Mafia 52: Killer Comes A Courtin' (The Play)
- Thread starter ZSandmann
- Start date
Well jl and ice were busy over the evening. I don't trust either of them. They are both experts at this. Be very careful of them. I think at least one of them is scum.
Kashta I see as on the mafia. I think she is being told exactly what to do.
JM has added no real content and the DR thing still nags at me. Her posts just enough to try and make people think he is an active towns person.
Dope's drive by vote is worrisome but he has been around so little I just cant figure him.
Noodles I see as innocent right now. She has been awfully quiet though.
maverick I think is just feeling out the ropes I see nothing worrisome about him yet.
Bugz - the whinning is killing me. Please stop. if you want to get a disscusion going about other players then start one, stop telling us how all alone you are.
FD very odd play. Watch her.
I am not sure about anyone else are they even playing?
Kashta I see as on the mafia. I think she is being told exactly what to do.
JM has added no real content and the DR thing still nags at me. Her posts just enough to try and make people think he is an active towns person.
Dope's drive by vote is worrisome but he has been around so little I just cant figure him.
Noodles I see as innocent right now. She has been awfully quiet though.
maverick I think is just feeling out the ropes I see nothing worrisome about him yet.
Bugz - the whinning is killing me. Please stop. if you want to get a disscusion going about other players then start one, stop telling us how all alone you are.
FD very odd play. Watch her.
I am not sure about anyone else are they even playing?
While I tend to agree on the issue of involvement, the roles are typically picked at random. When you sign up to play, you do not get to pick which side you are on based on your RL schedule....JMO
Oh for God's sake! I had both you and DD on my list of suspects, DD seemed a bit more scummy due to her actions or lack there of. I had my vote where I thought it should it be. I made a wrong choice, as many of us did. Besides, you screaming to be lynched did/does not sit well with me.
Sorry if you do not agree with my decision, next time I will check with you first. Now can you stop asking me why I voted DD instead of you? Should I vote you today? Is that what you asking for? Get over it and start looking at all the options.
I personally would like to follow DD's advice and not focus on the little things such as "Pizza", but to evaluate everyone and try to come up with the best viable option.
Last night I would have ssaid yes, the begging to be lynched is certainly not mafia like especially to save a townie....tho the more she posted after nightfall the more my suspicions surfaced again.....
How can I not whine a little when people who signed up aren't even voting or contributing? The run in and vote then disappear thing really isn't helping flush out mafia. In fact, it is pretty distracting.
I went and reread everything over again from last night. I feel totally like a mouse being played with by two cats. I am not trusting Ice, JL, or Kash.
I agree with the Kash statement. I think JL said awhile ago he felt she was being coached by someone more experienced. I have watched her follow Jpap and then follow JL. The Ice thing is too obvious. She herself even knows that. If she were to go up for lynch tomorrow and turn up mafia, I still don't think that would clear Ice for me.
JM is still on my list.
FD is still on my list. As much as I do believe her little one is taking up her time, her waiting until nightfall two nights in a row is just
I think she might very well be mafia and being coached when and where to place votes. Dopehand: I don't even have enough info to make a judgement here. Likes to use big words I think to confuse people.
Well, let's see.....
Kashta - very possible mafia
Jm1212- leaning mafia, but all I really have is the doc question and posts not containing much content...
Dopehand - completely distrust the pop in and vote - almost like he was told where to vote....
Mav - not sure
TRS - not sure - not playing?
Agass - not sure - not playing?
FD- possible mafia, absolutely do not like the late votes on both nights and the lone vote on Kash when it obviously did not make a hill of beans. not buying the "not involved enough to be in a plot" excuse
Ice - ???
Rich - middle of the road but leaning mafia ATM
JL - ????
Of Ice and JL, I would venture to guess that one of them is mafia; which one? I have no idea...but I hope I can figure it out!
Today my vote will most likely go to FD or Kashta....with a possibility of Dopehand. Just cause he has not been playing much does not mean he was not given a mafia role.....we need to take out the mafia regardless of their participation level.
It really hurt losing both Dawg and DD in one night. With the mafia getting a hit each night our lynches need to be accurate.
Kashta - very possible mafia
Jm1212- leaning mafia, but all I really have is the doc question and posts not containing much content...
Dopehand - completely distrust the pop in and vote - almost like he was told where to vote....
Mav - not sure
TRS - not sure - not playing?
Agass - not sure - not playing?
FD- possible mafia, absolutely do not like the late votes on both nights and the lone vote on Kash when it obviously did not make a hill of beans. not buying the "not involved enough to be in a plot" excuse
Ice - ???
Rich - middle of the road but leaning mafia ATM
JL - ????
Of Ice and JL, I would venture to guess that one of them is mafia; which one? I have no idea...but I hope I can figure it out!
Today my vote will most likely go to FD or Kashta....with a possibility of Dopehand. Just cause he has not been playing much does not mean he was not given a mafia role.....we need to take out the mafia regardless of their participation level.
It really hurt losing both Dawg and DD in one night. With the mafia getting a hit each night our lynches need to be accurate.
I'll admit that I'm still rattled from what happened last night. And now having just read through a barrage of posts from Ice and JL that filled 5 full pages (wtf is with those two?)... good God, I can hardly think straight anymore after all that.
Anyway.. I'm still trying to sort it all out. So for now, this is where my impressions fall. I'll continue trying to reevaluate things as today goes on. If I notice something that changes, I'll point that out too.
Day 3 votes so far...
IceH2O - Mafia without a doubt in my mind.
Johnlarson - Leaning mafia the way he steers the boat so capably, but so far in the wrong direction. Having doubts about so many others, I trusted in his logic/judgement way too much.... beware.
Ice and JL work extremely well with each other to influence the town while appearing to be very separate at the same time. Need to keep watching how well they continue doing this... as I'm not the only one who's noticed it or been influenced by their lead. We are being led in certain ways by both of them and it's worked out badly for the town this far.
Both Ice and JL planted a few lukewarm suspicions my way until they both saw I agreed with them about DD.. also Luv and FD. Then they both backed down and left me alone.... neither of them pursuing me again, until I first suggested Ice might be mafia IF the mafia doesn't take him out of the game. That got a strong reaction from both of them at the time and I've been "highly suspected" by them ever since.
Other comments...
rich311k - Leaning mafia but not sure. Rich has defended Luvbugz twice already since nightfall last night and raised JL's suspicion over Dopehand up a notch... right after Dope pointed at Luvbugz. If Luv is mafia, then she's got a real strong ally in Rich. Rich and JL are also closely aligned. Still need to decide whether that's good or bad.
Luvbugz - Very suspicious, but too flaky to pin her down. She acted a lot like that while innocent in the first game we played. Wasn't bouncing around like this in the next game when she was connected with the mafia team. Her meltdown in this game may be annoying, but it's also the best argument in her favor as not being scum this time around.
FireDancer - Suspicious, and overly certain of herself for someone who's not really playing. Ironically, it's Ice's vote against her now that's the best reason for not suspecting her. Keep an eye on what Ice does in this regard as this could be a passing thing to distance them. DirtyDawg did warn us that if DD turns out innocent... then Ice is most likely mafia. Not ready to lean innocent with FD yet but it's possible. Keep watching this.
Dopehand - very suspicious.. in and out like a flash but yet not playing.
jm1212 - Rookie player still who tries to cover his butt over Dr. question but handled it poorly. Would have benefited a lot from coaching at that time if he'd had that from a mafia team. Hard to believe the Mafia team would be stupid enough to send in one of their own to ask about the Dr. like that. Leaning innocent for the moment for that reason, but he bears watching to see what he does next.
noodles62 - Extremely vocal as always but quite neutral, likely innocent. I don't see anything off at all. She's just very good at this, so it isn't really safe to take her without a grain of salt. Still not getting a read either way.... wish I could tell. Would really be nice to know for sure.
maverickbr77 - So completely neutral.... it's enough to forget he's even here. Mav is extremely good at this as I remember now from the last game.. makes him a little less than innocent than he may appear to be.
The Red Severum - disinterested, most likely innocent again.... He doesn't bother getting into this since nothing involves him this time.
Agassizii - Who the hell knows or even cares at this point.. wait and see. Will get to him later.
Anyway.. I'm still trying to sort it all out. So for now, this is where my impressions fall. I'll continue trying to reevaluate things as today goes on. If I notice something that changes, I'll point that out too.
Day 3 votes so far...
Ice - Kashta
Fire - Ice
Luv - JM
Dopehand - JL
Main players...Fire - Ice
Luv - JM
Dopehand - JL
IceH2O - Mafia without a doubt in my mind.
Johnlarson - Leaning mafia the way he steers the boat so capably, but so far in the wrong direction. Having doubts about so many others, I trusted in his logic/judgement way too much.... beware.
Ice and JL work extremely well with each other to influence the town while appearing to be very separate at the same time. Need to keep watching how well they continue doing this... as I'm not the only one who's noticed it or been influenced by their lead. We are being led in certain ways by both of them and it's worked out badly for the town this far.
Both Ice and JL planted a few lukewarm suspicions my way until they both saw I agreed with them about DD.. also Luv and FD. Then they both backed down and left me alone.... neither of them pursuing me again, until I first suggested Ice might be mafia IF the mafia doesn't take him out of the game. That got a strong reaction from both of them at the time and I've been "highly suspected" by them ever since.
Other comments...
rich311k - Leaning mafia but not sure. Rich has defended Luvbugz twice already since nightfall last night and raised JL's suspicion over Dopehand up a notch... right after Dope pointed at Luvbugz. If Luv is mafia, then she's got a real strong ally in Rich. Rich and JL are also closely aligned. Still need to decide whether that's good or bad.
Luvbugz - Very suspicious, but too flaky to pin her down. She acted a lot like that while innocent in the first game we played. Wasn't bouncing around like this in the next game when she was connected with the mafia team. Her meltdown in this game may be annoying, but it's also the best argument in her favor as not being scum this time around.
FireDancer - Suspicious, and overly certain of herself for someone who's not really playing. Ironically, it's Ice's vote against her now that's the best reason for not suspecting her. Keep an eye on what Ice does in this regard as this could be a passing thing to distance them. DirtyDawg did warn us that if DD turns out innocent... then Ice is most likely mafia. Not ready to lean innocent with FD yet but it's possible. Keep watching this.
Dopehand - very suspicious.. in and out like a flash but yet not playing.
jm1212 - Rookie player still who tries to cover his butt over Dr. question but handled it poorly. Would have benefited a lot from coaching at that time if he'd had that from a mafia team. Hard to believe the Mafia team would be stupid enough to send in one of their own to ask about the Dr. like that. Leaning innocent for the moment for that reason, but he bears watching to see what he does next.
noodles62 - Extremely vocal as always but quite neutral, likely innocent. I don't see anything off at all. She's just very good at this, so it isn't really safe to take her without a grain of salt. Still not getting a read either way.... wish I could tell. Would really be nice to know for sure.
maverickbr77 - So completely neutral.... it's enough to forget he's even here. Mav is extremely good at this as I remember now from the last game.. makes him a little less than innocent than he may appear to be.
The Red Severum - disinterested, most likely innocent again.... He doesn't bother getting into this since nothing involves him this time.
Agassizii - Who the hell knows or even cares at this point.. wait and see. Will get to him later.
