difference in your issues which you call importance. I feel usually, your findings are much more than what you have now and seem to support them with as much passion. I don't like what I see by your posts.

I actually like the 3 up there now.

HNs try to implicate me let me go back and find all these inconsistencies.

Jpap was the vote that put Niko over the top

Beth has been all over the place, voting for herself even after making a list of suspects. Posts that were hardly comprehendable to posts that are very well written.




Charlie is questionable for his late switch

You are a better suspect then Grins. The copy and paste is enough proof to me that you're communicating. Also the post in which you quoted Mad but answered HN was another of your mistakes. Did you mean to attack Mad or HN in that post? If HN then you should be glad to vote him. If Mad then why was HN on your mind? Was it because you were communicating with HN?

 

[Dangerdoll]

I am not communicating with anyone. How many times do I have to say that? Just please, remember this after I am hit is all I can say.

 

[Rbishop]

Bala has been requested to deliver Present "B"......

And it has been delivered.....

 

[Rbishop]

thru post #923...

to lynch...

hook (2) by cs 870 ice 913

jpap (1) by hook 872

beth (2) by grins 890 jl66 910

5 of 11 have voted.....

no votes from beth, blue, DD, jpap, mad, gup

Nightfall at 8 PM EST Monday...

 

[IceH2O]

Also the post in which you quoted Mad but answered HN was another of your mistakes. Did you mean to attack Mad or HN in that post? If HN then you should be glad to vote him. If Mad then why was HN on your mind? Was it because you were communicating with HN?

DD I'd appreciate an answer to this part of my post.





I'll be leaving soon, its Madden 08 Day and then will be watching the 1st half of the game at my buddies then racing home to watch the 2nd half.

I'll be back on around 3ish I'm guessing.

 

[IceH2O]

In the above post that I want you to answer, you only need to answer who you meant to be attacking and why you chose them. You can ignore the communicating part of the question.

 

[charlie_stubbs]

ummm... Grins... mentioning it again?? come one now, noe you're starting to look obvious. I sure hope Charlie isn't having a roving eye because I am not in the chat area with you.

I only have eyes for you, my lovely little lemon drop.

The UD's are going to be the end of the mafia games. While I like the rule, I also know that life happens. I myself have died a UD and almost died a second one.

I posted a list that I think is not even close to anything at this point. Coler really seemed guilty, at no point did I get any type of vibe of him being a PW. Most everyone I have suspected so far have been innocent.

At this point I am most suspicious of charlie and beth. I am not going to do a bunch of quotes, but I think it can be seen where they have defended each other. I even think at least one of them has been called on it. I am fairly sure they are linked.

I am okay with voting for either one.

I vote to lynch bethkira2000

Above I have bolded part of your post. Please show me where it can be seen Beth and I are defending each other??? Which one of us was called on it??? Must have been her, because it surely wasn't me. Posts like this make me wonder about you. Thusfar, the evils are pounding us (no worse than the UD's I might add), I have been trying since day two to open peoples eyes to HN. Have you even mentioned him this game??? We need to kill an elf tonight or we're done.
I remember a time John, when I wondered what UD meant. Now it seems to have become the norm. I don't know how to police this sort of behaviour. I know when I Mod a game, the ones that die repeated UD's will not be welcome to play. (KOTD comes to mind, and now Coler, who's gameplay I once admired)
I actually died a UD once too, I was unable to get home in time to vote because of RL issues. I adjusted my gameplay and began to vote immediately after night from then on, to prevent it from occurring again. I encourage others to do the same.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

Post split to answer both parts.

Really HN you want to compare posts?

Not really, I've been completely in the dark and am a clueless townie. You I believe, aren't and have teammates to confer with. Like I said, the evils have stayed off all our radars and have led us around. Good game on your parts, poor on mine.

Need I remind you that you had votes on Rudolph on both days? I won't count Day 1s vote since it was early but you started day 2 on him then switched to Charlie while leaving suspicion on Coler. Then the last second switch to Niko.

No, you don't need to remind me of anything. I admit to having played a bad game and missed you guys completely.

Maybe on Coler? But at this point you've voted him, twice. Lady G a known innocent as is Coler and Niko. Judge a possible innocent. Blue and Charlie unknowns.



Using inheriting the role to lynch LG, even though it was never said any roles were switched.

Rb did state that needed adjustments had been made. I was wrong about LG, but I do believe that the role of the Grinch or possibly Blitzen changed hands.

You're actually a better bad guy then I am HN but thanks for trying to give me props.

I doubt it, but thanks. Unfortunately I'm a terrible blind Townie this game.

Comments in red above. I fear I've made the end game easy for you guys. Thanks for the attention after I posted that list.

 

[Grins]

LOL good one, Grins. Using the dirty card you just threw is only going to make it show you are more closer to the chat room than anything else. How about you state just what those suspicions on me were from the start. I would prefer post numbers too.

uh-huh.... mention #4. Now I can see the panic. I just hope people take note of it later on in the game. You are clearly being coached.

I didn't say that I had suspicions on you right from the start. I said I have listed what my suspicions were all along when it came to townspeople. My suspicion for you didn't start until the email paste. (and hello, I'm only mentioning it again in order to answer your question). In fact, I took what you and Blue were saying about Niko to heart and it factored in for making him a suspect at first. I'd not have done that had I considered you a likely suspect from the start.

And am I in a panic? If so it is because we're losing so many innocents this all could be over tonight. Aren't we all concerned about that? Ask what you wish DD because the sooner I can clear myself the sooner we as a town can find who can't.

For now, I'm off to get my Sunday offline chores done. Anyone want to help with a water change? Bueller? Bueller?

 

[Dangerdoll]

I'm going to copy and paste the quote of which you're mentioning so it doesn't look confusing to whoever reads it.

DD I'd appreciate an answer to this part of my post.

Originally Posted by IceH2O
Also the post in which you quoted Mad but answered HN was another of your mistakes. Did you mean to attack Mad or HN in that post? If HN then you should be glad to vote him. If Mad then why was HN on your mind? Was it because you were communicating with HN?


I'll be leaving soon, its Madden 08 Day and then will be watching the 1st half of the game at my buddies then racing home to watch the 2nd half.

I'll be back on around 3ish I'm guessing.

Originally Posted by Madcrawdad
DD, you were more sold on Niko being scum based on the 'investigate me, it's a waste of time' posts, but nothing sold you on CL?
what are you assuming I am missing from CL's posts that would have "sold me"? Apparently, they weren't enough to sell you either as you voted for G... after switching from Charlie, after switching from Coler... when exactly did you think CL was scum enough to vote for him? oh wait... or is it because you never wanted to get a "response" out of him and others, such as the excuse you already used.

I happen to think that Niko is quite sharp.... too sharp to make those posts as he did, they were clearly mis-posts. Do you think it's a good idea to discuss and investigate an innocent if we have a chance to figure out who the elves are? I would find that interesting if you did and would be interested in your reasons why.

in red is what I was picking up from Hooked. Yes, I quoted Mad but the red was my looking into Hooked. As soon as I posted it, I realized it, and that is why I posted the mistake immediately after.