Mafia #20 - Pirates of the Carribean the Play

[LesbianChap]

I think that's 4 left to vote...Blue, Mee-mee, Lady G, and Jpappy789.

Woops, wrong again...3...Blueiz, Mee-mee, and Jpappy789. Uhm, oh, and that's 900...goodnight.

 

[mee-mee]

LC, if you are uncertain about a person's gender, you might want to look at their profile. JM is a female. And she will tell you also...

Right now I agree with both the "biggest" targets...I find them both to be the most likely pirates, and at the time JM was the less looked at...and he still is. That's why I voted for him, to keep everyone, myself especially, looking at more then one target. I was so sure about Beth I didn't let myself look elsewhere...I don't want to do that again.

Why are you so concerned about everyone's post count. And brains and DC can be eliminated because they aren't even in the game...

Alright, I want to see 900 posts before I get to bed, so I figure I might as well do this, as it's not been done for quite a few posts:

User Name Posts
Grins 119
bethkira2000 90
rbishop 90
LesbianChap 78
IceH2O 70
Hooked Newbie 64
Lady G 59
johnlarson66 56
clown-lover 48
Mgamer20o0 38
judgemax 37
Malbri 34
Madcrawdad 31
Dangerdoll 26
Lupin 17
mee-mee 17
Blueiz 14
jpappy789 7
brains2 1
DeputyChiefJR 1


Where's JP at? Is he even playing?

 

[LesbianChap]

I wasn't concerned, but it added a post to get close to my 900 goal before getting to bed...and it appears to be something that's done periodically throughout most of these games...

Why not post it?

 

[mee-mee]

Yeah, that is true. But then we get carried away with who has the most or the least....That has been in every game so far. And some will only look at who posted the least. And others look at who posted most. Darned if you do and darned if you don't....

 

[Blueiz]

So let me get this straight Blue... you're calling for players to post more and saying that I've not been agressive (for the 2nd time)?

You've not posted much at all and I've gone after a few people including Rb, JM, LG, DD, Mad, and beth (unfortunately an innocent in Beth). Right now of the one's I've questioned, I think JM, Rb, and DD are my top suspects but based on this post you are climbing the ladder quick. Who exactly have you gone after? Who'd you put your hit on last night?

No, HN, not calling anyone out for low posting, or saying anyone should post more. Didnt say you havent been agressive. If you care to reread my post, I stated why in it that it seemed like you and ice werent posting as much.

As far as going after someone, I have posted my suspicions and thoughts as I have had them, and the reasons why I have voted for someone.

I too wish that Blue would post more. I can't tell much at all from what she has said; not with her role or with who might be pirates in the game.

Which of the low infrequent posters are you seeing only coming out to attack DD?

Again, I don't trust you Bob COUGHpirateCOUGH, but I'll listen to your theories.



So after 836 posts you have JL, LC, Mal, and MeeMee listed as pirates.

Hmm JL I can understand.

LC is so flipping confused about whether he can edit posts, if you're a man, if RB is you or if LG is Rb that it is difficult to believe he is being coached. LC if you are being coached, I suggest you kick some of the passed out pirates awake and tell them to do a better job.

Mal, eh maybe. But she sure isn't high on my radar.

Mee-Mee. OK, do me a favor...what is is that she is doing so badly that shows she is a pirate? JL who you listed as a pirate is saying the same thing about her. JPap who you also listed as "leaning more guilty" also said MeeMee was acting like mafia. They haven't convinced me she is a pirate, maybe you JM COUGHpirateCOUGH can.


Too much pirate rum JM?



Blue, I've been questioned since early in day one and I've answered direct questions gladly. I've not attemped to hide behind pleas of only trying to help. Call my method overboard or what you will but if I have actually said something that leads you to believe I'm suspicious then list it. For someone that has been observing and opening your ears as you said, you'd have found something if it exists in 850 posts.

An innocent wouldn't leave the other innocents to have to find it themselves, not when we're down Mg, Beth and now Lupin. If you're mafia, you're just trying to toss heat away from your pirate ship.

Grins, I didnt say you had attempted to hide behind anything. What I said was, you could be hiding out in the open. Instead of interpretting and reading between lines that are not there, it will pay for you to read exactly what I said and take it at face value. You are grasping at straws. I have listed my suspicions, including what I listed on you. This is the second time you have told me to post my suspicions. Guess what Grins, I have already. Do you have any more orders to bark? You are good at that, aren't you. Could you be leading the ship?

For reasons already posted, I vote to make RB walk the plank. This is subject to change. LC, JM, and Grins are other possibilities of who I may vote for.

 

[Grins]

Thanks all the same Blue but I'd rather not take advice from someone who has been looking more and more like a pirate.

 

[Blueiz]

Thanks all the same Blue but I'd rather not take advice from someone who has been looking more and more like a pirate.

You usually have so much more to say than this...

 

[Malbri]

Hmm OK, but if you are pretty sure about him, why not try to find out more about the majority you don't have a feeling about? There is more than one pirate after the town you know.

As for Mee-Mee, care to share with us why you are pretty sure she is innocent? Maybe it would help some of the rest of us make up our minds.

She seems to be the only one not giving me that vibe. Her style of posting does not seem pirate-like to me. She doesnt react in a panic like most pirates would, and she hasnt made any "slips" or just any posts in general that give the slightest hint of her being pirate.
So either she isnt pirate, or she is reaaalllly good

 

[IceH2O]

There seems to be a change in the air.. As to what it is specifically the villagers do not know but they can almost feel it, it is so perceptable.. It is only a deep bone feeling, but it feels so evil. The watchman being the ever villagagent person, spies on Black Beards ship way out past the harbor with a telescope and sees that the men/womean are celebrating.. They have dragged out what looks to be a barrel of grog and are toasting each other.. Since this is a low tech world and and the Watchman is only receiving video not audio he can only guess as to what the celebration might be, but it seems that it is centered around one person.

Ok some have posted thoughts on what this might mean. I've seen the drunken stupor and the captain forgets to send in the hit occurrence. I think the chances of these things are so slim that we'd would have to be really lucky for any of them to happen.

I think this is what happened. I think the Captain swapped roles with another player which makes me think Rb or JM were Captain and had to hand it off or risk being killed. The question becomes who did they hand it off to though. The celebration talked about is for the promotion.

I can speak for myself, thank you


I definetly have said what others have not. For example, I said that he explained his RL issues, then jumped on me for explaining mine. I may be wrong, but I dont remember anyone else saying that. Also, the fact that he seemed more willing to help the townies in the last game, when he wasnt even one himself, that was all me.

Ok so you added a little of your own. Not saying you're pirate Mal, just looking your way.

Hmm OK, but if you are pretty sure about him, why not try to find out more about the majority you don't have a feeling about? There is more than one pirate after the town you know.

As for Mee-Mee, care to share with us why you are pretty sure she is innocent? Maybe it would help some of the rest of us make up our minds.

I would like to know also. MM does a lot of OMGUS votes so thats not really enough for me but I can't say I see a reason to vote for JL by her except for his vote on her. I can understand JL putting a vote on her as long as it doesn't effect any lynchings to see if the pressure helps a slip up or if MM stays straight and narrow.

Here's the thing LChap, while I agree with some that you look like you might be trying to find scum, some of the things you say or do give me pause...

In the first quote above you mention that your OMGUS vote will 'make the game interesting with everyone trying to read into it.' If you're truly on the town's side, the idea isn't to have fun while trying to possibly confuse folks. The idea is to have the things you say, and the things you do 'clear' you in other people's minds, so that the townies can concentrate on looking elsewhere. Just a thought.

Additionally, the second quote above looks like you may not be sure about voting rb or JMax at all... the part about maybe moving your vote to someone else entirely seems like an odd thing to say.

Finally,

I vote to make Judgemax walk the plank. Normally I'm not one for trying to keep votes 'even,' but I think that rb and JM are both likely pirates. If voting remains close until later in the day, it could make it harder for Cooke to offer protection to the leading vote getter.

I agree about LC. To this point I had him leaning very much innocent. To many early attacks for a newb just because he knew what he was doing. I'm still not ready to move him down to pirate but I'll be watching a bit harder now. How crazy would it be if this was all distancing and they made him the Captain? Though if they did this to distance it was a poor plan because it has outed some of them.

Guys, this is kinda worrying me here. Do you think he is saying this because we have lost 3 innocents, so they are happy? Or do you think there could be another reason he would say this? I'm almost hate saying this, but it was the first thing I thought when I read it...do you think we are looking at the wrong ppl and they are celebrating because of it?? Both RB and JM seem like pirate to me, nothing they have posted at anytime really makes me feel any different, but this post by Clown has me more than worried? Anyone, have any thoughts on this? Maybe, they are celebrating b/c of the loss of 3 innocents, and being drunk is going to be part of the death post for one, or what???
I really would like some thoughts on this post, I believe Clown is putting hints out there for us, like the one in the post about the hit that was botched we just need to pick up on them.

Posted up above, its either

# During any night of the game the Captain might become unconscious due to overdrinking grog and not be able to get a hit on a townie.

But I strongly thought at 1st read that it was that the Captain swapped roles with another player and the celebration talked about is for the promotion.

 

[IceH2O]

Post 723

Im not sure where my vote will end up, LC is standing out the most to me at this time, however. Id ike to get to the one that is coaching him first. Ice or HN prhaps? What makes me say those two is they are both aggressive players and I dont see that agressiveness this round really.

Post 851 she back tracks a bit

Im not seeing as much from Ice or HN as I would expect to. That may be becuase there are so many posts and its not that they are posting any less, just it appears that they are becuase things are moving so fast. Altho they both have an aggresive play style, which brings to mind Grins.

HN asks in post 853

So let me get this straight Blue... you're calling for players to post more and saying that I've not been agressive (for the 2nd time)?

Post 905 Blue answers

No, HN, not calling anyone out for low posting, or saying anyone should post more. Didnt say you havent been agressive. If you care to reread my post, I stated why in it that it seemed like you and ice werent posting as much.

You did in fact say we weren't being aggressive. I didn't realize aggressiveness was measured in post numbers. I thought it was more about how hard you went after players. Isn't aggressiveness in quality and not quantity? I could have a million posts and never say a word to help.

You also try to link one of us to LC who you've been after non stop. I didin't see you mention Rb as a coach but your vote went there. Also say JM or Grins or LC would work for you. What happened to going after his coach?

I almost feel bad for Rb and JM, their team mates are throwing them to the sharks.

I hope you guys( DD Blue ) don't think just because you're willing to lynch these 2 that you automatically become leaning innocent. I think you guys messed up early this game and its going to bite you in the booty.