I hope you'd think she's cuter because I have an ugly mug..
:lipssealedsmilie:
Mafia #23 Revenge
- Thread starter Rbishop
- Start date
:lipssealedsmilie:
I did a quick scan and tomorrow when i have time I'll answer questions and make some analysis.
But I couldn't pass up this post.
How in the world did you get 4 new school mafia from this?
Either you are new school and slipped or you are old school and since you only have 3 players you're assuming the other group has 4.
I was pretty close to considering I was wrong about you and the JM we saw yesterday was just fooling around a bit to much. But then because Z states that it could be an inexperienced team that hit IBL and then Cory posted you are one of his top suspects and he is now your top suspect. Then this post.
RB did say 1/3 of the players would be mafia. With Z and the other late comers it would need to be 14 innocents and 7 mafia,so JM could have a point. We assumed KOTD and Z came in as innocents. I'm thinking maybe one of them didn't?
We have 2 days to think this through. But I wouldn't discount anything RB posts in night fall/during the day posts as they have always been a clue.
But I couldn't pass up this post.
Bala sees the Day One come to an end...
And the start of the Day Two...
Who can forsee the Trend..
Be four we reach the End...
g'nite, folks!
How in the world did you get 4 new school mafia from this?
Either you are new school and slipped or you are old school and since you only have 3 players you're assuming the other group has 4.
I was pretty close to considering I was wrong about you and the JM we saw yesterday was just fooling around a bit to much. But then because Z states that it could be an inexperienced team that hit IBL and then Cory posted you are one of his top suspects and he is now your top suspect. Then this post.
RB did say 1/3 of the players would be mafia. With Z and the other late comers it would need to be 14 innocents and 7 mafia,so JM could have a point. We assumed KOTD and Z came in as innocents. I'm thinking maybe one of them didn't?
We have 2 days to think this through. But I wouldn't discount anything RB posts in night fall/during the day posts as they have always been a clue.
I assumed, ..that since it said that another day was starting, that i was taking it as a "new" day! so my assumption, would be That new mafia has 4, ..yes i joked around yesterday, ..so what, ..i have read every post in this monster of a thread, ..if i want to be goofy, so be it, ..mafia didn't pick me, so I achieved me goal. so, you just go ahead and keep me on your list, ..And, i don't recall asking your "opinion" on my post, ..so, why did you offer it?..
That could be ICE but I would have to call FOUL with RB and throw one of his style of hissy fits if he did.. Because he specifically states under the mafia rules that he will pick a boss and that boss will select an additional team mate at the beginning of day one and another on day 2.
But as I have also stated before I know Bob likes to screw with the players and have been the person he utilized to perform such actions as well (I drove JL nuts in one game).. So I guess in reality I wouldn't put anything past him. But like I said if he did break his own rules I'll be calling as large of a foul with him as I did with you in your game.
I agree. I'm extremely tired and my GF is complaining that the computer is her replacement.. So I'm going to bed.. I might be on in the morning but won't be on all day as I have a list of service calls a mile long for the rest of the week..
OK My first move will be to analize ILB and see who might have felt safe hitting her...
So, the players she didn't go after at all: LG, Blue, DD, Emo, Bkw, Joan, Cool(wtf is this, it's on her list), Mad, KOTD. Joan is gone due to a UD. These are going to be my initial suspects. I'm going to add JM in there just cause she may have had ILB hit just so she could claim she'd never do something so stupid, ILB was obviously after JM the whole time, while looking at other people.
I think we can remove Bkw and KOTD off that list, at least for the Mafia team that hit ILB...though KOTD might have done it...obviously some none-gameplay related "connecting" going on with little comments to many of ILB's posts.
Origionally I was gonna make this the longest Mafia post ever, quoting almost everything from my suspects and analizing it...but I started this cause I couldn't sleep and I'm going to try again. Once again, my suspects to watch are: LG, Blue, DD, Emo, Bkw, Mad, KOTD, Cool (whoever this is) and JM.
My initial thoughts without going back:
Blue and Emo I haven't seen nearly as much of as I'd expect.
Bkw is quiet as usual.
Don't remember anything from Mad's posts. LG and DD pretty much the same.
KOTD seemed to attach himself to ILB a lot after he retracted his vote. Only reason he's still on my list, as he seems pretty helpful.
JM's seemed rather defensive most her posts, especially the ones targeted at her.
No content.
Goes after JM with no reason a few posts into the game...day 1 foolery.
Newbie card.
Tries to switch to HN...Day 1 foolery imo.
Screw'd up the vote change and can't figure it out. noob move.
And again.
Finally switches to HN...either ILB is sure, or ILB just want's to do jostle feathers.
Day 1 jokes, commenting on Mal's vote for ILB.
Gives HN a break and claims to wait till nightfall.
Some Day 1 RP, says the last several votes were to "make the game more interesting"
First time defense from Ice...claims a motive.
Response to a jibe from Ogre.
i have nothing to say....
Aparently some silly RP...origionally thought to be indicating the detective PR, but that turns out false.
IBL says the reason for a lot of her actions are for her own amusement.
I think this is more RP based on the post before last.
More RP.
Jibes Ice.
Uhm, guess there's no plan now?
Ice just jibed Grins about her bonbon addiction.
bored random post.
Defending her RP story, but I don't think that's very important.
AH, something I can use. Here she accuses/suspects: Ogre, Ice, Myself, Beth, Grins and JM. She claims to think LG is innocent, and maybe Grins.
Apparently Judge didn't like her last post.
People said she just copy/pasted CL's post...apparently she used his post to add her own thought.
Proclaiming her innocence.
Voting for Judge way before nightfall as she claimed she'd do earlier.
JM harrassed, she replied.
Another harrass from JM.
Defending another accusation from JM.
Here she's going after a suposed (false) slip from Mal.
Here she asks Mal if Mal think's she should vote for someone else other then JM. Mal says "I think you should"
HN asks her about her messed up RP story way up there a few moons ago, and threatens to vote for ILB is she doesn't have a good explaination. ILB has no clue what Grins is asking about.
I think this is in response to Mal saying "This is what happens when people complain I don't post enough." Not very helpful imo.Sorry...
Well the Mafia did it for you hun...trust me, it was more peaceful the way you went ;-)
Here she defends a jibe from Mal towards Ice.
Something happened with her and CL that I can't seem to find...almost saw some blood on this one.
KOTD quoted her last post and bolded the all-caps, and said it was a fun one too. Just some agreement between the two.
Can't tell if she was refering to something specific, or the game in general.
Just a tag-on from the last post.
Another tag-on.
Guess she's been avoiding RL cause of Mafia. tsk tsk.
Guess she's going to do the RL thing.
Guess she thought it was nightfall already. JM replied "You! lmao"
Here she's explaining her last post.
Official vote tally. Also to note: Mal and KOTD voted for ILB, then switched their votes.
So, the players she didn't go after at all: LG, Blue, DD, Emo, Bkw, Joan, Cool(wtf is this, it's on her list), Mad, KOTD. Joan is gone due to a UD. These are going to be my initial suspects. I'm going to add JM in there just cause she may have had ILB hit just so she could claim she'd never do something so stupid, ILB was obviously after JM the whole time, while looking at other people.
I think we can remove Bkw and KOTD off that list, at least for the Mafia team that hit ILB...though KOTD might have done it...obviously some none-gameplay related "connecting" going on with little comments to many of ILB's posts.
Origionally I was gonna make this the longest Mafia post ever, quoting almost everything from my suspects and analizing it...but I started this cause I couldn't sleep and I'm going to try again. Once again, my suspects to watch are: LG, Blue, DD, Emo, Bkw, Mad, KOTD, Cool (whoever this is) and JM.
My initial thoughts without going back:
Blue and Emo I haven't seen nearly as much of as I'd expect.
Bkw is quiet as usual.
Don't remember anything from Mad's posts. LG and DD pretty much the same.
KOTD seemed to attach himself to ILB a lot after he retracted his vote. Only reason he's still on my list, as he seems pretty helpful.
JM's seemed rather defensive most her posts, especially the ones targeted at her.
..how did i attach myself to ILB..?...i'd also like to know how..and why i am a suspect..lol
oh god..not a nother one..
Wow, what a bad night, not only a innocent but our DR too.
Now for a couple thoughts about Bobs "clues",
My final thoughts right now...JM old school and part of the hit on ILB...Grins new school. I think we just lynched the wrong one tonight (obviously), but until more evidence...I still believe Grins and Jmax to be mafia.
I have to get to bed now and will post more tomorrow, there is much to be discussed.
Now for a couple thoughts about Bobs "clues",
Ok, so IMO he is saying that the mafia didn't have to do much...b/c the innocent pretty much hung themselves. Now do I think we were wrong about all three ppl we had in the top votes.....no, I sure do not. What I do wonder about is JM and Grins...JM pretty much brought the votes on herself, is he talking about her too, that is possible but I tend to believe he makes each post to the person lynched. Grins..well, really she didn't bring it to herself is he talking about her...I don't think so.
What do I get from this post...well, I believe the hit on ILB was from an experienced player, that is what I get from this.
My final thoughts right now...JM old school and part of the hit on ILB...Grins new school. I think we just lynched the wrong one tonight (obviously), but until more evidence...I still believe Grins and Jmax to be mafia.
I have to get to bed now and will post more tomorrow, there is much to be discussed.
