Mafia 62- The Play

I retract my vote for Dangerdoll and vote to lynch Labby I think that ties it up again but not sure if my tracking is correct. (work has been crazy)
Not sure my vote will stay there til nightfall but I feel pretty good about it right now. She has proven herself to be a pretty good player and able to pull the wool over even vets eyes. At this point I am not willing to take the chance.....I will do my best to sneak on here in an hour or so and try to put up a list altho one it is pretty flimsy.......

Not exactly sure what you're seeing that makes you think I'm mafia. I've been active, trying to put my thoughts out there for the town. If you could say why you think I'm mafia, something other than from the previous game, I would appreciate hearing your thoughts. Do you not find Rich or the jpap/Ag discourse suspicious?
 
Not exactly sure what you're seeing that makes you think I'm mafia. I've been active, trying to put my thoughts out there for the town. If you could say why you think I'm mafia, something other than from the previous game, I would appreciate hearing your thoughts. Do you not find Rich or the jpap/Ag discourse suspicious?


You have been active, that does not mean you are a townie. I agree that my vote is largely based on how well you have played the past couple of games but the comments made about Alex and then your vote for him are a bit fishy. As for Rich, no, not suspicious, yet. the banter between Ag and JP seems pretty typical for JP. He finds something to pick at and keeps picking away until he is satisfied. (eeewww, wonder if he picked his scabs as a kid!) LOL

the rest in no particular order:

Ice, I got nothin yet except that he seems resigned to the fact hat he will be hit or lynched early.

Kash, pretty quiet thus far but it is day one..

Zaffy, no read
DD, evil to the core! (JK, I have no idea)
Dawg, no read
JL, no read
Zsand - suspicious as we have not had a "question" yet and it is almost the end of day one!

JB, creeping up on the meter, but this could also be residual from him killing off Santa! :angryfire:

Razz, no read yet.

Obviously, day one has me pretty baffled and right now my vote sits where I feel it is best. This certainly may change as the daylight fades........

oops, forgot the new kid on the block...:huh:
think that is everyone.
 
^^ sorry for the typos!
 
You have been active, that does not mean you are a townie. I agree that my vote is largely based on how well you have played the past couple of games but the comments made about Alex and then your vote for him are a bit fishy.

Ok, fair enough. My comments on Alex were meant to help the town, but obviously people have not taken it that way. I personally like to know a players style (typically active, likes to lie low, etc) so I extrapolated that with the assumption that those of you who hadn't played with him would like to know that about him. I still don't see why that is seen as a suspicious move, but so be it.

I'm innocent, I'm trying to help the town, and I really wish more people would weigh in. I'd really like to hear from others before making my vote, but I'm going to have to vote before my meeting at 3pm CST in case I don't get out before nightfall (not likely but could happen).
 
No one has anything more to say???

Ok, I'll go ahead and vote so I don't UD, but if people speak up before nightfall and I get back in time I may very well change my vote. Right now all I'm going on is gut feeling.

I vote to lynch jpappy.
 
No one has anything more to say???

Ok, I'll go ahead and vote so I don't UD, but if people speak up before nightfall and I get back in time I may very well change my vote. Right now all I'm going on is gut feeling.

I vote to lynch jpappy.

The old gut feeling, popular on day one.

I have not really drawn much of a conclusion on anyone. No one has done anything extraordinary.

The strangest voting was from Ag in my opinion with multiple changes and not really for any reason.

I will have to wait and see. I am not all that uncomfortable with my vote on Kashta right now.
 
As I'm reading through the thread, here's the thing that has me going hmmm...

It seems strange that a townie would try to clarify that they were trying to NOT sound like a mafia. This sounds more like the thought of a mafia trying not to sound like a mafia. Thoughts on this Jpap?

Also, it seems strange to me that you're raking Ag over the coals so heatedly. Don't worry, I'll pull some posts. :p:

It was supposed to be a funny spin-off of the classic "we will see" line that mafia liked to throw around. I guess the humor of my disclaimer was lost...

I have nothing either.... I will say the whole Ag/Pap conversation is pretty interesting and as much as my knee jerk reaction is to vote paps... I can't help but think he's got good points... I am especially leaning off him a little because he was the first one to indicate that Ag was possibly playing in other games, which is why he would suggest Alex had been quite in "other" games.

What!? DD actually agrees with me on Day 1? Call the press!!!

First one to suggest random voting.


To which jpap responds with

Jpap, why did you pick up on the use of the word "random" from Ag when Rich was the first one to throw it out there?


Good point Kash, and Rich really hasn't had much to say since then either...



Struck me as a bit odd too, though at that time I was thinking Ag was a bit suspicious myself.


But Rich was the one who started in with the suggestion that everone random vote. Why not call him on it?



Was it a random vote or was it not Ag? Was your second choice random between the two remaining non-posters or were you trying to not double up on a vote?


I'll buy this for now, an attempt to get people talking.



I picked up on this too, really digging into Ag. I'll admit I was kicking bushes around Ag for a bit and still don't know what to make of him but jpap continued grilling him pretty hard.


And I can see that side of it too, was trying to figure that out myself.


Ag is not a noob and has participated in more games than I have. I do agree the whole jpap/Ag interaction has the feel of a set up. I'm still not sure which way to go with it, yesterday was leaning towards Ag being scummy but after giving it more thought I don't think I trust jpap.



Your little qualifier there just made you sound like Tony Soprano.


You're right, you did say that.


Agree. Looking forward to see those posts you're pulling and what you think about that situation.

Right now I've got three people at the top of my scum list.
1. Rich: has been around, posting here and there, but what insight have you provided the town? You did initiate the random voting which got people talking (a good thing), yet as Kash pointed out, this could be a good strategy to post without revealing anything. Also leads to a ton of confusing fingerpointing.

2. jpappy: You've gone awful hard at Ag, if you were laying bait for him he took it in one swallow. Looking back, he's jumping each time you poke him. If you're innocent, it's some good bush kicking, if you're mafia, excellent set up. I'm reserving judgment for now on that situation.

3. Agassizii: Either you fell for mafia trap or you have a guilty conscience to be as squirmy and non-committal as you have been. You're no noob, you had to know you would come under some fire for changing your vote so quickly. Not sure what to think of you either.



Right now my vote is torn among those three. I'm tempted to vote for Rich at the moment, but now that Zsand has retracted his vote for Rich my vote will lack power (for the moment at least). I am going to hold my vote for a couple more hours so hopefully more of my fellow townies can weigh in.

You missed my post then where I already answered that question. Agass' post was the most recent to use the word so I quoted it. I wasn't trying to pick on him at that point, just making an overall statement.

You have been active, that does not mean you are a townie. I agree that my vote is largely based on how well you have played the past couple of games but the comments made about Alex and then your vote for him are a bit fishy. As for Rich, no, not suspicious, yet. the banter between Ag and JP seems pretty typical for JP. He finds something to pick at and keeps picking away until he is satisfied. (eeewww, wonder if he picked his scabs as a kid!) LOL

the rest in no particular order:

Ice, I got nothin yet except that he seems resigned to the fact hat he will be hit or lynched early.

Kash, pretty quiet thus far but it is day one..

Zaffy, no read
DD, evil to the core! (JK, I have no idea)
Dawg, no read
JL, no read
Zsand - suspicious as we have not had a "question" yet and it is almost the end of day one!

JB, creeping up on the meter, but this could also be residual from him killing off Santa! :angryfire:

Razz, no read yet.

Obviously, day one has me pretty baffled and right now my vote sits where I feel it is best. This certainly may change as the daylight fades........

oops, forgot the new kid on the block...:huh:
think that is everyone.

That's exactly what I was going to respond to Lab. I have always come charging out of the gates so I would like to know what exactly about the argument he finds suspicious. The nature of the back and forth is pretty typical.

(and no, I didnt pick scabs as a kid :silly:)

No one has anything more to say???

Ok, I'll go ahead and vote so I don't UD, but if people speak up before nightfall and I get back in time I may very well change my vote. Right now all I'm going on is gut feeling.

I vote to lynch jpappy.

Good to know.

I vote to lynch Agass

Still my best suspect.
 
Hey guys,

Sorry about getting distracted last night, things have been a little hectic lately. I didn't get to follow up on my suspicions on Jpap, and won't be able to get back on before nightfall. I hate the timing of this with Labby having just voted, but I vote to lynch Jpappy. Something just seems off with his interaction with Ag, and it seems strange to me that he's so concerned with semantics.

I'll be able to be on after work tonight. I'll get caught up then.
 
Hey guys,

Sorry about getting distracted last night, things have been a little hectic lately. I didn't get to follow up on my suspicions on Jpap, and won't be able to get back on before nightfall. I hate the timing of this with Labby having just voted, but I vote to lynch Jpappy. Something just seems off with his interaction with Ag, and it seems strange to me that he's so concerned with semantics.

I'll be able to be on after work tonight. I'll get caught up then.

I'm less concerned about semantics and more concerned about the odd logic he used to jump around on votes.
 
So, I'm caught up and we have quite a bit more input but nothing really solid to go on. I still have Ag leading my suspect list but it's more of a gut feeling (as most people's votes are) Just to get a list out there:

Ag- Gut feeling so we shall see.
Jpap- If Ag is mafia I think he is also due to the whole banter thing that went on.
Lab- Not much to go on but still more than I have for anyone else.

My list WILL change after day one but for now this is it.
 
AquariaCentral.com