Originally Posted by Hooked Newbie
bkw- How did I make Ice & CL look guilty exactly? They actually are the closest in my mind to innocent right now. Ice, because I think his posts have been different from past games when I've always tended to suspect him (again, if he's playing me he's doing better than ever). Cory, I think is innocent because if he would have really looked at jpappy's post, he should've seen the implications.
You didn't come out and say they were guilty, but you called them out on a possible connection. If you insinuate a connection between two players that's the same as calling them guilty.
That's why I went after him and tried to play that post down. Those that didn't weigh in at all on the shading post are shady to me (pun intended) because I think the mafia were probably discussing it behind closed doors and wouldn't want to let on that they caught it.
So let me get this correct, to play a post down you went after CL, an honorable thing to do. Although i kinda see it as scummy, after cl pointed out im sure everyone was thinking the same thing and no amount of playin it down would help. If the mafia read the CLs post then the nail was in the coffin. I think you were just tryin to set yourself up. Make it look like you were tryin to help JP...........and that's exactly what you're doing now.
My vote on Emo was because I read his post as an admission. Period. I read it wrong and am sorry, but other than the numbers thing, I'm ok with not having to read his posts anymore. Trust me, if I was mafia and had to choose between Emo and Ice as innocents... Ice would be gone right now. Thanks for the vote though. I was feeling kind of left out. Any other suspects or actual thoughts that might help us out?
If it was a mafia decision to hit ice i would agree with you. In the matter of votes i dont think so. The mafia had to hide behind something for their night one votes, and the emo thing was an easy out. This leads me back to my post. Either Ice is mafia and you helped him out, or Ice is innocent and it was a setup to get rid of ice later. In either one you hide behind the Emo confession post. Which you're doing right now
Just my thoughts. I think you're a good solid vote.
HN is my number one vote.
LC is my number two. still playing differently then before, and i agree with CL that Jmax sending him a READ IT!! pm could mean he really needs to read his pm.
Mad its been awhile since i actually played with you but you seem suspicious.
I feel pretty strong about the first two, mad is just a feeling.
Cl-you pointed out the Jp thing and the LC thing. Both good catches, i dont know if a mafia would pointed out either. Im leaning innocent.
I hope this works... I hate the commenting within a quote though I do it myself sometimes.
1. If I mention that two players appear innocent it's the same as calling them both guilty?! I call everyone out. You included.
2. I went after Cory to get a reaction and hopefully detract from the jpap post. Cory's response led me to believe that he wasn't evil (maybe a bit too "enthusiastic" though). Why so jumpy about the fact that you supposedly didn't notice it?
3. I just don't get what you're trying to say here... again, Ice and I are either innocent or guilty. Go back to your chat room and come up with something that makes sense...
I'm not hiding behind anything, I'm right here. Quit regurgitating past cases and make your own (original) on me if you think I'm guilty. You seem so sure of what "I'm doing right now"... So what is it? I'll give you a clue... I think I'm outting scum.
