Mafia #67 - 50/50 -- The Play

[Lab_Rat]

Stand up and take a bow for your performance.

If I were scum I'd be quite proud...unfortunately I'm not. Excuse me while I gather my thoughts...

Labby, you keep insisting on reminding people that whoever wanted to do whatever "even if FF was Mafia".... well, FF wasn't mafia... why do you keep saying that... yes, I see you are making points or whatever but the moire you put in the post "even if FF was Mafia", I think you are confusing people or trying to...

...

Noods and Dag, I will admit Noods has not put much effort into the game but I think I read that she was going to be a little busy so I can see her infrequency, but Dag seems to blame others for doing things that he is doing as well... except heavy handing his posts in order to make them seem like he's innocent when all it says to me is that he's got some kind of over confudence for some reason... most times, this over confidence equals Mafia.

??? I said that I'm voting JB because he insisted on keeping FF around, even if FF was scummy...not because he was saying FF was innocent. Go back and read JB's posts without skimming.

As far as Dag goes, that's just the way he is...try growing up with him... :grinno:

Wow. Does "having some class" mean nothing in ACville?

JB, that would be "Klassy", with a "K"...

What makes you so sure you won't be too busy saving your bacon to be questioning anyone?

Oh Wiz, I'm sure I'm next to be lynched...haven't we gone over this ad nauseum. Go read what was discussed right before night 1 if you need a reference...

 

[johnlarson66]

Don't go all FF on us now Lab.

I think you are just an easy vote, just as FF was.

Of the people with you on FF, who do you have leaning mafia?

 

[johnlarson66]

Lab, since you like stats and odds - FF had 8 votes, there are 7 mafia. That means there is a 100% chance that one mafia voted for FF.

 

[the wizard]

Noods is acting very suspicious with the lack of posting. Although given she did say her posting would be sporadic but it's been almost non existent. Her pregame post of I won't be able to post as much could have just worked out very well in her favor as it gives her a reason to lay low.

JB has some really weak reasons for voting for LR which makes me suspect:
I don't like the train.
The way he read the thread LR is twisting words or misunderstood what FF meant by i wish the mafia would investigate me.

I guess I just don't understand how anyone could misunderstand what FF said. HE ASKED FOR MAFIA TO INVESTIGATE HIM. No good can come of that for the town if he is innocent. All they would have to do is send a hit on him and bang he's dead without any suspects.

As for LR I could honestly see her being a mafia who is cutting off the finger to save the hand. But I think she would try using a band aid first instead of the knife.

Did you like the train on FF?

If I am not mistaken, the way I read it LR drew first blood. She started with the knife.

While each might take out some of their own it would be on accident. With this format if you get the feeling someone might be on your side isn't worth trying to save them instead of just saying "well we were probably going to kill some of our own anyway"? Pretty much no matter what the format you want to keep your own people alive unless they have been completely outed like Noods last game.

Is this why you consistently rush to defend LR?

 

[the wizard]

If I were scum I'd be quite proud...unfortunately I'm not. Excuse me while I gather my thoughts...



??? I said that I'm voting JB because he insisted on keeping FF around, even if FF was scummy...not because he was saying FF was innocent. Go back and read JB's posts without skimming.

As far as Dag goes, that's just the way he is...try growing up with him... :grinno:




JB, that would be "Klassy", with a "K"...


Oh Wiz, I'm sure I'm next to be lynched...haven't we gone over this ad nauseum. Go read what was discussed right before night 1 if you need a reference...

I have read the entire FF/LR fiasco. I need no reference as I was quite able to see what you were doing.

 

[Dangerdoll]

I am pretty sure I was responding to Lab's suspect list, which I had asked her for. I have Kash leaning innocent because I agreed with what she had said about FF. Since Kash has Wiz in her life, she has not posted as much as she used to. In this game her limited post have been informative. As far as long posts, most of the time I see long posts as a sign of scumness.

Why did you vote for FF again? I think everyone can agree that some scum voted FF, you were #2. Is Lab going to take the fall for your vote?

I voted FF pretty early because he was spewing all sorts of confusion from the moment the game started and how he came out of the gate practically screaming he was innocent. From the game I have played, anyone that says they are innocent and even begs people to believe them automatically says mafia to me., then there was him saying Noods wasn't playing when she is so here he adds confusion, another mafia tell...and then there was the confused card...... that's why I voted for him. He didn't stop claiming innocent either from the get go all the way to night call.

As far as Kash goes, I believe Wiz and Kash were indeed a couple during last game when she went heavy in on Noods and Coler... that is her as an innocent in my eyes.... her not being here so frequently draws me to question why she is being so quiet...

I can elaborate more on my reasons for voting FF in the morning after looking back at yesterday but I do believe I've summed it up.

 

[Lab_Rat]

Don't go all FF on us now Lab.

I think you are just an easy vote, just as FF was.

Of the people with you on FF, who do you have leaning mafia?

No, I will kick bushes until the noose tightens around my neck and I am no more for this game. I just didn't feel like rehashing everything for Wiz when he could so easily go read it himself.

For scum on FF, I'm going to go with Noods, Rich, and either DD or Annie. Noods has not made an effort to contribute to the town whatsoever, and Rich has only made non-committal posts, seems like he's looking for an easy way out whenever questioned. Neither has risked anything, both have laid very low and both were late votes for FF. DD I can't get a read on one way or another and Annie has hardly posted anything at all. At least DD appears to be doing some bush kicking. Annie has done nothing pro-town that I can tell.

Lab, since you like stats and odds - FF had 8 votes, there are 7 mafia. That means there is a 100% chance that one mafia voted for FF.

I 100% agree with your assessment. I think it's likely there are more than 1 scum on FF, maybe even 3 or so. 3 scum on FF would fit with 4 scum voting for me. I think Tank is just clueless and didn't know where to place a vote.

 

[the wizard]

wow really did not see that coming. FF you really do suck at playing innocent.

You suck at being objective with your voting. You stated right off the bat that your vote was a revenge vote. (very scummy)

Then as LR continued her badgering and manipulating the thread day 1 all you posted was repeats of her posts.

I didn't see one objective bush kicking post from you yet you are quick to point to others for lack of posting.

 

[Lab_Rat]

I have read the entire FF/LR fiasco. I need no reference as I was quite able to see what you were doing.

Obviously you could not see that I was telling the truth. I'll admit, when an idea gets in my head sometimes I run with it too far. I thought I was doing what was best for the town. If I were scum I'd have come up with some elaborate fiasco instead of kicking around FF and his scummy seeming posts.

 

[jbradt]

No, I will kick bushes until the noose tightens around my neck and I am no more for this game. I just didn't feel like rehashing everything for Wiz when he could so easily go read it himself.

For scum on FF, I'm going to go with Noods, Rich, and either DD or Annie. Noods has not made an effort to contribute to the town whatsoever, and Rich has only made non-committal posts, seems like he's looking for an easy way out whenever questioned. Neither has risked anything, both have laid very low and both were late votes for FF. DD I can't get a read on one way or another and Annie has hardly posted anything at all. At least DD appears to be doing some bush kicking. Annie has done nothing pro-town that I can tell.




I 100% agree with your assessment. I think it's likely there are more than 1 scum on FF, maybe even 3 or so. 3 scum on FF would fit with 4 scum voting for me. I think Tank is just clueless and didn't know where to place a vote.

Labby, you keep using this phrase "pro town", but you were the driving force behind lynching an innocent. Even after several people tried to point out to you the flaw in your interpretation, you kept at it. Was that terribly pro town?