mafia 63- Who is Who

Alright, it's coming down to the wire. As I keep turning things over in my head, I believe JL is scum.

I've also been looking a lot at Labby's theory, and it does seem to hold water. It's interesting to me that JL switched his vote to Annie (after some pressure), then switched back to FF saying "I'm pretty sure I'm wrong [that he's a townie]". Then a couple posts later, he says that he has no read on FF, but is 100% sure Annie is scum. Yet you still seem unwilling to vote for him. That's scummy JL. And I think Labby is right; you're trying to protect Annie. Since the only reason for scum to protect anyone is because they are the boss, I retract my vote on JL, and vote to lynch Annie.

I hope you're right, Labby...
 
jbradt said:
I've got to agree with Jpap here RB. Even I understood the rules... doesn't matter what form they took. I have a hard time believing you were that confused by it.
Click to expand...

Guess it's a matter of principle.....don't repeat the rules accurately in a game thread, then say it is active...cheesey.

For those of you claiming you knew it to be a rule, you never shot down any posts declaring no communicating folks on day one...
 
Rbishop said:
I wouldn't base a theory or justify anyone else's when folks have been playing under two sets of rules and even though there were numerous posts contrary to the rules, the Mod never clarified the issue.

For all those that posted no one was communicating in numerous posts on day one and most of day two and any theories developed on that...they are all bogus since the Mod said a rule from the sign up thread was in affect though not in the rules stated in this game at the on set.

So from what I see, it is nothing more than a crap shoot day one vote...
Click to expand...
I refuse to believe you have no more insight than this, RB.:pc:
 
I still think anyone voting for FF without poking a hole in my theory about Annie and JL is totally scummy. All I ask is for my theory to be debunked.
 
you 3 doesn't equal the 14 players...
 
Lab_Rat said:
I still think anyone voting for FF without poking a hole in my theory about Annie and JL is totally scummy. All I ask is for my theory to be debunked.
Click to expand...

I've already put my $.02 in on the theory. I wholeheartedly believe one of the two is scum and one of the two is the policeman.
 
its the one hour mark can someone post the lynch list?
 
jpappy789 said:
I've already put my $.02 in on the theory. I wholeheartedly believe one of the two is scum and one of the two is the policeman.
Click to expand...

What do you make of JL not voting for someone he is 100% sure is scum in favor of someone he is pretty sure is not the mayor (but doesn't know if scum or innocent)?
 
Rbishop said:
you 3 doesn't equal the 14 players...
Click to expand...

Yep, but when "us 3" equate for most of the talk going on concerning today's situation it makes no difference how many people did.

For someone who seemed to take offense to being called a lurker, you sure haven't proven that you are not one...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom