Mafia #69: Ghost Hunters Game Thread

[Lady G]

I'm voting for Ice because from what I can tell, he's the scummiest so far. If someone comes up scummier looking I'll change my vote. The mind games he's playing do not have a pro-town feel to me.

Really, if you look back...he mentioned it yes. Others kept bringing it up and decided it was a good idea I guess. Not saying he isn't evil, he very well may be. Not saying he is innocent either...I just don't know and really am not willing to take that chance just yet. If he is evil, it will show through.

I dont see anyone saying that their vote is going to an innocent...if there are ppl its hardly "most"

Nope, they didn't say they are voting innocent. The talk of voting vet innocent or noob innocent is all over the place though. I just do NOT like it.

 

[Lab_Rat]

I could have sworn it was mentioned (by someone else before) that you and him were on a team and you instructed him to keep quiet, no more posting... and that is what he did. This is not something from this game I remember byut one of the last couple of games. If I am wrong, by all means, correct me.

I think you're thinking of Ice being on the team with I Love Mollies last game.

 

[Lab_Rat]

Really, if you look back...he mentioned it yes. Others kept bringing it up and decided it was a good idea I guess. Not saying he isn't evil, he very well may be. Not saying he is innocent either...I just don't know and really am not willing to take that chance just yet. If he is evil, it will show through.

Nope, they didn't say they are voting innocent. The talk of voting vet innocent or noob innocent is all over the place though. I just do NOT like it.

You don't find it an odd thing for him to mention? Yeah, I'll focus on things I find scummy...I found his suggestion quite scummy. Why are you trying to sweep it under the rug?

No townie is going to vote for a noob innocent vs. vet innocent on purpose. I hope everyone in the town votes for who they think is scummiest. Scum team will probably go for the easy lynch, which right now is looking like FF.

 

[IceH2O]

the question you asked is in the post below


when I was reading this, I was thinking to myself, I was not sure what he thought, meaning whether he thought Lab was a better player than. Then I read his role play post where he explains that he does in fact believe Lab to be a better player than him. Well, he doesn't say so much in the post, but instead goes on how he thinks you and Lab are good players, will post like you two have and hopes to learn from it.... well, that is if HE is Mr. Palmer.

I could have sworn it was mentioned (by someone else before) that you and him were on a team and you instructed him to keep quiet, no more posting... and that is what he did. This is not something from this game I remember byut one of the last couple of games. If I am wrong, by all means, correct me.

Ok I haven't read any of his role playing posts. They do nothing for the game,from him or anyone else for that matter.

I've never been on a team with FF, Lab might be right that you might be thinking Mollies.

 

[[AC] maelstrom]

Really, if you look back...he mentioned it yes. Others kept bringing it up and decided it was a good idea I guess. Not saying he isn't evil, he very well may be. Not saying he is innocent either...I just don't know and really am not willing to take that chance just yet. If he is evil, it will show through.

Nope, they didn't say they are voting innocent. The talk of voting vet innocent or noob innocent is all over the place though. I just do NOT like it.

no one is seriously talking about voting vets or noobs or any of that LG. it was the initial suggestion that ppl are concerned with which is why it keeps being brought up...do you have any thoughts on the issue that arent wishy washy?

 

[BioHazard]

As an addendum to my previous statements...

 

[Lady G]

I think you are reeeeeeealy pulling at strings to find anything I've said scummy. How is it scummy to learn from a past mistake (that is, waiting too long to vote), and make an early vote based on what I know at the time, knowing that I would be able to change it later? I never know how busy or unbusy I will be, so I am planning ahead.

I don't think I'm "pulling strings" at all. Everyone is focusing so much on Ice and FF, just do not see either as the "most" scummy at this point. Ice through out a thought or idea, most jumped on it, FF is all over the place, making him a easy target... that really isn't much of a scum tell at this point for me with him.
Yes, it is good to learn from past mistakes...and it isn't bad to place a early vote, but in this post again you just did it...saying you placed it early knowing you can change it, at the same time saying you never know how busy you may be. It can't be both ways, I think you see Ice as a "safe" vote. If he does show innocent you can say "Oh I planned on coming back and changing it just didn't have time" "he looked scummy at the time" and so on.

 

[Dangerdoll]

hmmmm.... maybe, but I coulda sworn it was FF... my bad... sorry

 

[dirtydawg10]

Are Dawg and Annie even playing? Haven't hardly heard from either of them...laying low perhaps? Annie I expect it from, Dawg not so much.

Yup...I'm playing. Definitely not posting as much as usual but I'm still playing. I still don't see me voting for either Ice or FF. At least not yet. If Ice was evil I don't see him making a statement like he made. It doesn't 100% rule it out but I'm not seeing it right now. Same goes for FF. He seems to just be acting like FF. If either of them shows evil it will not be good for the other one.

I've been quiet so far for two reasons...yesterday was because I was recovering from sleep deprivation from my weekend fishing trip in NH. Today I just haven't been able to get a read on anyone and have just been trying to catch up.

The biggest thing that bothers me right now is LR and Kash saying they see Ice as scum yet they are both voting for Ice instead of FF. The problem I see with that is this is how Ice wants them to vote. If you distrust Ice why vote the way he wants you to vote?

 

[Lady G]

You don't find it an odd thing for him to mention? Yeah, I'll focus on things I find scummy...I found his suggestion quite scummy. Why are you trying to sweep it under the rug?

No townie is going to vote for a noob innocent vs. vet innocent on purpose. I hope everyone in the town votes for who they think is scummiest. Scum team will probably go for the easy lynch, which right now is looking like FF.

For Ice, no I don't think it is odd to mention. Not sure his true intention behind it, but I do not find it so odd. I didn't "sweep" it under the rug, just see no reason to go on and on about it.

no one is seriously talking about voting vets or noobs or any of that LG. it was the initial suggestion that ppl are concerned with which is why it keeps being brought up...do you have any thoughts on the issue that arent wishy washy?

I said what I thought.