Mafia who done it! The Play

Ice I think Rb is mafia, but If I had to go with my top 2 for a vote he would not be one of them. My top #1 vote is Ogre-as the Colonel.And HN or LC wouldd be second
 
IceH2O said:
I'll vote anyone but Mad at this point out of the team RB/Mad HN/LC. I'll be leaving in a bit but if we can all agree on who we think is Col, which I'm leaning either LC or RB then I'll vote that way. The more I think about it I would think the Col would befriend me to keep me off their ***.
The only reason I went after RB 1st was the gloating LMAO post. If you guys would rather go after LC I'll follow suit.
Click to expand...

The most telling line of all...and if it's Beth that's Mafia between Beth and RB, that explains why RB would stick on Ice through the first night...

I think we've found our COL.
 
IceH2O said:
I'll vote anyone but Mad at this point out of the team RB/Mad HN/LC. I'll be leaving in a bit but if we can all agree on who we think is Col, which I'm leaning either LC or RB then I'll vote that way. The more I think about it I would think the Col would befriend me to keep me off their ***.
The only reason I went after RB 1st was the gloating LMAO post. If you guys would rather go after LC I'll follow suit.
Click to expand...

I've been thinking about this and it makes sense. There is one major problem with it though... I'm not on a team. I'm still doing some reading and think that you may actually be the missing piece of the puzzle. I'll probably be voting for either Rb or YOU.


Madam Mod- When is night?
 
LesbianChap said:
Oh yes, we're one and the same. And I don't think they'd hit one of their own when they could take out an innocent instead.




I agree...we need to go after a single Mafia member, and hopefully get the COL. Mad is my best target, now I'm wondering if the rest of the innocents are going to join me against you.
Click to expand...

Save your breath trying to convince me. You've fooled me long enough, to bad all things come to an end huh.

Maybe you can convince the others but anything from you and HN will fall on deaf ears. RB hasn't pulled any evidence to date so I'd be amazed if he tried to convince anyone of anything now and well Mad could be innocent but I doubt it.But I'm willing to save him for last.

You say the mafia wouldn't hit their own. But you're missing the entire point. They only need to get 2 innocents on the mafia player they name and 2 on another mafia player. The when night is about to fall the 4, or even only 3, mafia players switch to an innocent to end the game. With the way innocents have been around at night fall a switch could easily be made without a counter switch.
 
bethkira2000 said:
Ice I think Rb is mafia, but If I had to go with my top 2 for a vote he would not be one of them. My top #1 vote is Ogre-as the Colonel.And HN or LC wouldd be second
Click to expand...

Beth can you explain why Mad wouldn't even put any pressure onto RB?

Has RB helped the town at all? His posting telling us to go find the posts on our own didn't even draw a peak from Mad. Don't you think Mad would have been all over that if innocent?
 
Yes Ice I do, but maybe Mad was looking for the top gun like you and me. I am not saying that Rb is innocent. I think Rb is Mafia but I don't think Mad is, I have said who my top picks are.
 
Look guys, I think rb is on everyone's list. I agree with Ice that we must pick ONE person to lynch. The innocents can't be split up at this point or we are screwed. I like rb (and will keep my vote on him) as mafia.

My concern is that Ice and mad (and me for that matter) haven't been eliminated by the mafia. That leads me to think that we have some experienced mafia players. So I can't discount that one of Mad, Ice, hooked is mafia.
 
IceH2O said:
I've got it figured out and its the only thing that makes sense to me.

I vote to lynch RB

I think the mafia team is

RB
Mad
HN
LC

If RB isn't the Col then LC is.

I think they split into 2 teams.One to attack me and one to befriend me. Notice LC and HN never attacked each other enough to draw suspicion or votes onto one another and the same for Mad and RB. But the team of RB/Mad has attacked HN/LC and vice versa. That way if one team got lynched the other team looked innocent.

Nothing is going to change my mind on this,

RBs LMAO was a gloat to be saying I got played. Mad then asked RB what the LMAO was for so that RB could explain it the way he did.

Beth Bkw and Ogre I believe 100% you are innocent, you need to really look into this idea with an open mind and ignore whats been said about anyone else at this point. We need to all vote for the same person and let the coin decide. If you think you know who the Col is then thats who we need to vote. If we can't agree on the Col lets at least agree on 1 of the 4 to vote for.
Click to expand...

Pretty sure that Ice will vote RB instead of LChap here... folks need to pay attention, the mafia can now start putting their own people on lists in order to seem legit, even offer to vote them....right after they lynch an innocent for the win.

LesbianChap said:
Well I looked back a bit...re-skimmed the thread...if I weren't playing this game, based on the vote record alone, I'd say Ice, HN, myself and Mad were the Mafia team...Ice, HN, and myself have voted the same every night, and voted for an innocent every night, which doesn't look good for us. Mad's placed his vote each night where it would do no damage.

And since I am playing, I know one of those players isn't Mafia...my modified team would have to be: Ice, HN, Mad and either Beth or RB. RB was willing to sacrifice Ice the first night, which doesn't look well...so I don't think Ice is the Col...Beth has been on the radar for a while now. I think Ice was helping to keep Mad off the radar by accusing him so hard...if I were to name a Col, it'd be him, and they're either willing to lose RB, or Beth's the Mafia and they're trying to lynch another innocent.

I've been fooled, and played...but hopefully this will be the start of fixing the situation:
I vote to lynch Mad
Click to expand...

You've been fooled and played, yeah right. Do you even read your posts? I really love the part about Ice keeping me off the radar by accusing me so hard.....what a wonderful new strategy. Let someone quietly slide by, by accusing them and trying to undermine them at every turn.

I've said it strongly since Day 1....you're scum. Has that been helping you hide in plain sight? Pretty sure it hasn't, hoodie-boy.

I vote to lynch LChap

For all you mafia who want to start screaming 'OMGUS! OMGUS!' make sure that you fully understand what one is before doing so...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom