Mafia #44 Christmas At ACville

[Dangerdoll]

I called it not really townie like because of the excuse of "just to bring me in the race".... why wouldn't you elaborate "for the town". The statement is too wide.

your vote carries weight, sure... but your validity, light as a feather.

 

[johnlarson66]

I retract my vote on piggy67 and vote to lynch noodles.

The main reason I am doing this is becuase I don't want to just limit my suspects to noobs. While I think there is at least one noob as evil, I don't know that for a fact. The noobs are playing just like noobs play.

Noodles was hot and heavy there for a bit. She got a little heat and has been gone. I am sure if there are a few more votes on her she will squirm. Even when she had two votes she was pretty dramatic. Her attempts to blend in and not take responsiblity or ownership of her votes is of concern to me.

I go back and forth about cat. I think he is attempting to be helpful. Now is that becuase he really is mafia, I am not sure. I am willing to give cat a pass at this time.

I need to keep in mind that besides the three communicating evils, there are three communicating innocents. They might not be able to investigate, but they are able to trust each other. They each know of two other confirmed innocents. That is like two investigations right off the bat.

Just as a noob could be an evil, a noob could be part of this bunch.

 

[Sploke]

Interesting night. DD is peaking my radar right now. I seem to remember a few past games when she was evil, she tends to come up with some fairly strained reasons to explain peoples actions. As DD said, it would be pretty easy for the grinch to say, ok, we're going to hit eddie, you really get on him so when he turns up innocent it will just look like two innocents attacking each other because they don't know any better. Especially with the whole motocross thing...come on, does it really matter?

As far as eddie and TL being gone...neither of them were particularly helpful, so while it sucks as far as the numbers go, I don't think we're out any real profound analysis.

I called it not really townie like because of the excuse of "just to bring me in the race".... why wouldn't you elaborate "for the town". The statement is too wide.

your vote carries weight, sure... but your validity, light as a feather.

Above is what I had posted yesterday about you. As I said - It looked this morning like the votes were going to add up between noodles and piggy - I obviously have some suspicion about you, and I was hoping that putting a vote on you and making a three way tie would instigate some discussion about it. Unfortunately there hasn't been much action today so not as much is coming from it as I had hoped.

You have also played enough games to know that making a hit on a noob like Eddie, especially a noob that was next in line for the chopping block would look like a mistake easily contributed to inexperience on the grinch side and could use this as an advantage to throw off suspicions.

 

[Dangerdoll]

Above is what I had posted yesterday about you. As I said - It looked this morning like the votes were going to add up between noodles and piggy - I obviously have some suspicion about you, and I was hoping that putting a vote on you and making a three way tie would instigate some discussion about it. Unfortunately there hasn't been much action today so not as much is coming from it as I had hoped.

You have also played enough games to know that making a hit on a noob like Eddie, especially a noob that was next in line for the chopping block would look like a mistake easily contributed to inexperience on the grinch side and could use this as an advantage to throw off suspicions.

me being on people's suspect lists is no news to me, sploke.... I already know that... I already know what you were doing so not sure why you feel the extra explanation is needed. Could it be that maybe you indeed are Mafia and that is to clue in the noncommunicating elf?

You're right, I have been in enough games to know that but as you already know, when I have been evil, I have already used that move so it's not a big brilliant edge of your seat strategy to me.... nor would I use the same tactic over and over and over...

I don't know why you keep pushing on me sploke... but in doing so, if you are mafia, it seems like you sure are lettin a lot of the secrets out... better be careful. Maybe you have too much Wii on the brain.

 

[johnlarson66]

game off///

Looks like it is a normally Monday, I will not be around for the rest of the day. It will be close to mid-night before I will be able to be on a computer.

I am not real happy about the circumstances of my short notice departure, but stuff happens.

I will keep glancing at the thread, while packing, until I have to leave.

game on///

 

[Sploke]

not at all, sploke. Not sure I understand the reasoning...

I called it not really townie like because of the excuse of "just to bring me in the race".... why wouldn't you elaborate "for the town". The statement is too wide.

me being on people's suspect lists is no news to me, sploke.... I already know that... I already know what you were doing so not sure why you feel the extra explanation is needed.

Well, which is it? You either wanted more explanation, or you already had everything figured out and didn't need it explained...

 

[Dangerdoll]

Well, which is it? You either wanted more explanation, or you already had everything figured out and didn't need it explained...

odd post number from you...

sploke, after hearing hardly a peep from you in days, you come in and pick someone off the wall to poke at, from what I have noticed from you today is that you have come on here and continue to provoke responses out of me, much like pappy accused me of doing... I wonder what he thinks of it...

Further, I never asked for more explanation, you volunteered it... You asked me what I felt about it, I merely pointed out that I didn't understand your reasoning or understood why you wouldn't come out and make a more explanatory post for the town BUT also said that I didn't want to continually be accused of "taking things out of proportion", much as you seem to be doing now. Did you miss that post? As a matter of fact, I believe my posts in response to you have been consistent and fair, it seems like someone is trying to twist things to make it seem he's been in the game the entire time...

 

[jpappy789]

I think that those are valid arguments, but they did hit him. So why? I think that it did create confusion, as we had to figure out who to go after, and thus wasted part of our day. We also spend time looking for reasons as to his hit (like I seem to en doing) and wasting time. It makes sense to me, anyway.

'nite.

I chalk it up to inexperience on the evil side. Eddie was pretty much a goner today and when he showed up innocent I would say DD would have been a very good choice for tomorrow. If she were innocent that would put us down 6 (with the hits) and 5 if she was actually an elf. From a numbers stand point I cannot see a logical reason why Eddie was hit. They left today wide open for discussion and the chance to find one of them, them being the evils, which is a very good thing.

Alright..this is what i meant.
In my experience from other investigation,this can only be the cleverness and mischievousness of a evil elf trying to trick the brain of other.
For this i just got you on my list as my top suspect,after is catfish.

"Out of my last 53 cases 49 have been given full credit to the police and the rest to me"Sherlock Holmes
The evil ones are the ones who opens their mouth and bring themselves captured.

the polices are the elfs.

I don't see any help in this kind of posting. Please post reasons with your assumptions rather than guess wildly at who people may be.

so Jl,tring to put me back into the spot light,imo that's a good way to take the heat off you by pointing my way,but that's ok.

Piggy you have been in the spotlight since day one. You don't need JL's help with that. And I am curious as to why you think JL is "taking the hest off him"...he isn't on the chopping block...

from what I can see so far, I would have to say v, piggy, paps, and cat have my attention...
V - because of as mentioned, he is all over the place. Call it noob, I call it suspicious.

piggy, VERY confrontational and also, all over the place...

paps, I just cant seem to figure why you are poking at me as much as you are, accusing me of the very things you are doing to me.... and then you still won't drop things. I can't answer you because you won't accept any explanation I give you, or rather you do, but you seem to twist it into some kind of magical manipulating theory of how I am trying to wing things. I have news for ya, and I am sure lots of others already are aware of this, I don't put that much thought into the game.

and finally cat... for the host of reasons that have already been explained.

Out of these 4 people, I really am on the fence of who to vote for..... I need to see more, to feel what is most damaging..... every time I want to go one way, I see something new...

I also want to note on Sploke and Plants light posting habit. Makes me very uncomfortable as I am used to seeing a lot more from both of them.... Hooked, I understand he was involved with considerable RL issues.... now, I hear sploke with Wii... ok.... how about you plant?

(yes, pap.... I seem to be letting people off easy on their absence excuses... care to dagger me now or would you rather do it slowly?)

game off,hey guy's this is a blast,i agree with cat,addicting!!!game on.ok,i'm catching on how to spot discrepancies(ie,slips)in your posts,also i have yet to figure out how to do the multiple post in a post thing,you guy's can drill me on why i haven't backed up my thought's with quotes,but that's why.Im not tring to play the newb card or give excusses, I AM LEARNING, sooo all you evil's beware!!!!!

So after it's already been explained earlier you decide to skip over it and use the excuse now? Sorry, but you've been given a pass day one and now it's time to step up to the plate. I'm sure you will call me evil for saying this.

I vote to lynch noodles

Call it jumping on a train or whatever, but I would like to get a better read on both piggy and DD before going through with a vote. Virt is still up there but I am not sure if the whole list thing was a tactic to appear helpful or just a noobie thing to do (I am thinking the latter) Hopefully I will be online later but I wanted to have a vote in.

 

[Sploke]

I'll admit I was quiet over the weekend..strangely enough I have more time to get online at work in my office than I do at home, especially this time of year. so sue me for trying to get back into the game now that i have the time.

i'm leaving work in a few minutes and won't be able to get back online until about 10-11pm probably, but i'm comfortable with my vote where it is.

 

[piggy67]

I chalk it up to inexperience on the evil side. Eddie was pretty much a goner today and when he showed up innocent I would say DD would have been a very good choice for tomorrow. If she were innocent that would put us down 6 (with the hits) and 5 if she was actually an elf. From a numbers stand point I cannot see a logical reason why Eddie was hit. They left today wide open for discussion and the chance to find one of them, them being the evils, which is a very good thing.







I don't see any help in this kind of posting. Please post reasons with your assumptions rather than guess wildly at who people may be.



Piggy you have been in the spotlight since day one. You don't need JL's help with that. And I am curious as to why you think JL is "taking the hest off him"...he isn't on the chopping block...

the spot light is where i prefer to be.so every body can see who or what i am, or am not.





So after it's already been explained earlier you decide to skip over it and use the excuse now? Sorry, but you've been given a pass day one and now it's time to step up to the plate. I'm sure you will call me evil for saying this.
I was given a pass from day one,who gave me this pass?is that like a get out of jail free?and do you mean i was passed up by you for the hit on eddie?
I vote to lynch noodles

Call it jumping on a train or whatever, but I would like to get a better read on both piggy and DD before going through with a vote. Virt is still up there but I am not sure if the whole list thing was a tactic to appear helpful or just a noobie thing to do (I am thinking the latter) Hopefully I will be online later but I wanted to have a vote in.

at this point i still vote to lynch DD