mafia 63- Who is Who

[Fishfriend1]

.... dinta dinta dinta Take ur time to test in me and u will find infinity.... and time goes by and you will see infinity.... a freak like me just needs infinity.... relax take ur time..... take ur time to test in me and you will find infinity....... Dinta dinta dinta dinta....

The song infinity i think. its just a great song and thats one of the things i am thinking right now... oooo the next ones on lol.

 

[Kashta]

Alright, my assessment of Fishfriend boils down to this... FF isn't the least bit interested in taking this game seriously. This thread is a goof for him... little more than a fun romp. I don't believe FF gives a rat's arse which team wins. His approach to the game (by his own statements) tell us he merely wants his vote to "count."

Meanwhile, we have two well reasoned, experienced mafia gamers using this little diverstion to both jump in at the deep end - when they're looking at a shallow stream. Kick your way through the shrubbery all you want.. make mountains out of those mole hills too. I believe it's way too much over way too little. FF is acting scummy? I sincerely doubt it. Whether he's mafia or townie is (roughly) a 50/50 call in my judgement.

Now, to those pointing out the fact that TRS flipping innocent by UD makes the odds higher that Fishfriend is mafia instead of town.... that's a load a crap, as well. The exact same argument is equally valid when applied to everyone in the game. There's no real correlation or increased odds that FF is scummier now than he was two hours ago, when compared to the status of everyone else here.

Weak argument there, too... bs logic. :bs:

Fishfriend happily sided with me yesterday. He's doing the same thing in sync with JB today. Not only has he got no clue whether I'm mafia or town.... or whether JB is mafia or town... he couldn't care less either way. Mind you, even if all 3 of us (me, JB, FF) were on the same side... even we wouldn't all know it yet.

This is a dead end and a complete waste of our time. I don't sense anything malicious about FF either (as it was with Woodward in a previous game)... Fish seems like a good kid who's just having a fun time.

That said... my impression now is both Jpappy and Lab Rat are going all out to use Fishfriend's goofiness as a convenient diversion. I'm just not sure which of the two between them will get my vote today.

I retract my vote on Rbishop.

Back again soon...

 

[Lab_Rat]

Thanks for the info and my comments are in red (duh)

The way (format) you responded makes it hard for me to respond so I'm going to have to break it up for readability sake. All of the quotes below are from FF, I didn't feel like typing his name over and over.

I was just happy to have a friend or at least someone whos didnt think i am scumy

That's fair.

I dont, if she is then she still knows what she is doing

I fully agree Kash knows what she's doing; I don't know if she's scum so I'm not going to trust her or follow what she says without independent analysis of her theories.

.
I dont iclude the bosses because if get them u win no matter what

Not sure why you wouldn't include bosses because they are part of their respective teams but whatever...

Agien i say IDK, how do i know your not scummy and just trying to frame me

Exactly my point and why it's bothering me you're blindly following anyone who seems experienced...at this point in the game the only person I trust is myself. I know my role. Everyone else has a 57% chance of being scum now that TRS has been shown innocent.

I didn't know he was leaning me away...

He said he was thinking you were just being an enthusiastic noob (or something to that effect) not necessarily scummy. Did you miss that??? I thought your response was a direct response to him saying that.

Good try maybe i will if at least 3 people vote for it lol.

What? What "it" do 3 people have to vote for? This makes no sense. What was a good try? So far you have done zero to help the town but you even beat jpap in posts.

 

[Lab_Rat]

Meanwhile, we have two well reasoned, experienced mafia gamers using this little diverstion to both jump in at the deep end - when they're looking at a shallow stream. Kick your way through the shrubbery all you want.. make mountains out of those mole hills too. I believe it's way too much over way too little. FF is acting scummy? I sincerely doubt it. Whether he's mafia or townie is (roughly) a 50/50 call in my judgement.

Now, to those pointing out the fact that TRS flipping innocent by UD makes the odds higher that Fishfriend is mafia instead of town.... that's a load a crap, as well. The exact same argument is equally valid when applied to everyone in the game. There's no real correlation or increased odds that FF is scummier now than he was two hours ago, when compared to the status of everyone else here.

This is a dead end and a complete waste of our time. I don't sense anything malicious about FF either (as it was with Woodward in a previous game)... Fish seems like a good kid who's just having a fun time.

That said... my impression now is both Jpappy and Lab Rat are going all out to use Fishfriend's goofiness as a convenient diversion. I'm just not sure which of the two between them will get my vote today.

I retract my vote on Rbishop.

Back again soon...

So you're thinking he's not scum? Yes, the same odds apply to everyone. I agree I've spent too much time on him and focused too much energy on him, did you miss that part of my post before?

I did feel I owed him a breakdown of why I said he was squirmy and scummy. That's the reason I took the time to pull all those posts and respond to his responses.

There are others who have not posted, such as Ag and Razz. They have the same chance of being scum as FF or you, Kash. The point is, I have to vote for someone tonight and so far, nothing I have seen makes me feel the need to change my vote yet. Produce something compelling and that may change.

 

[RazzleFish]

Wow 233 posts before night 1! There should be a limit of how much you guys can post while I'm away! I skimmed through and no doubt I missed a lot so my vote is going to be an OMGUS. I vote to lynch RB......... for now.

 

[Fishfriend1]

... um ... im not sure how to respond. Hmm well to Kashta i do take this game seriously. Im always like this.

To LB the nice try was a getting me to voice my opinion and all the notes ive taken so far (about 2 paragraphs). If u get 3 people to vote for me posting my notes was what i meant but i think that was a stupid comment.

Time to type more notes...

 

[jbradt]

... um ... im not sure how to respond. Hmm well to Kashta i do take this game seriously. Im always like this.

To LB the nice try was a getting me to voice my opinion and all the notes ive taken so far (about 2 paragraphs). If u get 3 people to vote for me posting my notes was what i meant but i think that was a stupid comment.

Time to type more notes...

FF, withholding any thoughts you have about any player serves only to help the mafia. This is the first thing you've said that makes me want to really take a hard look at you. I'll switch my vote to you if it'll help. But I'd really rather keep it where it is...

 

[rich311k]

... um ... im not sure how to respond. Hmm well to Kashta i do take this game seriously. Im always like this.

To LB the nice try was a getting me to voice my opinion and all the notes ive taken so far (about 2 paragraphs). If u get 3 people to vote for me posting my notes was what i meant but i think that was a stupid comment.

Time to type more notes...

Sharing your thoughts is what this is all about. Gives people a chance to comment on them thus forming opinions about each other.

 

[Lab_Rat]

FF, withholding any thoughts you have about any player serves only to help the mafia. This is the first thing you've said that makes me want to really take a hard look at you. I'll switch my vote to you if it'll help. But I'd really rather keep it where it is...

What he said...

 

[Kashta]

... um ... im not sure how to respond. Hmm well to Kashta i do take this game seriously. Im always like this.

To LB the nice try was a getting me to voice my opinion and all the notes ive taken so far (about 2 paragraphs). If u get 3 people to vote for me posting my notes was what i meant but i think that was a stupid comment.

Time to type more notes...

Fish, you're doing just fine. Please take nothing I just posted about you just now as a criticism in any way at all.. it isn't. I enjoy your enthusiasm for this game and I truly hope you continue to play in these with us. This is a lot of fun and I'm glad you're jumping right in the way you've been doing.