Mafia #44 Christmas At ACville
- Thread starter Rbishop
- Start date
You were innocent and killed by the Grinch. It's interesting because innocents don't usually root for the Mafia to win. Sorry to see you go...I think?
This night was crazy. I think of all the votes on 3L Noodles is most suspect. It put 3L in the lead. Also the fresher footprints in the snow could be a clue. This along w/my previous thoughts about Noodles is enough to warrant a vote.
I vote to lynch Noodles
I vote to lynch Noodles
Ummm Eddie, you were not lynched by the town tonight. The Grinch put a hit on you as Dawg has stated.
johnlarson66
These Pandas Rock
Just a quick sneak and a chance to post. Don't worry I work all day tomorrow and will be able to post lots.
I am glad 3L showed up and voted. I really think it got to a point where there was really no choice, but to vote for 3L. Him showing up and not UDing was good for the town. I will not hold voting for 3L against anyone. I moved my vote on him and really had no idea what to do if he did not show up.
While noods and DD are both good suspects. I want to turn to the two remaining noobs. They both came out guns blazing, both seemed on some sort of mission and both seemed to play with only one person they were focused on. The fact that one of them was on me, right from the start is of concern to me. I also highly suspect the other one.
My top two suspects are pig and V2K. I think one of the two (if not both) are evil. I can understand the reasons why V2K could not be, but rb has in the past made slight changes due to circumstances. To stay away from that debate, I will vote for the pig.
I vote to lynch piggy67
I am more than willing to talk about noods and DD. I hope others talk about them, the noobs and whatever else that pops up (including me).
I am glad 3L showed up and voted. I really think it got to a point where there was really no choice, but to vote for 3L. Him showing up and not UDing was good for the town. I will not hold voting for 3L against anyone. I moved my vote on him and really had no idea what to do if he did not show up.
While noods and DD are both good suspects. I want to turn to the two remaining noobs. They both came out guns blazing, both seemed on some sort of mission and both seemed to play with only one person they were focused on. The fact that one of them was on me, right from the start is of concern to me. I also highly suspect the other one.
My top two suspects are pig and V2K. I think one of the two (if not both) are evil. I can understand the reasons why V2K could not be, but rb has in the past made slight changes due to circumstances. To stay away from that debate, I will vote for the pig.
I vote to lynch piggy67
I am more than willing to talk about noods and DD. I hope others talk about them, the noobs and whatever else that pops up (including me).
First off tonight sucked, Eddie I must say that early on you really looked coached and if you dont get a sour taste from this first game I would love to play with you again. Now on to buisness.
First lets look at the way votes finally fell. Ok as we see T3L Caught the major windfall of their actions on the last minute joining the game and voting. I believe only 1 mafia joined in on the lynching of T3l and I believe that because the mafia knew that was a sinking ship as soon as he showed up. they let the town do the job for them.
Now lets look at my next big thing. here we have what I feel is a major tell on the part of these 2 folks i just quoted. As we see they both voted for the same person for the first night. Then they come out after nightfall and jump right back to gunning for noodles. Now this is what I get from this, and its that these 2 are a communicating pair. Now I do not know for 100% that its the evil pair because I feel plant of all people would be a better vet than that to slip up like that but... who knows.
All I know is that I'm going back to look harder at these 2.
First lets look at the way votes finally fell. Ok as we see T3L Caught the major windfall of their actions on the last minute joining the game and voting. I believe only 1 mafia joined in on the lynching of T3l and I believe that because the mafia knew that was a sinking ship as soon as he showed up. they let the town do the job for them.
Now lets look at my next big thing. here we have what I feel is a major tell on the part of these 2 folks i just quoted. As we see they both voted for the same person for the first night. Then they come out after nightfall and jump right back to gunning for noodles. Now this is what I get from this, and its that these 2 are a communicating pair. Now I do not know for 100% that its the evil pair because I feel plant of all people would be a better vet than that to slip up like that but... who knows.
All I know is that I'm going back to look harder at these 2.
Hmmm I was sure that at least one of the two innocents lost last night was evil. But I guess 3l was gone either way and eddie was going to be close to tops today. So I agree with jl that a vote for 3l last night doesn't prove anything in my book.
Right now piggy, DD, and noods top my list.
To respond to DD...questioning excuses is valid but you just kept going and going. That's over the top to me.
I wish I could go back and respond to more things but multi quoting on an itouch is too hard...tomorrow then
Right now piggy, DD, and noods top my list.
To respond to DD...questioning excuses is valid but you just kept going and going. That's over the top to me.
I wish I could go back and respond to more things but multi quoting on an itouch is too hard...tomorrow then
Last post. I know I wasnt lynched by the town because you guys "Spared" me for one night. I would of been this time around because you guys had no faith. You would of messed up massively just admit it. Im still rooting for the Grinch and the Evils!! Because well nobody believed me so GO GRINCH GO!!!
A few things from yesterday that caught my eye...
Noodles, this quote below bothers me somewhat. That you justify your vote, based on the fact that JL popped onto my radar seems a little scummy. It looks like a possible mafia attempt to lay blame at someone else's feet, should the lynch go badly for the town.
---------------------------
JL, you really surprised me yesterday. You seemingly did something that I don't ever recall you doing. It appears that you switched votes in an attempt to save yourself from the lynch block.
In this earlier quote you note that 3L is a possibly decent lynch candidate, but at the same time a possible UD also. Because of this, in your opinion, he's not really worthy of your vote. Makes sense to me.
This is a post after a few votes came your way.
Now here's your vote change to 3L. I believe that it came at a time when you were very close in votes (if not tied) with 3L. When others might have been considering getting off 3L because it looked like he may not show, you were getting on...apparently to make sure that 3L did UD, in your words. Looks like a complete reversal on your earlier thought re: 3L, and a clear attempt to save yourself.
I've seen lots of players vote to save themselves, but you're not one of them. Pretty sure I've seen you take a lynching in past games, even when you've had similar opportunity to save yourself. What gives?
-----------------------------
DD, I find this new 'taskmaster' attitude you've taken for this game to be quite unusual for you. I've played quite a few games with you... some you've been really involved, and others not so much.
Seems like with you, this game, that people are darned if they give excuses ahead of time, and darned if they don't. This puzzles me, as you've been at both ends of the spectrum in games, and your involvement doesn't normally seem to hinge on the role you've been assigned.
I'm concerned that you've found lots of time this wave to play this wave, and figure that you'll use it to toss some scum on those with less time.
Noodles, this quote below bothers me somewhat. That you justify your vote, based on the fact that JL popped onto my radar seems a little scummy. It looks like a possible mafia attempt to lay blame at someone else's feet, should the lynch go badly for the town.
---------------------------
JL, you really surprised me yesterday. You seemingly did something that I don't ever recall you doing. It appears that you switched votes in an attempt to save yourself from the lynch block.
In this earlier quote you note that 3L is a possibly decent lynch candidate, but at the same time a possible UD also. Because of this, in your opinion, he's not really worthy of your vote. Makes sense to me.
This is a post after a few votes came your way.
Now here's your vote change to 3L. I believe that it came at a time when you were very close in votes (if not tied) with 3L. When others might have been considering getting off 3L because it looked like he may not show, you were getting on...apparently to make sure that 3L did UD, in your words. Looks like a complete reversal on your earlier thought re: 3L, and a clear attempt to save yourself.
I've seen lots of players vote to save themselves, but you're not one of them. Pretty sure I've seen you take a lynching in past games, even when you've had similar opportunity to save yourself. What gives?
-----------------------------
DD, I find this new 'taskmaster' attitude you've taken for this game to be quite unusual for you. I've played quite a few games with you... some you've been really involved, and others not so much.
Seems like with you, this game, that people are darned if they give excuses ahead of time, and darned if they don't. This puzzles me, as you've been at both ends of the spectrum in games, and your involvement doesn't normally seem to hinge on the role you've been assigned.
I'm concerned that you've found lots of time this wave to play this wave, and figure that you'll use it to toss some scum on those with less time.
Interesting night. DD is peaking my radar right now. I seem to remember a few past games when she was evil, she tends to come up with some fairly strained reasons to explain peoples actions. As DD said, it would be pretty easy for the grinch to say, ok, we're going to hit eddie, you really get on him so when he turns up innocent it will just look like two innocents attacking each other because they don't know any better. Especially with the whole motocross thing...come on, does it really matter?
As far as eddie and TL being gone...neither of them were particularly helpful, so while it sucks as far as the numbers go, I don't think we're out any real profound analysis.
As far as eddie and TL being gone...neither of them were particularly helpful, so while it sucks as far as the numbers go, I don't think we're out any real profound analysis.
I really see no reason why being the third one on is such a tell tale sign - again why I defended/justified my vote....
not sure if that answers you satisfactorily or not but I just shortly woke up and need to get my coffee......more in a bit.
