As usual not a ton to go on yet, but I do have a few questions and thoughts for day one and something I can go back and reference later on.
lady: Other than my first game when haven't I been talkative? You on the other hand are typically a high poster as well and only 4 posts so far this game?
ogre: I find it interesting that when you first placed your vote on me you did it with a wink and the admittingly funny reason of getting me to be quiet. Then you say you're just being annoying to keep the vote there. And then when Mad questions sticking to a random vote being a scumtell you suddenly start suggesting your vote was because I was being scummy. If anything is a scumtell there it is your inconsistency in your reasons for the vote.
hook: The trouble with this theory is that it would hold true for anyone wanting a strong player on their team. So while I don't disagree with it I don't find it very meaningful now either. And yes, I'd say that even if someone else had mentioned you versus me in the theory. I don't have a strong sense from you yet of what your role might be, maybe because you're not a PR this time? It will be interesting to see whose posts get scummier once the dons start choosing teammates.
ice: That last bit I just said to HN applies to you as well. You're just as difficult to read. I'm curious however what it is about Mal that you were mentioning here.
blue: I can't figure out if you were confused about the edited post or if you are trying a really scummy game tactic of making it seem as if I did to everyone else.
clown: Could you explain this post? It looks like you are saying that just because you didn't type it doesn't mean you didn't type it which of course makes me say huh? I'm still wondering why you have an avatar you have previously stated was used to let people know you're mafia. Oh and it appears we both kinda goofed yesterday early on in the midst of the silly flying posts. You did indeed respond to a post of Hook's that his last text was about me. So I was not incorrect about that, however I did miss that his first response was about JM which was the one you were referencing. Oh one last thing, I didn't watch the episode but my son tells me you're basically saying I never leave the computer in order to catch the mafia. Oh and you're calling me fat and icky. :silly:
DD: You're another one I have a hard time reading until typically after the first nightfall. Especially when there have only been 3 posts.
emo: Are you letting us know your role is similiar this game? Oh, and no other questions because that has been your only post which I find odd.
cory: I sincerely had no idea you had played so many games. Where did you get these odds? Frankly it looks like you've just stated the extremely obvious power players that you'll be watching. Shouldn't we all be keeping an eye on them? Other than that your posts thus far are reminding me of when you were mafia in the last game, but only having played that one game with you I don't know if you just always seem mafia'ish COUGHladygCOUGH or it is a tell.
lchp: So why did you try to vote for yourself? Normally I'd guess you were just being silly but seeing that you announced to everyone your strategy for this game would be far different than in the past I'm not so convinced it was silliness this time.
ILB: Eh, ILB I don't know what to think of your posts other than to guess that you aren't a communicating mafia because I'd think if you were, a more experienced player would be telling you to not post as you have been.
beth: You hoooo Beth? No posts yet.
bkw: Although I've played with you before you haven't been a high poster so I don't have much of a read on you going into this nor from what you've said thus far. I'll have to watch what others that know you a bit better might be questioning.
joan: I was confused about past game references during my first game but I learned to ask others for an explanation. Although sometimes it wasn't a helpful answer that I got, sometimes it was because as someone else mentioned it can lead to tells on how someone plays the game in general.
cool: Although I think you being a Celine fan is a mafia sign :silly: it obviously isn't enough to sway me to you being my vote for the day especially since you might not be back on before nightfall.
mad: I don't disagree with this post, however I do disagree with the inference that most are treating it as irrelevant. Once again you're playing as helpful and once again that means nada when it comes to figuring out your role.
jdge: And yes, your analysis of yourself helps a bunch! COUGHmafiaCOUGH
mal: Errr, other than the mix ups with the vote counts you seem to be posting as usual.
king: New, no posts yet.
lady: Other than my first game when haven't I been talkative? You on the other hand are typically a high poster as well and only 4 posts so far this game?
ogre: I find it interesting that when you first placed your vote on me you did it with a wink and the admittingly funny reason of getting me to be quiet. Then you say you're just being annoying to keep the vote there. And then when Mad questions sticking to a random vote being a scumtell you suddenly start suggesting your vote was because I was being scummy. If anything is a scumtell there it is your inconsistency in your reasons for the vote.
hook: The trouble with this theory is that it would hold true for anyone wanting a strong player on their team. So while I don't disagree with it I don't find it very meaningful now either. And yes, I'd say that even if someone else had mentioned you versus me in the theory. I don't have a strong sense from you yet of what your role might be, maybe because you're not a PR this time? It will be interesting to see whose posts get scummier once the dons start choosing teammates.
ice: That last bit I just said to HN applies to you as well. You're just as difficult to read. I'm curious however what it is about Mal that you were mentioning here.
blue: I can't figure out if you were confused about the edited post or if you are trying a really scummy game tactic of making it seem as if I did to everyone else.
clown: Could you explain this post? It looks like you are saying that just because you didn't type it doesn't mean you didn't type it which of course makes me say huh? I'm still wondering why you have an avatar you have previously stated was used to let people know you're mafia. Oh and it appears we both kinda goofed yesterday early on in the midst of the silly flying posts. You did indeed respond to a post of Hook's that his last text was about me. So I was not incorrect about that, however I did miss that his first response was about JM which was the one you were referencing. Oh one last thing, I didn't watch the episode but my son tells me you're basically saying I never leave the computer in order to catch the mafia. Oh and you're calling me fat and icky. :silly:
DD: You're another one I have a hard time reading until typically after the first nightfall. Especially when there have only been 3 posts.
emo: Are you letting us know your role is similiar this game? Oh, and no other questions because that has been your only post which I find odd.
cory: I sincerely had no idea you had played so many games. Where did you get these odds? Frankly it looks like you've just stated the extremely obvious power players that you'll be watching. Shouldn't we all be keeping an eye on them? Other than that your posts thus far are reminding me of when you were mafia in the last game, but only having played that one game with you I don't know if you just always seem mafia'ish COUGHladygCOUGH or it is a tell.
lchp: So why did you try to vote for yourself? Normally I'd guess you were just being silly but seeing that you announced to everyone your strategy for this game would be far different than in the past I'm not so convinced it was silliness this time.
ILB: Eh, ILB I don't know what to think of your posts other than to guess that you aren't a communicating mafia because I'd think if you were, a more experienced player would be telling you to not post as you have been.
beth: You hoooo Beth? No posts yet.
bkw: Although I've played with you before you haven't been a high poster so I don't have much of a read on you going into this nor from what you've said thus far. I'll have to watch what others that know you a bit better might be questioning.
joan: I was confused about past game references during my first game but I learned to ask others for an explanation. Although sometimes it wasn't a helpful answer that I got, sometimes it was because as someone else mentioned it can lead to tells on how someone plays the game in general.
cool: Although I think you being a Celine fan is a mafia sign :silly: it obviously isn't enough to sway me to you being my vote for the day especially since you might not be back on before nightfall.
mad: I don't disagree with this post, however I do disagree with the inference that most are treating it as irrelevant. Once again you're playing as helpful and once again that means nada when it comes to figuring out your role.
jdge: And yes, your analysis of yourself helps a bunch! COUGHmafiaCOUGH
mal: Errr, other than the mix ups with the vote counts you seem to be posting as usual.
king: New, no posts yet.
