Mafia #69: Ghost Hunters Game Thread

I vote to lynch BIO.

JRR that was a fine display of poor sportsmanship.

Sorry I wasn't here to switch to Mael. I fully intended to spend some time yesterday reviewing the thread, and didn't. I am overwhelmed in RL.

I was the kill vote on Lab and have been voting for Bio since Lab was lynched. Mael was blowing smoke my way for some time now. I think it should stand to reason I am not on a team with them.

Darn, innocent again.

Annie, maybe I was just tired reading all of Maels posts last night and missed it, how was Mael blowing smoke your way for some time now?

I do seem to recall when questioned beyond Bio, he would name a few others.

If I remember correctly, he did mention you as suspect but always as "less likely".
 
I retract my vote on Bio and vote to lynch CCM

I think we need to make this a 2 or 3 horse race at this point. If we are wrong or scum move around to save their own at least we get more information than everyone piling on one suspect. The odds are definitely with us but we need to get info from the lynches from here on out because I have a hard time believeing the EVP is going to help any more and we have no psychic or doc.

Dawg, I do agree with you. We learn absolutely nothing from landslide lynches and need to split up a bit to see who aligns themselves where.

2 or 3 horse race is good I would be leery of more than 3.

Off to work, hope I can get back early but as I said I will try with my laptop if it doesn't look that I will.
 
I retract my vote on Bio and vote to lynch CCM

I think we need to make this a 2 or 3 horse race at this point. If we are wrong or scum move around to save their own at least we get more information than everyone piling on one suspect. The odds are definitely with us but we need to get info from the lynches from here on out because I have a hard time believeing the EVP is going to help any more and we have no psychic or doc.

I think this is a good idea and I really like CCM as scum.

I retract my vote on Bio and vote to lynch CCM.
 
<game off> sorry y'all. You guys were way too into me being scum, and I UD'ed because I didn't have enough time to get into the game like i should have to prove that i wasn't scum. I chose to UD in order to quit wasting everyone's time and efforts. </game off>

You could have still placed protections...
 
Wiz made a good catch here -

I'm positive that the message would be from the innocent side, the evils get to communicate so why would they need to send a message?

2ndly, looking at the votes Annie was the kill vote on Lab. He was vote #3 and no one else got more then 2.

So the info looks good to me and I believe you.

I think we should take out Bio then we'll get Mael tomorrow.

Noods is a possibility as I explained earlier but I'm not as sure on that. I'm sure Noods wouldn't mind being a test subject as long as we still have numbers, meaning Bio and Mael are evil.
Her post stating she thinks she is being played or trusting someone she shouldn't could be positioning herself in case Mael got lynched.Also she got bent out of shape about me questioning only her .

I'm willing to lynch them in that order. I still think bio is evil more then I think it of JRR CCM or Rich.

Maels post about the train I think was to scare innocents off Bio.

Ice, what would have been the benefit of keeping Mael around? Did you have doubts that Dawg was telling the truth? Did you want to wait and see if anyone disputed Dawg's claim?

Why the rush on Bio?

Your thoughts on noods are kind of out there also. It was her switch that caused you to catch Lab, who you followed. Noods also waited until you switched before she switched.

You never jumped in there (one way or another) when I got vocal about the "where is John" posts after it had been less than 20 hours since my post and there was really nothing to add. Noods claimed I had been helpful to the town before. She has yet to post one example of how I have been helpful to the town.

You state "I'm sure Noods wouldn't mind being a test subject as long as we still have numbers, meaning Bio and Mael are evil." Well Mael was evil. Now if Bio comes up evil, I will still follow the Ice and noods show.
 
studying my notes and the vote counts I am starting to come up with some questions.

DD on D1 you had a lone vote on mael, based on the interaction between the two of you.

This interaction, I might add, was frivolous and more often than not just a distraction.

Could this have been distancing?

You voted to lynch LR but you were a late vote and your reason was to go with the "consensus of the town".

At this point, LR was pretty much a done deal as she started self destructing on D2.

On D3 you are also a late vote on Mael. Who had been outed as known scum.

Would you care to comment? Especially now that your vote sits on someone that Mael, known scum, was pushing for the lynch?

I will post other questions to other players as I get them.
on day 1 which is hard enough as it is, I came in and needed to catch up. Once I did, I found it interesting that Mael would even consider talking about who is behind the mask and said as much. I only wanted to say that trying to find out who was wearing the mask was so yesterday, where as Mael seemed to be insisting that I was trying to say that he actually suggested people start trying to guess....and then Mael continued to poke at seemingly nothing issues... this went on for most of the day.

Day 2 was a day after my birthday, which I had started celebrating already. I think this will be the 3rd time I am explaining this. Friday night, which was officially day 2's call, I was out at a party where my husband had a gig. I did not have too much time to read through things and was depending on the town for this. Yes, my vote was later on labby, but it was not a late in the day vote. I came to the board and posted, I wasn't sitting on the PC thinking... ok, is now a good time, is it too early to post, is now a good time? Come on, that's ridiculous. I was busy and got here when I could, period. The website where the pics are posted are at worldwithin.net, if you are that interested. Saturday night, my husband had a chili cook-off at his lodge. I didn't get any pictures of that though but I did get home really late and did not have a chance to check the board. Sunday, I was cleaning and all that fun stuff that I ignored due to the birthday festivities I enjoyed for the few days before that. Yesterday, I had a little time to try and catch up. We brought my nephew to the trainstation last night at about 9 so he could get back to his life in Brooklyn.

Day 3, same as before. I placed my vote when I got here. Guess what, DD does have a life besides sitting on AC's Mafia thread all day... who woulda thunk it??

Today, I have just gotten here, when my vote was placed on Bio, it was the consensus of the town that Bio was sure to be evil due to her previous posts and such... do you really need me to go and quote everything that led everyone to believe bio must be scum? As I am reading through today, more interesting things are being brought up. I see that the decision is to go for a tie for more than one person to better our chances on getting scum this night. I still need to read a little more thoroughly, but rest asured that I am back to regular hours.

Was that complete enough for you, Wiz... if you need, I guess I can break it down a little more but I don't think you need it... however, I won't be mad if you do... just say so.

As of this moment, I am not sure if I should be leaving my vote on bio or changing it to Cavie... gotta go back and read.
 
Dawg, I trust you way more than Ice and noods.

CCM has chased after me and baasically ignored everything else.

I retract my vote on Bio and vote to lynch CCM.
 
Wiz made a good catch here -



Ice, what would have been the benefit of keeping Mael around? Did you have doubts that Dawg was telling the truth? Did you want to wait and see if anyone disputed Dawg's claim?

Why the rush on Bio?

Your thoughts on noods are kind of out there also. It was her switch that caused you to catch Lab, who you followed. Noods also waited until you switched before she switched.

You never jumped in there (one way or another) when I got vocal about the "where is John" posts after it had been less than 20 hours since my post and there was really nothing to add. Noods claimed I had been helpful to the town before. She has yet to post one example of how I have been helpful to the town.

You state "I'm sure Noods wouldn't mind being a test subject as long as we still have numbers, meaning Bio and Mael are evil." Well Mael was evil. Now if Bio comes up evil, I will still follow the Ice and noods show.


I am just back from my Monday lunchtime study group but before I get back to work:

John, my "claim" that you were helpful was referring to the bush kicking you were/are doing; not a specific comment that was made. I do not see the need to pull all of those posts. not sure why you are so bent out of shape because I said you were being helpful. :screwy:

I am not really sure what being a "test subject" means but if it could somehow help root out scum or settle some concerns then by all means, knock yourselves out.

____________________________________________

I also would prefer to have a two horse race so if I need to move my vote to even up the race I would be happy to do so. (I left my vote tally sheet at home this morning) Bio and CCM seem to be on the same page with their comments and thoughts and since there is no comm. inno team it just kinda sticks out to me. could it just be noob confusion? maybe but seems scummy to me....the only one I feel confident with at this point is Dawg, based on the recent events.....
 
I vote to lynch BIO.

JRR that was a fine display of poor sportsmanship.

Sorry I wasn't here to switch to Mael. I fully intended to spend some time yesterday reviewing the thread, and didn't. I am overwhelmed in RL.

I was the kill vote on Lab and have been voting for Bio since Lab was lynched. Mael was blowing smoke my way for some time now. I think it should stand to reason I am not on a team with them.

Darn, innocent again.

Unless Lab was sacrificed by her teamates...
 
I am just back from my Monday lunchtime study group but before I get back to work:

John, my "claim" that you were helpful was referring to the bush kicking you were/are doing; not a specific comment that was made. I do not see the need to pull all of those posts. not sure why you are so bent out of shape because I said you were being helpful. :screwy:

I am not really sure what being a "test subject" means but if it could somehow help root out scum or settle some concerns then by all means, knock yourselves out.

____________________________________________

I also would prefer to have a two horse race so if I need to move my vote to even up the race I would be happy to do so. (I left my vote tally sheet at home this morning) Bio and CCM seem to be on the same page with their comments and thoughts and since there is no comm. inno team it just kinda sticks out to me. could it just be noob confusion? maybe but seems scummy to me....the only one I feel confident with at this point is Dawg, based on the recent events.....

What bush kicking? Whose bush did I kick? Give some sort of examples. Look at your notes.

I think "test subject" means is that we lynch you to find out what you are.
 
AquariaCentral.com