Mafia 66: Farmers versus the Railroad - the play

[jpappy789]

Are you sure your not just trying to confuse us, oh great one?
I think that this make the # of theories you have come up with around 8 or 9 right? Just come up with a suspect list and reason to kill them and your all set to go, you dont need to come up with 400 thousand diff ways the RRO could win or lose. That just confuses me...

FF, are you advocating for people to just throw out a suspect list and vote? Because all that does is stifle discussion, exactly what the mafia want. We're at the point where we cannot mis-lynch and expect to be around tomorrow. We have to go through every scenario possible to narrow down what exactly the mafia is attempting to do to win the game. I don't see why you would disagree with that. Everyone but the mafia is already confused...

OK, the answer to that is someone (cant remember who) said that anyone voting noods cant be scum, i was just pointing out the flaws in that idea.

It was Annie, first of all. Second of all, what did you say that in any way discredited the notion that the people voting for Noods are innocent. Are you saying that isn't true because you are scum? Because you used yourself as an example then.

 

[Lab_Rat]

Distancing. Thats what it is. She doesn't what to go down with Coler.

Hammering on each other is NOT distancing. Distancing is giving a little kick here, a little kick there, maybe a random vote on someone when it doesn't matter. Such as Noods vote on Odin if Odin indeed was scum. What is going on between me and the "3 horsemen" (not sure who their fourth is) is no where near distancing.

Honestly, the kicking I was getting day 1 did not seem scummy to me, when Wiz brought up that whole 4 horseman theory. I felt those kicking at me were legitimately trying to hash out if I was indeed acting pro-town. The feeling I'm getting now by Annie, Wiz, and Coler is a bunch of manipulation and finger-pointing without solid pro-town bush kicking. A lot of smoke and mirrors if you will. It reeks of desperation.

 

[jpappy789]

More thoughts!

Why Noods would vote jump last minute if it weren't to save a teammate...

to frame an innocent.

OK, um, well Lab appears to be going defensive, Coler has finally decided to go on the offensive, prob with the old saying "the best defense is a good offense". Meanwhile JP is just doing his bit to help the town and Annie is still nit here! He just pops up to post a few things and then just leave like nobodies business.

Another thing is that its day 3 and im not a major suspect yet! WOW! That must be a first. Maybe its because ive just been helping the town and not posting so much.

Ive also been trying to not post unless I had something to say, only 2 post were nothing posts, plz forgive me.

That is all for now.

I'm assuming this is in regards to Noods framing Coler...

Ok, so i have more thoughts.

Hmmm, I think that the scum team includes Wiz, Cole(maybe), JP, and just possibly Lab. Cole because Noods saved his ***, Lab because she seems to be losing her ability to think strait and stay focused. Wiz, he just seems scummy its a gut feeling, annie because he hasn't really helped the town much.

Yet you think Coler is scum? So what do you think ACTUALLY happened...was Coler setup by Noods or did she save him?

Woops, thats supposed to be annie, not JP lol. I should really stop and re-read my posts, wonder why i typed JP...

Yes, I wonder why...

FF, if you're scum I have to congratulate your team for putting out so many distractions this game that you're just a minor player. If the situation was different I would consider voting for you. But at this point you've become the biggest wildcard now that Onin is dead.

 

[Dagamoth]

I put theories I think are reasonable out there so I can get some feedback. Dag's enthusiastic vote right after what for me was a very confusing nightfall make me a little uneasy. Why does it bother you if I put that thought out there? Doesn't mean I think he's scum, but I did find it a bit unsettling. You not wanting to examine people from every angle makes you seem scummy.



Dawg and Jpap. More confident Dawg is innocent, but jpap has stayed consistently pro-town from what I can tell.


You're saying I'm not focused??? :laugh: Pretty funny coming from you... And seriously, you put me on a list with the three people hammering me and trying to convince the town to lynch me...yeah, that really makes a whole lot of sense FF... :screwy:

I was convinced that Coler was scum yesterday and the events of last night have not at all made me think he was innocent. If anything the 1 hour before nightfall of Coler is the best guy ever, I wish i was Coler, The OhHHHH coler is so great, OOOOO Can I have coler babies, etc... only made me more suspect of him and the people who are giving him verbal HJs.

 

[Fishfriend1]

I'm assuming this is in regards to Noods framing Coler...



Yet you think Coler is scum? So what do you think ACTUALLY happened...was Coler setup by Noods or did she save him?



Yes, I wonder why...

FF, if you're scum I have to congratulate your team for putting out so many distractions this game that you're just a minor player. If the situation was different I would consider voting for you. But at this point you've become the biggest wildcard now that Onin is dead.

Im just trying to think how every little bit of this game could be happening. Its a possibility (small, but still there) that noods was frameing coler.

If i knew i wouldnt be asking.

Im a wildcard? well i guess i am.

 

[jpappy789]

[/U]

Im just trying to think how every little bit of this game could be happening. Its a possibility (small, but still there) that noods was frameing coler.

If i knew i wouldnt be asking.

Im a wildcard? well i guess i am.

To the bold part...it's interesting then that you are going after Lab for doing the same thing.

 

[Lab_Rat]

[/U]

Im just trying to think how every little bit of this game could be happening. Its a possibility (small, but still there) that noods was frameing coler.

Didn't you just say I was scummy for doing this very thing? Something along the lines of just put a list out there but no more theories...

 

[Coler]

I snipped alot of that post out to the only thing that needed commenting on.
If i'm understanding your theory correctly you're saying the whole scum was voting for you and every innocent was voting for Noods. That means the whole scum team strategy would be clearly identify yourself in an attempt to save someone who EVERY SINGLE PERSON IN THE GAME KNOWS IS SCUM WITHOUT A DOUBT. that scum strategy is try and get coler lynched and then they coordinated with Noods to give up on that and vote for wiz after making the plan to have every single member of scum team identify themselves with a vote on coler......

That makes absolutely no sense.

What I posted makes sense if you look at the behaviour about the votes. I've already posted in detail on it. The reality is that I was a soft target for anyone to vote for, even when revealed innocent.

Actually on Noods vote for wiz I said this was indicative possibly of her being un-cordinated, or of not voting for me to make me look scummy. She was known scum - you can decide yourself whether not voting for me was to save me or to make me look bad. Its a judgment call you have to make - I and others can only give opinion and analysis.

 

[Coler]

Wow if that isn't an word HJ I don't know what is. Coler was kashta's primary suspect in the beginning (aside from noods who she was informed was evil), Coler defended Noods in day 1, Noods defended Coler by not voting for him last night. Coler and scum are now claiming that the scum would have won last night if they had lynched an innocent yet a known scum voted in their worst interest for wiz instead of coler even though there could have been possibility for 50/50 and game winning lynch. Scum are trying to distort the facts so much I just have to laugh at the weak arguments they are trying to prop up.

Yeah...kash was my primary suspect in the beginning for my vote on her. I did not defend Noodles. This post is genuinely misrepresentative. I think you and your team, if you are scum, may be cracking a little.

 

[Coler]

Correction, I was kash's primary suspect for my vote on her.