MAFIA 22: Who is who?

Mg
Beth
Jpap
HN- known mafia
LC
LG
Clown
CT-known mafia
JM
RB
Grins
Ogre
Bkw
DD
Cory
Emo

Just bringing up the list of players, for easy reference.

Oops, I knocked of HN when I colored his name..
 
"quell" my issues...LOL! You are silly if nothing else, and yes you do make me nervous.

At this point I have to say, DD...Lchap...and Emo are my highest suspects.

I'm going to give Lchap a break at the moment.. I think my day 1 vote etc is clouding my brain about him right now.. There have been a couple of other things that have piqued my interest but I'm not certain enough to replace my vote.
I've spent some time re-reading the thread but the boss of the house is wanting help with things before bed so I'm gonna have to run for the night. I'm hoping tomorrow goes better for work than today did.. sigh..

///Game Off
I was on an 30 ft extension ladder on top of a 12 story building installing a satellite phone antenna today in the cold, snow and wind.. On top of their air handler penthouse section.. I really got chilled.. I have to complete the inside portion and run a wire from the top of the building down to basement.. The fun part is that they don't have a straight chase to get all the way there.. They are using it as an emergency phone in case local power/telephones go out. The building has its own generator so internal power won't be an issue..
/// Game On
 
I'm going to give Lchap a break at the moment.. I think my day 1 vote etc is clouding my brain about him right now.. There have been a couple of other things that have piqued my interest but I'm not certain enough to replace my vote.
I've spent some time re-reading the thread but the boss of the house is wanting help with things before bed so I'm gonna have to run for the night. I'm hoping tomorrow goes better for work than today did.. sigh..

///Game Off
I was on an 30 ft extension ladder on top of a 12 story building installing a satellite phone antenna today in the cold, snow and wind.. On top of their air handler penthouse section.. I really got chilled.. I have to complete the inside portion and run a wire from the top of the building down to basement.. The fun part is that they don't have a straight chase to get all the way there.. They are using it as an emergency phone in case local power/telephones go out. The building has its own generator so internal power won't be an issue..
/// Game On
Ahhh, now see you are worrying me yet again...this did nothing to "quell" my issues, this makes me wonder if I am right and LChap IS the boss and he picked YOU to be his team mate!!

For now I vote to lynch LChap

Well, I went back and forth with him all through day one (and the last 2 games), he would make a good "Boss" candidate and now Clown has made it look as though he is protecting him. Again, I could be wrong...but this is the way I am seeing things atm. HN, was teasing him...playing like him from last game, and I could see Lchap as thinking HN was innocent and retaliating against him by hitting him.
 
HOW COULD THEY KNOW TO COMMUNICATE?!?!?!?!?!??!

Half the hypothesises posted so far all involve people communicating before anyone could know anything about anyone else.

Yes well lets hope the mayor and the policeman understand what should seem so obvious. Seeing that there could be no investigations before the first night the theories of mafia knowing who one another are before then just seems suspect to me as well. If not suspect it sure doesn't make one look all that formidable as a player. Which of course would be suspect in itself if it was being used as a tactic to not appear as a threat. A useless tactic considering how good some of the players are that have said it.

So what made HN look like an innocent to the Mafia boss? Why did he say something that might have made him look like an innocent in their eyes or was it just a random hit.. Thats what I'm looking at now. Just to see if there is anything in his posts that might point us in the mafia boss direction..

Well lets look at where his votes were..they were hopping as fast as LC's were in the MotelHell game you guys played.

14: DD
45: Mg
304: Cory
375: Bkw
415: LC
425: Ogre

If we were to suspect all of those to be mafia it would make the 8 total up once you add in CT and HN himself. However I find that highly unlikely that they'd all be mafia. Probably just HN"s way of rooting out his own team as well. Not to say that the boss isn't in there, shoot I have my vote on LC at the moment. Of course now that I type that and consider that HN has had more interaction with LC than I have, did he suspect that LC was innocent and was trying to set him up? In fact, it would seem that the 2 people that have had the most one on one contact in the game with LC would be HN and Clown in the pirate game. Or am I mistaken and he was a communicating innocent in the motel game?

Also looking at the final votes , the only one with a vote on HN at all was RB. Not sure that means anything at all really but offering it up in case it triggers something for someone else.


of taken (or tooken for Grins)

::flinch::

Oops, I knocked of HN when I colored his name..

Do it again, anything to make the mafia boss remember his blunder. Hey lookie Bob, there is that word again.
 
Ok, heres the list of players still alive with numbers beside them (scale: 1=innocent, 10=mafia)

RB 7
Mg 6
LG 6
Bkw 6
Punkkid 6
Clown 5
Beth 5
LC 5
JM 5
Grins 5
DD 5
Ogre 4
Jpap 4


This is just my oppinion.
 
HOW COULD THEY KNOW TO COMMUNICATE?!?!?!?!?!??!

Half the hypothesises posted so far all involve people communicating before anyone could know anything about anyone else.

Here's the scenarios right now:
Mayor finds innocent : begins communication
Mayor finds mafia : begins pushing for a lynch on that player
Boss finds innocent : innocent dies tonight
Boss finds mafia : they begin communication

Whenever the two leaders find one of their own, we probably will not see much happen at all. They'll need to protect that relationship as much as possible... crap, I'm giving away secrets again, but...

At this point, anyone pushing a 'they knew to communicate last night' theory is mafia to me.

The big deal that we won't learn very much at all for a few days... until a) the mayor finds the police and a few targets or b) one of the bosses finds enough of his/her team to start really manipulating the votes.
ok, I get it... so as of last night's end and day start today, we possibly have 2 innocents and 2 mafia's talking. My goodness, some people are so touchy LOL
 
Ok, heres the list of players still alive with numbers beside them (scale: 1=innocent, 10=mafia)

RB 7
Mg 6
LG 6
Bkw 6
Punkkid 6
Clown 5
Beth 5
LC 5
JM 5
Grins 5
DD 5
Ogre 4
Jpap 4


This is just my oppinion.

So your opinion is that basically everyone has about an average chance of being either mafia or innocent? Helpful.
 
So your opinion is that basically everyone has about an average chance of being either mafia or innocent? Helpful.

lol there is a 3 point spreed...... i keep reading and reading.... i am not sure who should i caste my vote for...... guilty people talk alot trying to get people to look at others.... right Grins......
 
AquariaCentral.com