Mafia 34-Time Crisis(the Play)

[Hooked Newbie]

Dawg how do you get that he was talking about 17 players that have posted so far from that quote?

Dawg I got 16 because he was counting the 3 on his team but not the sniper that is evil but not known to them.

Ice how do you KNOW that chill wasn't including the sniper? How do you come to the absolute conclusion that he automatically subtracted 3 from the overall list and forgot that the sniper was really on his side???...it was a nice find but it seems like you keep trying to push this without any clear proof.

Do I see some protection going on? Or is it backtracking by Ice?

This has been an interesting exchange. I'll go ahead and be the first to post a list. I don't care if anyone else does or not.

Lady G
Chill
Ice
Jpappy

 

[IceH2O]

So basically you are going on a hunch that chill accidentally slipped by revealing the number of his teammates because he misread a post and stated that there were less players than there are?

Misread what post? The post he quoted says 20 the list has 20 players on it.

Yes,I'm going on the assumption that he slipped.

You have something better to go on? Do us all a favor and point it out for us.

 

[jpappy789]

DD can still respond. She's saying the opposite of what I think. So, what up DD?

I understand...what really bothers me is that DD questions dawg for suspecting both Ice and Chill but she never takes a stand on the whole issue. Not even a word about the discussion going on.

 

[jpappy789]

Misread what post? The post he quoted says 20 the list has 20 players on it.

Yes,I'm going on the assumption that he slipped.

You have something better to go on? Do us all a favor and point it out for us.

He said that he made a mistake and said 17 instead of the 20 that was in Rb's post....I call that misreading...

No I don't have anything better but it's only been like 24 hours and we have another full day, which is why I am not liking this "chill is a terrorist" thing based on your assumption.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

Well Dawg this one is a team game and the dynamics will probably be different. Group votes should be interesting. I expect there will be some teaming up. If I am lynched it will be good to remember who jumped on this when I turn up innocent.

Silly to claim innocence this early.

I don't know he wasn't counting the sniper. I hope if he is a terrorist that he was so its 1 less person to have to look for. I was just going by numbers that a total of 3 terrorist plus a turn wouldn't be enough versus a SWAT team and Dr. I guess I automatically see this stuff from a modding viewpoint.

So is claiming from a modding standpoint.

So basically you are going on a hunch that chill accidentally slipped by revealing the number of his teammates because he misread a post and stated that there were less players than there are?

Why so fervent in defending Chill? Hunches are pretty much it on day one and I'd argue that they're valuable throughout the game. Being able to "make a case" is usually a byproduct of following a hunch and reviewing.

I retract my vote for Lady G and vote to lynch either Chill or Jpappy...

 

[OgreMkV]

Do I see some protection going on? Or is it backtracking by Ice?

This has been an interesting exchange. I'll go ahead and be the first to post a list. I don't care if anyone else does or not.

Lady G
Chill
Ice
Jpappy

I'm not sure about G and I would add Dawg and DD to that list. Keeping in mind that there are two teams as well. It could easily be team vs. team at this point... but I doubt it.

I understand...what really bothers me is that DD questions dawg for suspecting both Ice and Chill but she never takes a stand on the whole issue. Not even a word about the discussion going on.

Agreed... DD is slippery like that though... (man, I so want to add a risque joke here, but I'm trying to be a gentleman.)

 

[Chill]

Misread what post? The post he quoted says 20 the list has 20 players on it.

Yes,I'm going on the assumption that he slipped.

You have something better to go on? Do us all a favor and point it out for us.

You know the only flaw in this logic is that a 3 person terrorist team doesn't seem big enough.

It would be a good plan for the terrorist team to jump on a mistake and make it look like more than it is.

 

[jpappy789]

Silly to claim innocence this early.



So is claiming from a modding standpoint.



Why so fervent in defending Chill? Hunches are pretty much it on day one and I'd argue that they're valuable throughout the game. Being able to "make a case" is usually a byproduct of following a hunch and reviewing.

I retract my vote for Lady G and vote to lynch either Chill or Jpappy...

This probably doesn't mean much to you but I am not defending chill just not agreeing with Ice's hunches...I agree with your thoughts on how day one works but IMO Ice's is a stretch. As I said earlier unless chill trips up later I am treating this as a mistake. Right now I am more interested in how DD will answer my and orge's questions

 

[jpappy789]

I'm not sure about G and I would add Dawg and DD to that list. Keeping in mind that there are two teams as well. It could easily be team vs. team at this point... but I doubt it.



Agreed... DD is slippery like that though... (man, I so want to add a risque joke here, but I'm trying to be a gentleman.)

Ogre, what do you mean by "two teams"... terrorist vs. terrorists or citizens vs. terrorists...unless I missed something really important its all one big team of terrorist with a lone sniper

 

[IceH2O]

No not sure where I came up with the number but that wasn't it.

He said that he made a mistake and said 17 instead of the 20 that was in Rb's post....I call that misreading...

No I don't have anything better but it's only been like 24 hours and we have another full day, which is why I am not liking this "chill is a terrorist" thing based on your assumption.

Hmmm... I don't see where he says he misread a post, he says he doesn't know where the number came from.

We might have 24 hours but I'll be asleep and at work for at least 20-22 of those hrs depending on when I get home from work so I don't have the luxury to wait. If I get home in time, I better, and Chill shows me something different or someone else finds something better then my vote will change but for now this is the best suspect I have.