Mafia #77 Game thread- Back to the basics

Zaffy said:
I vote to lynch Piranha.

Reasons are the same as before. I think his whole Blackmail scheme is ridiculous. In light of Labby turning up innocent, (Pir wouldn't have known she's the doc yet). I feel like he used that as an attempt to protect her and buddy up to someone who he knew would flip town that night.
Click to expand...

He was at least trying. What have you done so far?
 
the wizard said:
I have to say that I agree here. You handled that wrong LR and cost us a good player and the Dr with one last minute post.

Sorry you were hit and sad to see you go Ice.
Click to expand...


Guys I'm not seeing any benefit in beating up the dead. Labby made a mistake she can see that without all of us pointing it out to her.

Let's move on and find the scum.
 
Chill said:
Guys I'm not seeing any benefit in beating up the dead. Labby made a mistake she can see that without all of us pointing it out to her.

Let's move on and find the scum.
Click to expand...
I agree.

We all also made a mistake. Now that I am looking back at it we should have piled on labby even with the RC. The mafia would have switched their hit but we wouldn't have lost 2 innocents...... Well, in theory.

Well, I am off to bed.......
 
Kashta said:
Dawg, I think the point to be learned here is it would have been okay for Labby to post about either her theory or to role claim her role... just not both at the same time with little time left for us to process/discuss both pieces of info together.

Lab is the one who took herself out of the game based on the posts she made. I'd say the same is also true for Ice. He's the one who put himself up for lynching when he decided to post about someone by name that he thought was a townie PR. Us vets keep telling the noobs not to do this... ever. Had Ice followed that same advice, he'd still be alive now. When the rest of us were compelled to switch off Lab Rat after she RCd, Ice wouldn't have been in the running based on lingering doubts about his allegiance that he drew upon himself.
Click to expand...

It doesn't matter. She had to RC in order to give her theory that was the problem. I agree they both got themselves into hot water. I do see that the lynch could have been changed to a mafia but the odds weren't good of that happening.
 
rich311k said:
Why Haydn?
Click to expand...
He's quiet and scummy.
rich311k said:
He was at least trying. What have you done so far?
Click to expand...
Thank you.
dirtydawg10 said:
Where does it say I think Salt is innocent? Lab had the most votes and so she would have been lynched and the mafia would surely hit another innocent. The comments about Ice, LR and Salt were in saying that LR couldn't have known she was gone until very close to night anyway.
Click to expand...
You said the votes were b/t ice lr and salt, you said we would have lost innocents either way. Sorry, guess I misread that.
Chill said:
Guys I'm not seeing any benefit in beating up the dead. Labby made a mistake she can see that without all of us pointing it out to her.

Let's move on and find the scum.
Click to expand...
THANK YOU!
RazzleFish said:
I agree.

We all also made a mistake. Now that I am looking back at it we should have piled on labby even with the RC. The mafia would have switched their hit but we wouldn't have lost 2 innocents...... Well, in theory.

Well, I am off to bed.......
Click to expand...
Thank you, and good night.
 
Here's a good place as place as any to start:

IceH2O said:
ok looking at votes Lab Salt and me are all tied at 4.

I'd watch those on any of us.

My gut and posts I've read I'd say on:

Salt watch Wiz and Razz

On Lab maybe Kash I don't feel anything on the others

On Me they all gave me the willies at one time or another but mostly Pir and Mav.Rich worries me just because he is voting me because I'm protecting a possible PR.
....
Click to expand...

My money is still on Pir for scum but I'm going to go back and look at Ice's suggestions here before I vote. Not sure I have the clearheadedness to do this tonight though.
 
Chill said:
Here's a good place as place as any to start:
My money is still on Pir for scum but I'm going to go back and look at Ice's suggestions here before I vote. Not sure I have the clearheadedness to do this tonight though.
Click to expand...
I love it how if someone dies and they were innocent, their theory is immediately correct. Honestly, if it looks like I'm getting voted off, I'm going to start screaming who I know is scum.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom