Mafia #23 Revenge

Grins said:
blue: I can't figure out if you were confused about the edited post or if you are trying a really scummy game tactic of making it seem as if I did to everyone else.
Click to expand...

All I can say grins is, I know what I saw. It really matters not to me who believes me. Next time Ill be sure and copy the whole post instead of only quoting it.

Im not holding to much out on LC voting for himself mainly becuase it is day one.

I could look at grins post edit as scummy, but not going to, however her denying it happened, well..... time will tell exactly what I think about that.

Lady G doesnt seem to be her usual self. :game off: everything ok LG? :game on:

Not sure where my vote is going to land, I want to go back and see if I can seperate the banter frrom the real information, if that is possible to do from day one postings.
 
Good luck trying to decipher Blue, I am going to base my vote from posts that are well day 2, thats when people seem to get serious. Well a little more serious.
 
Grins said:
cory: I sincerely had no idea you had played so many games. Where did you get these odds? Frankly it looks like you've just stated the extremely obvious power players that you'll be watching. Shouldn't we all be keeping an eye on them? Other than that your posts thus far are reminding me of when you were mafia in the last game, but only having played that one game with you I don't know if you just always seem mafia'ish COUGHladygCOUGH or it is a tell.
Click to expand...

Yep, I played the 8 first games I believe (when there was sometimes only 10 people lol)...and now I'm starting to play them again.

rbishop said one third of people playing this game are mafia, so then each of them has a 33% of being mafia, just like me and you.

I always play like this, with an exception of one game. Thats why I'm sorta hard to read. This game I can honsetly say I am here to help the town.

Matt
 
OgreMkV said:
This post just pushes the fact that the 4 players mentioned would not be mafia. Who would pick someone on their team that is likely to be considered by all to be mafia.

rBish is very good about not manipulating the roles. I think he does what I do and run everyone through an Excel random number generator a couple of times for the roles.

Personally, the only thing that I consider scummy right now (besides going ballistic over a day one vote) is being very quiet and non-helpful.

I was thinking about changing my vote, but the more I think about it the more I'm comfortabe where it is.

At first, it was a sort of joke to get Grins to calm down. Then when she jumped on me, then Mad jumped on me for stating that votes on day one pretty much have to be random, I started to get somewhat suspicious. It's not a 99.9% sure she's mafia yet, but there seems to be a hint of it.

Me and Mad just don't mesh for some reason in these games. It's just the way it is. I don't think he's mafia because he disagrees with me.

Like I keep saying (and no one seems to get this)... day one is a crap shoot. Especially with 200 pages of fluff, two days of additional bad guys, and the only fingers being pointed are totally random or towards people making (at least partially) helpful posts.
Click to expand...

What?! So you're saying you are mafia? Maybe I read it wrong....
 
Blueiz said:
I want to go back and see if I can seperate the banter frrom the real information, if that is possible to do from day one postings.
Click to expand...

No kidding huh? The only way I can ever do it is to start reading from the beginning again to sort it all out. Even then I sometimes wonder if anything is really that useful until much later on in the game.


Cory Lover said:
rbishop said one third of people playing this game are mafia, so then each of them has a 33% of being mafia, just like me and you.
Click to expand...
True, he did say that but it doesn't start that way because according to the rules the dons haven't picked their teams yet I think. Some, but not all so that would mean the %s are a bit off. In any event though, I wasn't asking thinking it was a scummy thing, but more for clarification in case I was missing something.
 
Cory Lover said:
What?! So you're saying you are mafia? Maybe I read it wrong....
Click to expand...

Grins said:
The first time I read Ogre's post I had thought it read "I don't think he is mafia just because he disagrees with me", but now that you point this out I find it interesting.
Click to expand...

I assumed thats what it meant?..maybe i am missing something, but i don't see , how that could imply, that he himself is mafia?..
 
hhhmmmm interesting, probably a typo Orge doesn't seem like the kind of player to make such an obvious tell. But then again even the most veteran players can make mistakes.
 
Grins said:
mad: I don't disagree with this post, however I do disagree with the inference that most are treating it as irrelevant. Once again you're playing as helpful and once again that means nada when it comes to figuring out your role.
Click to expand...

Nope, never accused 'most' of treating day 1 as irrelevant... based on your post to Jo, I said YOU were treating it as irrelevant. On Day 1, most goof off a little early on, but few actually say that no good info ever comes out of day 1.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom