Mafia #28: The Play

Lady G said:
Can you tell me what it is about John and Swayde that have you worried Z?? More then a "feeling"...as your feeling on Niko was wrong...
Click to expand...

Yes a feeling, and I will acknowledge that I was wrong about Niko. But also there were the Day 1 reasons I posted the other day. John seemed to be trying too hard on Day 1, giving us post counts and analysis when it didn't seem to be the right time. And now with 24 hour days it will be tougher to get good reads on people before the next Night falls. I really wish the first few days would have been 48 hours. Swayde I always suspect, but in particular the one liner posts and the way they post like five or more times in a row and then disappear.

LOL needs to post more. The early posts seemed scummy and now that they have been called them out they don't seem to post much at all. Newbies make me nervous because I don't know how they play and it seems most people like to give them a few days free pass, and choose to go after more veteran players.

IceH2O said:
The fact that JM didn't vote for Rb when she could have pushed him to the front for good and her lack of voting for me when thats who she wanted to vote for kind of seals the deal for me.

I can live with she didn't see RB as bad because I didn't either.But I still don't get why she thought a vote for me at the time of her vote would have been a waste. I would have placed my vote on who I thought was the mafia player, not on someone I wasn't sure of being mafia.

The rules don't say anything about the Don having investigations so its not really important to get the Don this game,as long as they are mafia we are good.

I know I said I'd vote RB for HN and DD but more and more I feel as though I have to vote JM based on my thoughts above

I retract off RB and vote to lynch JM. Either is a good vote IMO and I will go back to RB if not enough see JM as a threat.

Zig and Live, you need to start talking. Suspects and why you think so.

Z, I don't get why Sway and John are suspects to you and why JM isn't? Care to explain and help us see what you see?

Charlie who are your suspects, we know you voted LOL but that can't be the only person you are looking at.

We need to be right, its either 6-5 right now or 7-4. If there are only 4 mafia then we have a night we can be wrong. If its 6-5 then if we lynch wrong its game over.Hopefully someone was granted the DR role and they protect the correct person tonight from the hit. That would also buy us another day.
Click to expand...

Everyone is a suspect to me Ice, those were just my short list. Nothing has happened yet for me to have anyone leaning very strongly Innocent so I have a list of neutral players and ones I am leaning Mafia. LOL, Swayde, and John ones I am looking very closely at.
 
Hummm..

My thoughts:
I think, after fianlly reading and Getting up to date on the posts...
Ice, you've insinuated you were every role in the game at one time or another, which If I lived in a lynch happy society, I fly around town on my broom at midnight.. just making yourself look guilty as a joke? Mighty iffy. You have questions for everyone. always quick to point a finger, but not too good at defending yourself..so I think you are either the Detective, or the snitch, and right now, I'm thinkin snitch.

Judgemax, I think you're the don, or a patsy for the Don... Which might also be Ice.. Can Ice be the Don and the snitch?? you're awfully quick to claim your innocence...just because your a female doesn't mean you can't be the Don!! still not 100% trusting you either...

so far you two are the most suspicious to me..

I am looking at a few others too...
 
The Zigman said:
Hummm..

My thoughts:
I think, after fianlly reading and Getting up to date on the posts...
Ice, you've insinuated you were every role in the game at one time or another, which If I lived in a lynch happy society, I fly around town on my broom at midnight.. just making yourself look guilty as a joke? Mighty iffy. You have questions for everyone. always quick to point a finger, but not too good at defending yourself..so I think you are either the Detective, or the snitch, and right now, I'm thinkin snitch.

Judgemax, I think you're the don, or a patsy for the Don... Which might also be Ice.. Can Ice be the Don and the snitch?? you're awfully quick to claim your innocence...just because your a female doesn't mean you can't be the Don!! still not 100% trusting you either...

so far you two are the most suspicious to me..

I am looking at a few others too...
Click to expand...

where did i ever "claim my innocence", and where did i ever say i wasn't the don because i was female?..and ice?..the detective, ..nope, i have seen him play power roles many times, and he is not a good one this go round...
 
rbishop said:
That was pretty a prettysucky nightfall, late as it was. Sorry DD, but your posts were the best I had to go on for Day one.

Guess the UDs are becoming the most consitent thing in these games.

Not sure if I will be able toreview and poat before this early nightfall.

Best guess for now is......

I vote to Lynch Cory Lover...
Click to expand...

Hmm...I love your reasoning rb. Quite extensive.

I would love to hear your reasons, if you actually have any.



Top suspect:

rb-Well, if you vote for someone, at least give reasoning. When I was mafia, I'd try to give as little reasoning as possible, because I was afraid it wouldn't really add up to anything against that person. Last games you didn't post that much if I remember correctly, this game you are. Trying to appear more into the game? Trying to look like you are helping the town?

With that...I vote to lynch rb.

My vote isn't set in stone.
 
Thanks for you reply Z, I personally do not see anything with Swayde, and John well....he is always a feeling for me also. Anyway I was hoping there was a little more to it then that but at this point I suppose most is just a feeling.

Judge, I'm not sure what to think of you at this point....I really can see you saying you are the Don at the time you did and really being the Don, at the same time it was not a good move if you are.

Ice, I am still going back and forth with you. Really though aside from my thought of you being with the newbs I haven't seen anything to point at you. Except for DD and Hooked were both looking at you.

RB, I really want to say I think you are mafia...but as I have said earlier I am just not sure with you.

Zig and Live....I feel something is not right, but you are new and I don't know how you play yet, so I have my eye on you both at this point.

Cory, well nothing stands out to me with you either right now.

Z, haven't played with you in a while and trying to get re-use to you at this point...but most you have posted have been "feelings" and that gives me a slight uneasiness.

Charlie, you are scarce...I waiting for that weasel kicking you are so known for.

At this point the only one I have a strongest "case" against would be Judge...sorry you may of been joking, but I am more apt to believe it was a "fun" way for you to come out.

I vote to lynch Jmax - Subject to change at anytime, for any reason.
 
ZSandmann said:
Yes a feeling, and I will acknowledge that I was wrong about Niko. But also there were the Day 1 reasons I posted the other day. John seemed to be trying too hard on Day 1, giving us post counts and analysis when it didn't seem to be the right time.
Click to expand...

I posted my "Who Posted List" after Cory posted his "noting yet list". My list was after the game had been going for 24 hours. I was (and still am) suprised at the lack of posting. I also expected to see more role play. In no way do I see that I was "trying to hard". I also do not see how any of mine (or anyones) analysis is not at the right time. With that in mind, do you have any input on Cory Lover's "nothing yet list"? How can my post count be in question, but this list or his comments about HN and Ice (both mafia, or one mafia, or both innocent)?

I am okay with being a suspect, but I want to know why you do not have Cory Lover as a suspect.
 
Who Posted?
Total Posts: 387
User Name Posts
IceH2O 54
Hooked Newbie 46
rbishop 41
Lady G 39
ZSandmann 30
Dangerdoll 27
Cory Lover 24
Swayde 24
johnlarson66 22
judgemax 22
jpappy789 15
LiveOutLoud 14
The Zigman 10
mee-mee 10
charlie_stubbs 8
Reefscape 1

Here I am hiding in the middle again.
 
johnlarson66 said:
I posted my "Who Posted List" after Cory posted his "noting yet list". My list was after the game had been going for 24 hours. I was (and still am) suprised at the lack of posting. I also expected to see more role play. In no way do I see that I was "trying to hard". I also do not see how any of mine (or anyones) analysis is not at the right time. With that in mind, do you have any input on Cory Lover's "nothing yet list"? How can my post count be in question, but this list or his comments about HN and Ice (both mafia, or one mafia, or both innocent)?

I am okay with being a suspect, but I want to know why you do not have Cory Lover as a suspect.
Click to expand...

I do not get the big deal about the so called 'nothing yet' post. In previous games I make a list early, and about half the players I say 'nothing yet' or 'no read'. So what is the big deal about this one jl?

I truly did not have much to say about some of the players, but I decided to make a list anyways and comment on the ones I did have something to say about. If I just deleted the players from my list I had nothing to say about, then people would be very suspicious of that.
 
johnlarson66 said:
I posted my "Who Posted List" after Cory posted his "noting yet list". My list was after the game had been going for 24 hours. I was (and still am) suprised at the lack of posting. I also expected to see more role play. In no way do I see that I was "trying to hard". I also do not see how any of mine (or anyones) analysis is not at the right time. With that in mind, do you have any input on Cory Lover's "nothing yet list"? How can my post count be in question, but this list or his comments about HN and Ice (both mafia, or one mafia, or both innocent)?

I am okay with being a suspect, but I want to know why you do not have Cory Lover as a suspect.
Click to expand...

I do have my blond moments jl (no offense to any blondes out there), and I admit that. I did, if you recall, add more input about HN and Ice in my so called 'nothing yet' list.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom