Mafia #28: The Play

[johnlarson66]

funny, because I find it odd to even bring this out so early in the game when the first page is full of joking and the Ice/Hooked situation (no, this is not saying I am considering Ice and Hooked's posts jokes now). I think bringing this up now only brings out folks to start posting one liners, filling the pages with nonsense just to make sure they get higher post counts for the game so they don't fall to the bottom. Yeah, it may be good because it gets people to talk more so to show slip-ups but is it easier to weed the slips out of 100 nonsense posts than to weed them out of people trying to pick up points from truer posted thoughts? Sure, it might be forcing out the mafia if they are lying low and keeping quiet to me, it's six in one, half dozen in the other...

basically, in my opinion, John you might be trying to appear helpful to get people to sniff elsewhere because after all, you posted the list... right?

just for thought, because John had placed the list... I decided to see where he fit into the whole list. I removed pappy from the list and find that john was smack in the middle at the time of the list being made...

Hooked Newbie 16
IceH2O 14
rbishop 11
Cory Lover 10
Dangerdoll 9
---------------
johnlarson66 8
judgemax 7
ZSandmann 6
charlie_stubbs 5
LiveOutLoud 5
----------------
The Zigman 3
Lady G 3
Swayde 2
Reefscape 1
mee-mee 1

and what better place than to hide in the middle of the crowd, eh, john?

That is me, pretending to be helpful and hiding in the middle.

 

[jpappy789]

Im back with an update:

Night 1: Sunday 3/2 @ 6 PM CST

LOL (1)- Chas 24
Ice (2)- Hn 33 LOL 66
Swayde (1)- Ice 150

 

[LiveOutLoud]

Sorry Ice and Charlie I didn't see both of your guys' question Here's your answer I hope you all got your reading glasses handie I mainly voted for Ice for some reaction from different people first of all at almost the beggining you said that you thought HN was mafia because he was trying to get me to vote for Charlie like he was the wrong person to vote for Protecting?? And now that I've read all of the posts since then I've seen Charlie trying to protect Ice he asked something about is Ice's post fishy like mine supposedly are Is he protecting Ice??? Then then Ice said he would side with Charlie if I didn't respond Unless I miss it I didn't see Charlie say anywhere that he was voting for me There's a chance I could have missed it so correct me if I'm wrong.
Ice and Charlie reading this post.:lipssealedsmilie::grinyes:

 

[johnlarson66]

I vote to lynch Cory Lover

I do not think his posts have been helpful to the town. Two of his post do more to confuse the town than to help it. The post that says that either both Ice and HN are mafia, or just one is, or both are innocent touches a nerve with me. If it was said by a newbie I could understand, but CL has been around te block a few times. I also do not like the day one "nothing yet" list.

 

[ZSandmann]

Sorry Ice and Charlie I didn't see both of your guys' question Here's your answer I hope you all got your reading glasses handie I mainly voted for Ice for some reaction from different people first of all at almost the beggining you said that you thought HN was mafia because he was trying to get me to vote for Charlie like he was the wrong person to vote for Protecting?? And now that I've read all of the posts since then I've seen Charlie trying to protect Ice he asked something about is Ice's post fishy like mine supposedly are Is he protecting Ice??? Then then Ice said he would side with Charlie if I didn't respond Unless I miss it I didn't see Charlie say anywhere that he was voting for me There's a chance I could have missed it so correct me if I'm wrong.
Ice and Charlie reading this post.:lipssealedsmilie::grinyes:

You're not the least bit interested in why she thinks I'm mafia? Its her very 1st game,what does she have to go on besides the joke posts? She can't even claim intuition because she doesn't know how I play.

How can you be interested in why JM thinks HN and I are evil,she explained it, but not why Live thinks I am.JM actually had a good reason,though its wrong but possible.

So far you and Live are my top 2 suspects. I might keep Live around a 2nd day just to see if she accidentally tells us who the other team mates might be.
So with that for now I vote to lynch Sway.

Sorry Ice but this last post from LOL pretty much seals it for me. I would rather we get a Mafia than hold one in the pocket. I think we all remember the pocket mafia discussion from several games back. LOL is all over the place and seems to be trying to get the veterans all connected into a tight little bundle, I presume to get them all out of the way. Look at it from the perspective of a Mafia team with newer players. Wouldn't you want to get Ice, HN, and Charlie out of the way first?

I vote to lynch LOL!

Not "in stone" but I like my vote.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

I can definitely see the case on LOL, but I think she's just playing a role dictated by someone else. I want to chop the head off the snake...

I retract my vote for Ice and vote to lynch Rb. This vote will stay unless someone comes out as mafia.

 

[IceH2O]

Not so fast potato man, there are still weasels about.
I vote to lynch LiveoutLoud.

Well that figures I don't even get a chance to say something and somebody's already trying to vote me out

Sorry Ice and Charlie I didn't see both of your guys' question Here's your answer I hope you all got your reading glasses handie I mainly voted for Ice for some reaction from different people first of all at almost the beggining you said that you thought HN was mafia because he was trying to get me to vote for Charlie like he was the wrong person to vote for Protecting?? And now that I've read all of the posts since then I've seen Charlie trying to protect Ice he asked something about is Ice's post fishy like mine supposedly are Is he protecting Ice??? Then then Ice said he would side with Charlie if I didn't respond Unless I miss it I didn't see Charlie say anywhere that he was voting for me There's a chance I could have missed it so correct me if I'm wrong.
Ice and Charlie reading this post.:lipssealedsmilie::grinyes:

You commented on Charlies vote for you,so how did you miss it?

Yes I did say I'd side with Charlie on voting for you.You ignored our questions, mafia tend to try to side step questions hoping they will be swept off to the side and forgotten.

No protecting going on here,I'm no more positive that Charlie is innocent then I am of anyone else.

 

[IceH2O]

Sorry Ice but this last post from LOL pretty much seals it for me. I would rather we get a Mafia than hold one in the pocket. I think we all remember the pocket mafia discussion from several games back. LOL is all over the place and seems to be trying to get the veterans all connected into a tight little bundle, I presume to get them all out of the way. Look at it from the perspective of a Mafia team with newer players. Wouldn't you want to get Ice, HN, and Charlie out of the way first?

I vote to lynch LOL!

Not "in stone" but I like my vote.

I can definitely see the case on LOL, but I think she's just playing a role dictated by someone else. I want to chop the head off the snake...

I retract my vote for Ice and vote to lynch Rb. This vote will stay unless someone comes out as mafia.

I take it neither of you guys think Sway might be the one calling the shots? Doesn't it bother you that she wants to know more about JMs post then she did for Lives vote? Like she knew why Live voted that way?

What are your thoughts on Sway? I know about pocket mafia but I see 2 I think are and I'd rather take out the more experienced one.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

I take it neither of you guys think Sway might be the one calling the shots? Doesn't it bother you that she wants to know more about JMs post then she did for Lives vote? Like she knew why Live voted that way?

What are your thoughts on Sway? I know about pocket mafia but I see 2 I think are and I'd rather take out the more experienced one.

I'm not as convinced about Swayde as I am of Rb. It bothers me a bit that she was more interested in JM's post than LOL's vote, but by the same token I could read this as you trying to protect LOL. I definitely wasn't comfortable being followed onto you by her though so for now she seems guiltier to me. What are your thoughts about Rb?

 

[mee-mee]

Look at that...distancing already....

Nice try BOB....

Well I gotta say that the Ice-capades is quite interesting to read first thing in the morning. You certainly are busy Ice. I don't agree with people that Ice looks scummy, in fact I see him as looking like an innocent who is trying to kick in as many doors as he possibly can and stir things up. Standard Ice aggression and it seems to be the same thing he did in the last game I participated in with him, where I was convinced he was a bad guy and helped lynch him only to see that he was actually a fellow a innocent.

HN jumping onto him so quickly is suspicious, but I seriously think he is too experienced and would know better than to jump so quickly and eagerly onto an innocent right away if he were mafia, so I am actually leaning him innocent as well.

CS, man you are still just as odd as I can remember lol. I guess it works for ya, makes it pretty difficult to get a solid read on you.

I do believe the mafia folks are laying low and letting innocents duke it out while they just try to blend in. It would be great to know how many mafia there actually are. We've got to figure in 3 people with roles too, which I tend to get mixed up with bad guy vibes. So if there are 4-5 mafia, like RB thinks, and 3 special roles, that ends up being about half the town. I can already feel the paranoia setting in.

And what happened to the role playing? That sci-fi game there was so much role playing, but there's like none in this game. It's certainly been exciting so far though at least. I want my eclairs Mee-Mee!!!

Anyhow, I am not getting a strong enough vibe off of anyone right now to cast a vote. I hope that there is a lot of participation today and some of the quieter folks put more out there to work with.

I had the same thought as DD, it definitely does seem like a family reunion of sorts. So many people I've had so much fun playing with in the past, all bundled up into 1 game. Just missing a few people, who will hopefully come back again =) It's going to make it tough though because a lot of you are really good at fooling me =/

Here ya go sweetpea...

It was probably more like....

"why the heck does jpap think my name is DON...?"

Maybe because you are...heehee

your hysterical...before you try and throw suspicion on me, check your facts.

1) I AM FEMALE

2) i am not quiet, ask anyone who has played prior, or talks to me.

3) I have played many of these games with hooked and Ice, to know, that something is wrong with Their play starting that way.

4) I am not trying to sway anyones opinion, If i was, it would have been more obvious, i was just stating my own opinion.

LOL speaking of Lady G, where is she?

Who Posted?
Total Posts: 105
User Name Posts
Hooked Newbie 16
IceH2O 14
rbishop 11
Cory Lover 10
Dangerdoll 9
johnlarson66 8
judgemax 7
ZSandmann 6
charlie_stubbs 5
LiveOutLoud 5
jpappy789 4
The Zigman 3
Lady G 3
Swayde 2
Reefscape 1
mee-mee 1

I find it odd that so many players have less than 5 posts.

Reefscape, charlie, and Mee-Mee. I'd really like to see some weasel kicking from ya'll tonight. At least point out your teammates to us before you UD.

So one quick question. Why are the few highlighting my name in bright colors. Is that a sign for some or just for me to be aware.....