Mafia 66: Farmers versus the Railroad - the play

[Fishfriend1]

Ok, so i have more thoughts.

Hmmm, I think that the scum team includes Wiz, Cole(maybe), JP, and just possibly Lab. Cole because Noods saved his ***, Lab because she seems to be losing her ability to think strait and stay focused. Wiz, he just seems scummy its a gut feeling, annie because he hasn't really helped the town much.

 

[Fishfriend1]

Ok, so i have more thoughts.

Hmmm, I think that the scum team includes Wiz, Cole(maybe), JP, and just possibly Lab. Cole because Noods saved his ***, Lab because she seems to be losing her ability to think strait and stay focused. Wiz, he just seems scummy its a gut feeling, annie because he hasn't really helped the town much.

Woops, thats supposed to be annie, not JP lol. I should really stop and re-read my posts, wonder why i typed JP...

 

[dirtydawg10]

Dawg...you need(ed) to answer the question I asked you clearly.

You logically think either jpappy or jb are scum, because you said some scum voted for the Wizard last night ? Which is it ? You were very clear.

Interestingly you opt to say that in fact the Wizard is perhaps/likely scum. I think that's because I said to you earlier that you logically think either jappy or the Wizard are scum...heheh my bad. I meant to say jpappy or jb.

You say you think the Wizard is scum because Noodles voted for them. That's eh original - explain ?

Coler...you were wondering why I said that I think the scum spread their votes around and who on Wiz was scum. Noods was the scum on Wiz...how is that not clear?

With that said, I did the same thing as you and put Wiz down instead of JB. That should have said I lean JPap more innocent than JB...but I do lean JPap more innocent than Wiz also.

 

[dirtydawg10]

As far as Noods vote on Wiz...I said it could be distancing on the part of Noods. She knew she wouldn't be able to take out Wiz with her vote. If she did as you say try to make you look bad wouldn't that also make Wiz look good?

And for clarification my post actually said I think Noods goal was to cause confusion. I was just saying her vote could have been for several different reasons.

 

[dirtydawg10]

Was she painting Coler in an unflattering light? or distancing from Wiz? or both? or neither? I think she was trying to cause confusion and it seems to have worked.

Here's the post I believe you were referring to Coler...just so it is all in the same place.

 

[dirtydawg10]

Ok, so i have more thoughts.

Hmmm, I think that the scum team includes Wiz, Cole(maybe), JP, and just possibly Lab. Cole because Noods saved his ***, Lab because she seems to be losing her ability to think strait and stay focused. Wiz, he just seems scummy its a gut feeling, annie because he hasn't really helped the town much.

You think Coler and Lab could be on the same team? Can you clarify that one for me?

 

[Dagamoth]

Coler- what can I say, heck of a guy. He appears to be working in the towns best interest.

Wiz- same as Coler

Take it as you will. I believe the towns interest will best be served today discussing a two or three horse race with:

Lab
FF
??? (Jpap?) (Dag?) (Dawg?)

Wow if that isn't an word HJ I don't know what is. Coler was kashta's primary suspect in the beginning (aside from noods who she was informed was evil), Coler defended Noods in day 1, Noods defended Coler by not voting for him last night. Coler and scum are now claiming that the scum would have won last night if they had lynched an innocent yet a known scum voted in their worst interest for wiz instead of coler even though there could have been possibility for 50/50 and game winning lynch. Scum are trying to distort the facts so much I just have to laugh at the weak arguments they are trying to prop up.

 

[Dagamoth]

My current theory...the votes on Noods were town votes. That gives me a primary suspect list of Dawg, Lab, & Dag. As per my previous post I would have had Lab innocent on D1.

I snipped alot of that post out to the only thing that needed commenting on.
If i'm understanding your theory correctly you're saying the whole scum was voting for you and every innocent was voting for Noods. That means the whole scum team strategy would be clearly identify yourself in an attempt to save someone who EVERY SINGLE PERSON IN THE GAME KNOWS IS SCUM WITHOUT A DOUBT. that scum strategy is try and get coler lynched and then they coordinated with Noods to give up on that and vote for wiz after making the plan to have every single member of scum team identify themselves with a vote on coler......

That makes absolutely no sense.

 

[Fishfriend1]

You think Coler and Lab could be on the same team? Can you clarify that one for me?

Distancing. Thats what it is. She doesn't what to go down with Coler.

 

[Lab_Rat]

Are you sure your not just trying to confuse us, oh great one?
I think that this make the # of theories you have come up with around 8 or 9 right? Just come up with a suspect list and reason to kill them and your all set to go, you dont need to come up with 400 thousand diff ways the RRO could win or lose. That just confuses me...

I put theories I think are reasonable out there so I can get some feedback. Dag's enthusiastic vote right after what for me was a very confusing nightfall make me a little uneasy. Why does it bother you if I put that thought out there? Doesn't mean I think he's scum, but I did find it a bit unsettling. You not wanting to examine people from every angle makes you seem scummy.

Who are they ?

Dawg and Jpap. More confident Dawg is innocent, but jpap has stayed consistently pro-town from what I can tell.

Ok, so i have more thoughts.

Hmmm, I think that the scum team includes Wiz, Cole(maybe), JP, and just possibly Lab. Cole because Noods saved his ***, Lab because she seems to be losing her ability to think strait and stay focused. Wiz, he just seems scummy its a gut feeling, annie because he hasn't really helped the town much.

You're saying I'm not focused??? :laugh: Pretty funny coming from you... And seriously, you put me on a list with the three people hammering me and trying to convince the town to lynch me...yeah, that really makes a whole lot of sense FF... :screwy: