Mafia 62- The Play

[dirtydawg10]

Oh...and let me add that it's not just for the more recent BS...Ice has been playing strangely the entire game. Ice were you trying to get the doc to spill the beans earlier when you were asking them to protect you for no apparent reason?

 

[ZSandmann]

Here are 2 more that say Ag should have claimed Detective. Really would anyone have believed him?

Dawg?
Z?
Lab?

Would you have believed him? And Z since you're the only one of the 3 to be on Ag where would your vote have moved to if you answer yes.




And this means what to you?




I don't see Jpap as being mafia at this time. On Day 1 mafia doesn't need to try so hard to attack (as everyones putting it) one person. They put out suspicion on many and then let the town go on the witch hunt.

I may have been persuaded to not lynch Agas if they had RCed, I can not say. The fact is they did not and were lynched, what could be a worse outcome than that one? I haven't seen anyone indicating the Dr should come out, that's just plain stupid. Agas was a very powerful player and they should have fought back harder, if they RCed, "maybe" enough people would have shifted and then the Dr could protect them from the Mafia. I'm not sure what's hard to understand about that.

So you're sorry that I said I trusted you??? I don't understand that. You've seemed pro town enough to me that At this point I would not vote to lynch you unless something majorly changed. The town was pretty good at picking innocents last time, I thought the idea of putting out who we trusted again was valid so I put mine out there. Is anyone else going to do so? Is the format of this game so different that it makes a most trusted list a bad idea? If so, I fell for it. I'm not latching on to anyone. I'm trusting people based on their logic and on what seem to be valid arguments.

Sorry Lab but it's Day 2, I don't trust anyone and I don't trust anyone that says they trust someone. The last game was different but we weren't naming people we trusted until very late in that game.

I vote to lynch Lab

 

[IceH2O]

Oh...and let me add that it's not just for the more recent BS...Ice has been playing strangely the entire game. Ice were you trying to get the doc to spill the beans earlier when you were asking them to protect you for no apparent reason?

Explain to me how anything I asked the Dr to do would cause them to spill their role?



And thank you for your answers about Ag. I admit I probably wouldn't have believed them it being Day 1 but I might have taken the chance to let it slide at least another day.In case you wondered my vote would have moved to Lab.

 

[IceH2O]

Z I wasn't saying you were, it was more a general question to you 3 to see what answers would come forth.


I don't think Ag really had a chance to come out even if he wanted. It was pretty close until the last 45 minutes of the night.Then the rest piled on to put it out of reach.

 

[Dangerdoll]

ok.... I haven't been around for the day due to a surgery.... I have a few pages to catch up on....

 

[Zaffy]

I've seen enough from Pappythat I'll give him the benefit of the doubt for now. I'm gonna keep him on my short list though.

I don't want to vote Lab because I hate landslides, and everyone I suspect aside from Lab herself, and DD are voting on her; Jpap, noodles, Ice.

I don't like Ice's whole deal with begging for protection, if he's scum and the Dr. buys it, it's a guarantee that their hits will go off without a hitch. He's poking at everyone just a bit, which I like though.

Noodles, I suspect for a reason that I'm keeping to myself for right now, I'll see what happens there.

 

[noodles62]

ok, I had hoped to have more time to devote today, but it is not working out except for checking in sporadically. I still think that Labby is not on the up and up. The latest pleas dig even deeper IMO.

Jpap, the banter and cornering with Ag last night was really suspect but I am proned to believe that he is a better player then that; so waiting on that one....

Ice, I agree that he had been playing "off" but at the moment am willing to write this off as being resigned to being killed off early. Not clearing him, mind you just giving a pass for the time being....a very short time being.

DD, sorry to hear about your surgery but I really hope to hear something of substance otherwise you seriously move waaaayyy up the list.

Rich? Is Rich here? Same with Mich.....absence does not make the heart grow fonder in this game...........

More in the morning. Hubby will be gone for a hours so my thoughts will be my own for while! High maintenance men are not worth the trouble!

For now, I will put my vote back where it was until I come with a better summation. I vote to lynch Labby

 

[Dangerdoll]

ok, all skimmed up to date.

I don't see why you would be trying so hard to stay in the game if you're innocent anyways.

this sounds weird. can't see why someone would be trying so hard to be in the game if they're innocent.... so I am thinking you are saying unless you are mafia, you aren't going to give two craps if you are grilled... hmmm... interesting take.

You had no problem voting for Ag, blaming jpap for your vote?

one, I am always suspicious of paps anyway. I wasn't "blaming Pap" for my vote, I thought it was important to note that he was dead on Ag in the first place. However, the more I think about that thought, if Paps is mafia, he wouldn't have known any roles on day 1 due to the lack of investigations.... I am not clear on if the mafia even gets investigations but he wouldn't have known anyone's roles

I did not miss that part of your question; your question was mistakenly aimed, I did not take out Kash. I cannot take out anyone. The only power I have is to put my thoughts out there for my fellow townies, and hopefully they will put their thoughts out for me. I still can't figure out why you guys think I'm so scummy. Because I've been throwing ideas out there? No one finds the way jpap baited and trapped Ag to be suspicious? I feel stronger that Noods is mafia but there is much more evidence for jpap being mafia, hence my vote. Evidence trumps gut feelings.

I will say again, there really isn't sufficient evidence on Paps which is why I would be hesitant to vote him. If anything, to keep directing anyone down this path of thought is scummy to say the least. Did I miss somewhere, where it said Mafia has rights to investigate?

I'm not looking one way and voting another. I'm looking both ways, if I had two votes I'd give one to both jpap and Noods. And I'm not attempting to blame jpap for lynching the detective, I am blaming jpap for the results of this nights lynch. (Also blame Ag some as he should have defended himself or even revealed he was detective).

and still you push.

My highest suspicions would have to go to Lab, with my next going to Ice. Ice because he is a good player and dangerous if Mafia because of how good he plays. I would say JL for the same reason. Ice, again, I would be most because of his interest in Kash and since he is such a good player, why wouldnt he be on Kash and then hit her in the same day. He would probably depend on the thought that everyone knows he wouldn't set himself up so badly...

My standard suspicions would be on Noods and Paps. Only because I always suspect them and make it a practice to look after them....

and Mich..... I don't buy the newbcard on him/her. That statement he/she made was pretty twisted.

If I were to vote now, my vote would go to Lab....

 

[jbradt]

Just checking in during lunch. Admittedly, I've been skimming since I don't have a whole lot of time right now. I'm becoming more suspicious of noods. Jpap I'm still suspicious about, but I'm still willing to go with the benefit of the doubt.

I'm still not seeing a MAJOR case for Labby, and the fact that such a big deal is being made over day 1 random votes and the fact that she's agreeing with me seems off. I can see where she looks suspicious, but I'm just not getting the feeling. I'm going to have to go back through... again.

Zaffy, as I'm looking into Noods too, it might be helpful for you to spill what you think. Holding back thoughts isn't very helpful atm imo.

I also plan to look more into DD. g/o... hope everything went well with the surgery DD. g/o

 

[RazzleFish]

I feel like there are enough people voting for Lab to make it a "town decision" so I feel comfortable going with the rest of the townies (Hopefully) and vote to lynch Lab.