Mafia 52: Killer Comes A Courtin' (The Play)
- Thread starter ZSandmann
- Start date
Just reading up again, can't complain about most people not posting, its pretty awesome. But anyways, after reading, I think noodles is mafia, because of the way she thinks EVERYONE else is mafia. Don't you think there should be some innocents? Or do you want to put the blame on everyone else and not on you. I think kashta is a innocent for first time this game, and I have never been wrong on her. I also think ice knows this, and is why he voted for her, because he wants her out.
if you would care to go back and actually read my posts you would see that I do not think EVERYONE is mafia. I believe I named a possible 4-5 which is probly a pretty close number based on the fact that we have only managed to take one mafia out so far.
I have been thinking on the ice or jl thing. JL missed the first day, he then starts on DD and leads the attack. We all no that she was innocent. he has been pushing people randomly to try and get a bite or two. Right now he seems to be fixed on Dope who has hardly been in at all. I think we know who our mafia mastermind is.
Any opinions on my theory?
Any opinions on my theory?
Well, we could and I think have complained about you not posting. this is the fifth day into the game and what, your second insightful post?
And just how many games have you played that would justify your accurate instincts of kashta's role?
Also meant to add to my post above the point that mafia players don't take a direct route when going after townies they hope to lynch. What they do is more subtle than that.
For example... imagine now that I'm innocent and after sticking my neck out last night to vote Ice as mafia, see what has Ice done in response? I expected Ice to tear me to pieces after putting myself at risk like that (when I could've kept a low profile instead), but he didn't. Aside from merely including my name on his list of mafia suspects (thus far), Ice spent a good amount of time last night ignoring me and virtually all the other active players in the game. I can see why Ice didn't come after me directly.. why would he do that? It wouldn't make sense. But what he's doing now doesn't make any sense either.
Since last night, Ice has directed his focus exclusively on people who are are much less involved in the game. Surely there's ONE prominent player left who's on the mafia side. We know the role assignments made were done randomly. Are we really expected to believe the mafia's efforts are being orchestrated largely by no-shows, beginners, and a few who don't have time to post much? I'm very sure there's someone else out there who's active and scummy that Ice is deliberately overlooking. If we can figure out who that is... there's a great target for our next lynching.
If I am right about Ice now and he is on the mafia team... then there are a few other things to watch for as this day unfolds. I'm saying all this now because I know it's very likely that I'm on my way out. What I've done has probably caused some trouble with the mafia's game plan... (if Ice is mafia). So look very closely at who comes after me hard... instead of Ice himself. Ice isn't going to do this himself, but you can be sure that someone else associated with him on the mafia team will. Wait to see who that turns out to be and then look for a connection between them.
Also pay attention after nightfall tonight to who does NOT get hit by the mafia. And ask yourselves why.
For example... imagine now that I'm innocent and after sticking my neck out last night to vote Ice as mafia, see what has Ice done in response? I expected Ice to tear me to pieces after putting myself at risk like that (when I could've kept a low profile instead), but he didn't. Aside from merely including my name on his list of mafia suspects (thus far), Ice spent a good amount of time last night ignoring me and virtually all the other active players in the game. I can see why Ice didn't come after me directly.. why would he do that? It wouldn't make sense. But what he's doing now doesn't make any sense either.
Since last night, Ice has directed his focus exclusively on people who are are much less involved in the game. Surely there's ONE prominent player left who's on the mafia side. We know the role assignments made were done randomly. Are we really expected to believe the mafia's efforts are being orchestrated largely by no-shows, beginners, and a few who don't have time to post much? I'm very sure there's someone else out there who's active and scummy that Ice is deliberately overlooking. If we can figure out who that is... there's a great target for our next lynching.
If I am right about Ice now and he is on the mafia team... then there are a few other things to watch for as this day unfolds. I'm saying all this now because I know it's very likely that I'm on my way out. What I've done has probably caused some trouble with the mafia's game plan... (if Ice is mafia). So look very closely at who comes after me hard... instead of Ice himself. Ice isn't going to do this himself, but you can be sure that someone else associated with him on the mafia team will. Wait to see who that turns out to be and then look for a connection between them.
Also pay attention after nightfall tonight to who does NOT get hit by the mafia. And ask yourselves why.
Thanks for your presence to the game. Now go back and re read the thread because I haven't voted for Kash. I voted for Fire. Kash voted for me.
People need to place votes. Suspicion is nice but we need to get a feel for commitment. Votes can be changed.But to see who you really feel is mafia will help the town determine what is what.
I do agree with JL that just because him and I seem to be the most active isn't a reason to vote us. I know my role, I don't know JLs but I'm hoping since we agree on most things we are both innocent otherwise I'm on the wrong trail.
My vote stays on Fire. Not sure how much we learn from her lynching but I'm pretty sure she is mafia and I'd rather get their numbers down any way possible.
For now I'm sticking to my list of
Luv
Agassizii
FireDancer7905
Kash
Jpap who we know was.
Again you're going to pull this?
I don't need to come after you Kash. You do a great job of outing yourself. I try to root out mafia. I try different tactics, some work some make me look scummy. In either case if lynched it leaves a nice trail for the innocents to follow.
You seem nervous that we might have a firm grip on your team and the end is near. I call the look who didn't get hit your Hail Mary pass.
Rich, your idea is possible of course. Wouldn't be the 1st time JL has fooled me but for now I have to believe him and I are on the same team. I don't agree that Dopey is mafia and not so sure on Jm either but I do agree with his suspect list of Kash and Fire.
johnlarson66
These Pandas Rock
I think the mafia mastermind is Dopehand.
I am not fixed on Dope, but it seems no one wants to even talk about the way he popped in and broke the tie.
That is twice that Luv has been saved.
Can people at least acknowledge that Dope's actions are suspect?
