Mafia #67 - 50/50 -- The Play

Lab_Rat said:
FF asking scum to investigate him for the good of the town seemed too far fetched for even me to believe. So I figured it was scum trying to save a teammate. I don't trust you guys, why should I believe some fantastic story about why FF would post scummy sounding things?

So JB, if FF had been mafia, how would keeping him around have been pro-town? That was your reason for not wanting to lynch him...
Click to expand...
I didn't answer this fully before. My reason for not wanting to lynch him was that I WAS NOT CONVINCED HE WAS SCUM. The other part was an idea that came to me that turned out not to work out.
The town, however; decided that it would be better to read his posts for what suited their purposes as opposed to what they said. Even after it was pointed out.

Labby, I've singled out you and Pappy pretty clearly so far for not only twisting words and being closed minded, but also for voting extremely early.

A lot of people have kept up with saying "it's day 1, we can't know anything". I've paid attention to that because that's the SAME PLOY I USED LAST GAME to great effect. Turns out we had a 60 page day 1. If anyone in this game (Tank, it's your first game so I'll exclude you from this statement) is going to tell me they couldn't have learned SOMETHING from lynching ANYONE else, then you're either a liar or looking only to further your own agenda.

You ask me who my top suspects are... I say again: throw a rock. With all this confusion caused by THE TOWN we know barely anything more than yesterday. And it's our own fault.
 
Lab_Rat said:
No problem! :thumbsup: Actually, it's that flaw in your logic that makes me think you're scummy above everyone else. It's why my vote is on you at this point.
Click to expand...


Isn't that the same reason you lynched FF? I think JB has a better grasp so I'm not planning on seeing a bunch of confused posts that incriminate him even more.

When I read JBs posts last night nothing stood out. Seemed the most argumentative part was when Jpap asked him if FF isn't on a team how could be slip and JB admitted to not thinking it all the way thru.Not liking his last post though. How do we not learn from FFs lynch? My suspect and why list will explain.

DD bothers me in the fact that 2 days now she has questioned Labs motives but she stayed on FF and voted with Lab,be interesting where her vote falls this time.

I have to go in early for inventory so I'll finish my suspect and why list later.
 
The little boy who cried wolf, huh? Forgive me if I'm confused here, but didn't the little boy claim falsely about the wolf so no one beleived him? How is it that me claiming I'm innocent when I'm really innocent related to that? Cuz that's saying I'm losing credibility with telling the truth. I don't get it. Not that it matters, iirc, every game I've played with you you have accused me of being scum. So I guess this is to be expected.

Would it be pro-town of me to hold back any ideas I have and not go after posts that I see as scummy? Sitting back, saying nothing, risking nothing would certainly allow me to live longer in these games, plus I wouldn't be kicked all over the place. Zs was right, players who post more are most definitely targeted more.


So JB, you said you didn't vote for FF because you weren't convinced he was scum...were you convinced I was scum? Is that how I gained your vote?
 
Lab_Rat said:
No, I will kick bushes until the noose tightens around my neck and I am no more for this game. I just didn't feel like rehashing everything for Wiz when he could so easily go read it himself.

For scum on FF, I'm going to go with Noods, Rich, and either DD or Annie. Noods has not made an effort to contribute to the town whatsoever, and Rich has only made non-committal posts, seems like he's looking for an easy way out whenever questioned. Neither has risked anything, both have laid very low and both were late votes for FF. DD I can't get a read on one way or another and Annie has hardly posted anything at all. At least DD appears to be doing some bush kicking. Annie has done nothing pro-town that I can tell.

I 100% agree with your assessment. I think it's likely there are more than 1 scum on FF, maybe even 3 or so. 3 scum on FF would fit with 4 scum voting for me. I think Tank is just clueless and didn't know where to place a vote.
Click to expand...

I post what I can, when I can. I'm a firm believer in quality over quantity.

That hurts my feelings Lab. Also makes me think what the hell else "pro town" I could have been doing. Believe me, I thought FF was a scumbag, and once that was proven, I had a sweet list of suspects for today. That list got tossed in the trash.

I agree Tank is a clueless noob. Innocent I hope, because I don't see anyone rattling his cage at this point without looking like an opportunistic scumbag. If he's scum, he's quite likely gonna skate through this game relatively unharmed.

That being said, I do think the whole FF fiasco did generate at least one good lead. JB and his "pocket mafia" ideas.

I have you leaning innocent at this point, and will be watching carefully those that will be pushing for your lynch today. I believe you just thought you had a scumbag in your crosshairs, no different than me.

While some may argue I am being led down the garden path by a pretty Doctor, I guess that still beats plowing fields with my retarded sister.

jbradt said:
Still working that out.
Click to expand...

So let me get this straight JB. With scumbags in every direction, behind every tree and under every rock, with evil lurking just a coin flip away as Mad might say, you have NO suspects. Not even one?

I have at least three suspects at this point. Pretty good ones too IMO. You're one. When I get home from work I'm going to spend some time reviewing your posts, particularly your ideas about pocket mafia.

Noods is next on my suspect list. Lurking in the shadows, constantly getting "caught up" are surefire scumtells. I'm always trying to get "caught up" when I'm a scumbag. I think a few votes on Noods would get her posting.

Then Rich. Rich who you might ask? Seems he only posts after his name is mentioned, is very non committal, and even stated he voted for FF to stop the conversations about him, not because he found FF's posts particularly scummy.
 
And just curious what was so great about that post. You were the third person to say I still think LR is a townie, which really worked well for you since you are in the same boat as her.

I voted to get rid of FF, there was certainly enough to think he was mafia which would be have been an added bonus, but I voted to be sure he was gone.

For the record I am thinking JB right now. He misquoted me and is picking things I think are not all that tremendous as reasons to suspect folks.
 
AnniesNotOK said:
...

Then Rich. Rich who you might ask? Seems he only posts after his name is mentioned, is very non committal, and even stated he voted for FF to stop the conversations about him, not because he found FF's posts particularly scummy.
Click to expand...

rich311k said:
Hi Annie! :)

I think I could post War and Peace and I would still hear how I do not post any good ideas. Once you get a label you keep it.
Click to expand...

I think it took less than 10 minutes. Too funny.
 
rich311k said:
And just curious what was so great about that post. You were the third person to say I still think LR is a townie, which really worked well for you since you are in the same boat as her.

I voted to get rid of FF, there was certainly enough to think he was mafia which would be have been an added bonus, but I voted to be sure he was gone.

For the record I am thinking JB right now. He misquoted me and is picking things I think are not all that tremendous as reasons to suspect folks.
Click to expand...

How did JB misquote you? Unless I'm mistaken the whole thing is there and his response wasn't serious.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom