Mafia 34-Time Crisis(the Play)

[dirtydawg10]

Silly to claim innocence this early.



So is claiming from a modding standpoint.



Why so fervent in defending Chill? Hunches are pretty much it on day one and I'd argue that they're valuable throughout the game. Being able to "make a case" is usually a byproduct of following a hunch and reviewing.

I retract my vote for Lady G and vote to lynch either Chill or Jpappy...

DD seems to almost be defending Ice too, although it is in a more round about way than Jpappy. DD what are your thoughts on Ice and why do you feel it to be a stretch that he could be evil because he questioned Chill? HN, what are your thoughts on DD at this point?

 

[jpappy789]

The terrorist can probably read and count. I'm not sure how my inability to do either makes me guilty but thanks for the response. It seems 4 is your answer to either 17 or 20 anyway.

I was going off of this post were he says he cant read or count...

 

[IceH2O]

You know the only flaw in this logic is that a 3 person terrorist team doesn't seem big enough.

It would be a good plan for the terrorist team to jump on a mistake and make it look like more than it is.

Its a 3 team terrorist with the possibility of becoming 5 with the turn and if they find the sniper to communicate with. I don't see it as being 3 total, just not enough IMO.

Sorry I just can't see where you pulled 17 players out of the air the way you did.You can't even tell us why you chose 17 players lol how am I supposed to figure out how you came to that number?

Ogre, what do you mean by "two teams"... terrorist vs. terrorists or citizens vs. terrorists...unless I missed something really important its all one big team of terrorist with a lone sniper

Its the Terrorist team/Sniper vs the Swat team/DR and the rest are innocents.

 

[Dangerdoll]

So you think that Ice could definitely NOT be a terrorist because he questioned Chill?

absolutely not.... I was asking Dawg why he had both Chill and Ice on his radar. I took him having chill on his radar for having his numbers screwed up and that he was busted with it by Ice.... but I was and still am unsure why he had ice on his radar.... or was it because Ice picked up on the numbers in the first place (I think that's what the explanation was).... which makes more sense to me? Chill slipping does.... I do find it odd that he would find Ice on his radar for knowing the numbers but do I believe it makes Ice in the clear, not on your life. I know Ice is a better player than that...

I understand...what really bothers me is that DD questions dawg for suspecting both Ice and Chill but she never takes a stand on the whole issue. Not even a word about the discussion going on.

I stepped away from the PC... sorry. As far as who I am most suspecting at the moment, well II would have to say it's you, pap.... not sure why it seems that you have some kind of target on me or maybe you just missed your afternoon tea... *shrugs*

 

[jpappy789]

Its a 3 team terrorist with the possibility of becoming 5 with the turn and if they find the sniper to communicate with. I don't see it as being 3 total, just not enough IMO.

Sorry I just can't see where you pulled 17 players out of the air the way you did.You can't even tell us why you chose 17 players lol how am I supposed to figure out how you came to that number?



Its the Terrorist team/Sniper vs the Swat team/DR and the rest are innocents.

Oh duh, I forgot about the swat team:duh:

 

[Dangerdoll]

while I'm at it, I think I will place my vote......

I vote to lynch pappy

not an OMGUS vote in the least, I am voting pap for the odd persistence I feel from him that has come out of nowhere. This is subject to change.

 

[jpappy789]

absolutely not.... I was asking Dawg why he had both Chill and Ice on his radar. I took him having chill on his radar for having his numbers screwed up and that he was busted with it by Ice.... but I was and still am unsure why he had ice on his radar.... or was it because Ice picked up on the numbers in the first place (I think that's what the explanation was).... which makes more sense to me? Chill slipping does.... I do find it odd that he would find Ice on his radar for knowing the numbers but do I believe it makes Ice in the clear, not on your life. I know Ice is a better player than that...


I stepped away from the PC... sorry. As far as who I am most suspecting at the moment, well II would have to say it's you, pap.... not sure why it seems that you have some kind of target on me or maybe you just missed your afternoon tea... *shrugs*

this makes no sense...you asked dawg why he put ice on his list when ice found chills mistake...but you dont think it makes him necessarily innocent...why ask dawg then?

well it's obviously not just me who found your quick question odd or slightly suspicious as ogre commented on it as well

 

[jpappy789]

while I'm at it, I think I will place my vote......

I vote to lynch pappy

not an OMGUS vote in the least, I am voting pap for the odd persistence I feel from him that has come out of nowhere. This is subject to change.

LOL odd persistence? thats a new one...:grinyes:

 

[Chill]

My first concern with RB's post was not the number of players. It was the idea that if we didn't vote anyone we would in effect extend Day 1 and learn nothing. I'm not big on lynching innocents to gain information. The number of players was secondary because to even entertain the thought, or more likely to argue against it, I would like to know the odds. To do that I was trying to figure out how many bad guys there are. If you review last game I also posted questions about odds and objections to lynching innocents. If you want to lynch me for this I can't stop you but you should keep an open mind to other possibilities that might arise between now and nightfall.

 

[Dangerdoll]

this makes no sense...you asked dawg why he put ice on his list when ice found chills mistake...but you dont think it makes him necessarily innocent...why ask dawg then?

well it's obviously not just me who found your quick question odd or slightly suspicious as ogre commented on it as well

I asked Dawg because he didn't give explnations and I am trying to see if peoples reasonings are making sense to me. Dawg mentioned Chills being on his radar but not Ice's at that post.

Ogre commented on it pappy, because you provoked him to.