Dawg, I think the point to be learned here is it would have been okay for Labby to post about either her theory or to role claim her role... just not both at the same time with little time left for us to process/discuss both pieces of info together.
Lab is the one who took herself out of the game based on the posts she made. I'd say the same is also true for Ice. He's the one who put himself up for lynching when he decided to post about someone by name that he thought was a townie PR. Us vets keep telling the noobs not to do this... ever. Had Ice followed that same advice, he'd still be alive now. When the rest of us were compelled to switch off Lab Rat after she RCd, Ice wouldn't have been in the running based on lingering doubts about his allegiance that he drew upon himself.