Mafia #44 Christmas At ACville

Sorry my bad her first night Investigation is what proved something to me. It should prove something to all of you if you go back and look.
 
dirtydawg10 said:
I'm not trying to stir anything up. Vote for me if you like. You were the one pressing Cat to reveal information when he wasn't comfortable doing so. The reveal worked because RB confirmed it. Your plan was for the person who received the gift to confirm it. I like the way things worked out. I also think you seem very opposed to Cat's list. It could be because you are #2 on his list. It seems you are #2 on several people's lists.



If DD knew something about me I'm sure she would have voted for me. You said you are going back to see where she implied she investigated Piggy. I don't think DD would imply that because she would know she would be the mafia's next hit. Look all you want Plant. I'm not hiding anything but I think you are.

Why are you not voting for Piggy? You may be better off in this game if you just take one of your own out in the lynch. Then you will be less suspicious. C'mon, Plant. Vote with DD (Santa) and lynch one of your own. Vote for Piggy.
Click to expand...
As I recall last game RB did not name the recipient of the presents last year. Mad had to ask Grins on the thread why she didn't open the present. Maybe RB changed it because Cat pm'd him about some concerns. I'm glad it worked out as well.

If Piggy is evil and on a team she is on yours. Are you and JL using her as your sacrificial lamb? Is that why you want them to get lynched so you can say aha, we were first? And about the research on DD I did find some interesting posts between you two.
 
plantling said:
As I recall last game RB did not name the recipient of the presents last year. Mad had to ask Grins on the thread why she didn't open the present. Maybe RB changed it because Cat pm'd him about some concerns. I'm glad it worked out as well.

If Piggy is evil and on a team she is on yours. Are you and JL using her as your sacrificial lamb? Is that why you want them to get lynched so you can say aha, we were first? And about the research on DD I did find some interesting posts between you two.
Click to expand...

Yet you still hesitate to vote for me. C'mon, Piggy voted for me. Why don't you make it easy and vote for me too.
 
Planting, take a break. You are killing yourself. Just open the present and join the rest of the innocents. Your squirming like it is nightfall and you have no votes.

I am glad you have given to the fact piggy is evil. Really, you should let piggy play another day and you should hang in his place. It was your advice that got him lynched.
 
After night Dawg comes out with his DD theory and Noodles has taken 2nd place.
dirtydawg10 said:
Well...here's my thoughts on Eddie being hit. It seems to me it would be for one of two reasons. Since DD seems to have had the most interaction with him as of late it was to either set her up or to take her off the radar. If she is evil I can easily see her hitting Eddie so the excuse can be "Do you think I would be that dumb to hit Eddie when I was the one arguing with him". On the other hand if she is innocent it may be a good way to get more heat on DD. Since Eddie already had the heat on him for day two I'm leaning more with DD being evil but I'll just have to wait and see what happens.

Oh yeah...Noods is running a close second for me.
Click to expand...

DD asks him about it...
Dangerdoll said:
curious dawg, with eddie being hit out, I can clearly see (obvious of course to me) that the mafia has tried to set things up. With this thought, hitting eddie and knowing I was the hottest on him, there they go, they think they will have the rest of the innocents on my back, in essence, they tried to set me up.... they will automatically again, take out two more innocents next nightfall.... I am curious as to why you feel the other way... that it makes me more mafia than innocent.
Click to expand...
He says he didn't vote for he because he's not sure but can totally see her setting things up.
dirtydawg10 said:
I already said what you are saying in my post. I actually said I'm not sure but I can see you being tricky like that. Of course it is easy for you to know what you are but it is not so easy for the rest of us. I didn't vote for you because I'm not sure but I can totally see you setting this up to clear yourself. That's why I feel you are more mafia than innocent. I am still teetering on the fence though I am leaning a little to one side.
Click to expand...
He wouldn't vote first but he would vote at the end of the train. The votes ended up being Piggy, Sploke, JP, and Dawg. I think he planted the seed and let it grow then jumped on.

dirtydawg10 said:
Yet you still hesitate to vote for me. C'mon, Piggy voted for me. Why don't you make it easy and vote for me too.
Click to expand...
I will most likely vote either you or JL. He's on your list as a maybe and I think he has all game long. It's a good idea to put your buddies on your list in case one of u gets lynched, eh?

Off to go look for JL's posts.
 
plantling said:
After night Dawg comes out with his DD theory and Noodles has taken 2nd place.


DD asks him about it...

He says he didn't vote for he because he's not sure but can totally see her setting things up.

He wouldn't vote first but he would vote at the end of the train. The votes ended up being Piggy, Sploke, JP, and Dawg. I think he planted the seed and let it grow then jumped on.


I will most likely vote either you or JL. He's on your list as a maybe and I think he has all game long. It's a good idea to put your buddies on your list in case one of u gets lynched, eh?

Off to go look for JL's posts.
Click to expand...

Yet you still hesitate to vote for me. PLANTing some seeds as you say? Are you waiting to jump on after someone else besides just Piggy has voted for me?
 
G/O **I've been in and out of the Dr's office all day. I failed a glucose test today, and now have to go back for a level 2 tomorrow, but that means that I have to take off work because it's a 3 hour test at the office. I also can't eat anything beforehand, and my tummy is too icky to eat now, so I'm starving. Taking off work means that I have to write sub plans, which means that I have a ton of work to do tonight. I've read up as best I can, and will post a few thoughts and a vote, then you probably won't see me until Thursday. The only good part of my day was that I heard my baby girl's heartbeat, again! Love that sound! ** G/O
 
1) I am willing to go with Cat. No reason not to believe him, and several convincing arguments that he is the real deal.

2) I still think Piggy is evil. Even after Cat's innocence was basically proven, he "mis-posts" and votes him (I think), then recants. I am more than happy to vote piggy again.

3) I am slightly upset that JL has me on his top 3, and only because Plant asked where I was. Seems silly to me, but not neccessarily evil.

4) Plantling, I think, is innocent. She beat the present thing to death, and then threw Cat under the proverbial bus. I don't know that a mafia would take the chance of being wrong on this score, then getting called out on it later.

5) Dawg - feels evil to me. Again, the wierd reasoning around Cat's revelation. I think it's good to question things, but I also think that there were good reasons to go with Cat.

6) I vote to lynch Piggy.

I'll try to keep up with anything new tonight until I crash in about 30ish minutes.

Again, apologies for the sudden disappeareance today.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom