mafia 63- Who is Who

[Fishfriend1]

Fine then MY notes on the game so far , my thoughts come after notes.
Notes on MAFIA 63 GAME:
I bet im gonna be investigated soon lol.
What with all my jumping votes and making bs jokes and just plain confusing people no one knows what team im on. I could be the mafia don or the mayor or neither. I have affectively made it impossible for ether side to vote for ma without risk to themselves. Ha Ha HA !
Lab_Rat is a good player maybe I should get to know him better. Kashta is no longer a "friend"… until further notice anyway.

My thoughts are that kashta is in a good position to be a leader and that Lab_Rat is really trying. I also think that John may be a leader and is trying to cover it up.
No thoughts on Razzle or any others who havent posted they still have a chance to be townie so i wont risk it. The wizard has really dropped off on posting he started out pretty good but now, well not so much, he may be seeing how people have reacted to my posting.

 

[Kashta]

So you're thinking he's not scum?

Yes, Lab Rat. And I think you've been digging up all the justification you could possibly find to support the characterization you either want to believe... or have us believe. It doesn't take all that to explain his behavior.

 

[Lab_Rat]

Yes, Lab Rat. And I think you've been digging up all the justification you could possibly find to support the characterization you either want to believe... or have us believe. It doesn't take all that to explain his behavior.

I must ask again, did you miss the part where I admitted to spending too much time focusing on him?

Rich seems scummy to me but I'm not going to vote for him yet because Rich always seems scummy to me, even when innocent.

 

[Kashta]

Fine then MY notes on the game so far , my thoughts come after notes.
Notes on MAFIA 63 GAME:
I bet im gonna be investigated soon lol.
What with all my jumping votes and making bs jokes and just plain confusing people no one knows what team im on. I could be the mafia don or the mayor or neither. I have affectively made it impossible for ether side to vote for ma without risk to themselves. Ha Ha HA !
Lab_Rat is a good player maybe I should get to know him better. Kashta is no longer a "friend"… until further notice anyway.

My thoughts are that kashta is in a good position to be a leader and that Lab_Rat is really trying. I also think that John may be a leader and is trying to cover it up.
No thoughts on Razzle or any others who havent posted they still have a chance to be townie so i wont risk it. The wizard has really dropped off on posting he started out pretty good but now, well not so much, he may be seeing how people have reacted to my posting.

Haha, hey thanks a lot, Fishfiend.. Oops, I meant, Fishfriend! :rofl:

PS to Lab Rat........ I rest my case.

 

[jbradt]

I must ask again, did you miss the part where I admitted to spending too much time focusing on him?

Rich seems scummy to me but I'm not going to vote for him yet because Rich always seems scummy to me, even when innocent.

I've gotta say here, Labby... it's a little strange to me that Rich (an experienced player) seems scummy, yet you hesitate to place the vote. FF who seems to be playing like a newb drew your ire early with no such hesitation.

Just pointing out the obvious. I still like my vote on Rich, but Kash makes some good points...

 

[Fishfriend1]

wow i really expected more then this in reaction to my notes

 

[Lab_Rat]

I've gotta say here, Labby... it's a little strange to me that Rich (an experienced player) seems scummy, yet you hesitate to place the vote. FF who seems to be playing like a newb drew your ire early with no such hesitation.

Just pointing out the obvious. I still like my vote on Rich, but Kash makes some good points...

I hesitate to place my vote because I would have sworn last game he was scummy right before he was hit by the mafia and shown innocent. In another game, at another site, I was actually mafia and thought he was the non-communicating mafia. I would have sworn up and down he was. He turned out to be innocent. Does that explain why I'm a bit trigger-shy to vote for him? With losing TRS, I don't want to make a mistake thinking he's scummy since my track record of thinking he's scum when he's not is pretty obviously erroneous.

 

[jbradt]

I hesitate to place my vote because I would have sworn last game he was scummy right before he was hit by the mafia and shown innocent. In another game, at another site, I was actually mafia and thought he was the non-communicating mafia. I would have sworn up and down he was. He turned out to be innocent. Does that explain why I'm a bit trigger-shy to vote for him? With losing TRS, I don't want to make a mistake thinking he's scummy since my track record of thinking he's scum when he's not is pretty obviously erroneous.

I do get it on some level, but you seem to be saying that you're hesitant to vote for Rich because you're not good at judging his play style. Is that right? If so, how can you be so sure about judging FF's play style since he's a newb and doesn't even have one yet? That's where the disconnect seems to be... for me anyway.

 

[jpappy789]

I wasn't trying to defend so much as say that I see FF's play as being more noob than scum. I understand how it looks that way though. Am I gonna have to get my high-tops on to protect my ankles? :silly:


Awwwwww, Rich; I OMGUS you too! And yes, I am looking for something to sink my teeth into... like an innocent voting (now twice), OMGUSY, skimmer? Yep, I like my vote just fine, thanks.

Aren't we all trying to find something to "dig our teeth into"? It seems to me as though that's the job of a townie.

I know, that's why I put it in quotes...FF sure seemed to think you were defending him in some way, though. I don't think you or anyone else would have chosen to investigate a new player when there are much more dangerous players out there. And since I dont think Ice would necessarily allow a new player to be the boss I doubt you two are a team, and the same goes with Kash. I just think it's weird that FF has followed the two of you but I could see why he would think that would be a good idea. I guess I'm just a little taken back by what he's said...I remember playing a lot differently when I first started playing and most newbs don't act so oddly right from the start...

I retract my vote on FF

I don't really like the vote the more I think about it...he was called out for following Kash and then did it again to JB...I would think he would be more cautious of that, so I agree with Kash's assessment that he's likely just having fun and doesn't care too much about what people think of him. It doesn't make him innocent so I will still keep him on my shortlist when I start gathering enough suspects to make one. He's said/done some pretty scummy things but I feel like I'm doing too much of what I did day one last game and I don't want to walk into that self laid trap again. At this point I would rather get a feel for FF as the game progresses and not jump the gun, so to speak. For all I know I may end up back here by nightfall but I need to do a read through or two before making that decision.

Wow 233 posts before night 1! There should be a limit of how much you guys can post while I'm away! I skimmed through and no doubt I missed a lot so my vote is going to be an OMGUS. I vote to lynch RB......... for now.

There's still some time to get a vote in and honestly, there's not much to comment on if you look past FF's frenzied posts. I really hope you get a chance to place an actual vote of some sort.

 

[Lab_Rat]

I do get it on some level, but you seem to be saying that you're hesitant to vote for Rich because you're not good at judging his play style. Is that right? If so, how can you be so sure about judging FF's play style since he's a newb and doesn't even have one yet? That's where the disconnect seems to be... for me anyway.

I can't be and now I'm all :nilly:

I'm not going to retract my vote right now as I have to go TA a class in 10 minutes. I won't likely be back until maybe a half hour before nightfall. If I get back in time to review the thread again I may change my vote. But I'm not going to just throw a vote on someone now because I feel :nilly: