Mafia 78- The Gunslinger Returns...The Play

[jbradt]

I don't see a whole lot more in the thread worth commenting on specifically, but I'll put my thoughts out there for you one more time, Wiz.

Right now I'm looking at Ice, Rich and Jspigs as probable for reasons I think I've made clear.

I'm looking at Tay, Pappy and FF as possibles. I think I've made those reasons clear too, but if you want clarification, just ask.

 

[IceH2O]

I snipped a bit out of Ice's long post. I don't have a lot of time today, but Ice; I'd really like to see the post where I took back my anxious feeling about Pappy-dew. We have a very friendly relationship on AC in general, so friendly posting is a norm for us. That hardly means I don't think he's scum anymore.

I say all that just to say that because I'm posting in a friendly manner with Pappy in no way means he is clear in my mind. Again, I'd love to see you pull the post where I stated I no longer suspected him.

Now I see what you mean. I was concerned about a lack of posting early on. When that picked up today, it made me relax a little about you. Now that I understand the misunderstanding, I'm a little less anxious.

Its this quote, where I said the post must have been a Tums/Rolaids post for you. I said you became friends over the Jpig case. I took less anxious as less a suspect which means to me, not as much a threat. Do you have to say I no longer suspect someone in those exact words? Is there anyone you don't suspect?

 

[jbradt]

Its this quote, where I said the post must have been a Tums/Rolaids post for you. I said you became friends over the Jpig case. I took less anxious as less a suspect which means to me, not as much a threat. Do you have to say I no longer suspect someone in those exact words? Is there anyone you don't suspect?

There is a huge difference IMO between "a little less anxious" and "no longer suspect". Truth is I always suspect Pappy. The level of suspicion that manifests will vary throughout the game.

Yes, I don't suspect Wiz. :silly:

But to be serious, I've put my lists/thoughts out there from the beginning of the game. I have yet to hear a reason that makes sense to me of why you suspect me.

 

[IceH2O]

Some thoughts by several others would be nice....Hay, Dag, Salt, Pir....come on, do none of ya having anything to add?

No crap guys, between the 4 of you there are 28 posts and 16 of them are Pirs.

Makes a good team to look into if we start picking off innocents, possible they are just laying back and letting us take one another out.

 

[IceH2O]

There is a huge difference IMO between "a little less anxious" and "no longer suspect". Truth is I always suspect Pappy. The level of suspicion that manifests will vary throughout the game.

Yes, I don't suspect Wiz. :silly:

But to be serious, I've put my lists/thoughts out there from the beginning of the game. I have yet to hear a reason that makes sense to me of why you suspect me.

Doesn't need to make sense to you, only needs to make sense to Wiz, myself and anyone who might become slinger.

 

[jbradt]

Also, you can believe that when I no longer suspect someone, I will say so specifically. Pappy's responses to my questions made sense as I know he did just move back to school and into a new house. Does that make him innocent? Not hardly, but it's a plausible reason/excuse for his relative absenteeism that was making me nervous.

 

[jbradt]

Doesn't need to make sense to you, only needs to make sense to Wiz, myself and anyone who might become slinger.

Fair enough, but just because it makes sense to you does not equate with being right.

 

[IceH2O]

Fair enough, but just because it makes sense to you does not equate with being right.

Did I say I was right? I could be totally off, if I got the gun I sure wouldn't just turn around and take my shot. I'd take the 48 hours to question and rethink if my suspect list is correct or not.


Ok Wiz put out the question to the town who would you shoot if I turned up scum.

I think he should have also asked who would you want me to shoot when I turn up innocent?

 

[Dagamoth]

alrighty then. even though not everyone has given me an answer about who you would shoot right now, the consensus seems to be Ice and for basically the same reason.

Let me set up a hypothetical (that means pretend) situation. You are the gunslinger. You just shot Ice down in the street, and still have the gun. So Ice then has turned up scum. The deadline approaches, YOU have to take your next shot now.

Who will it be?

Why?

So I just woke up a little bit ago and started reading what I missed since I went out yesterday. Off of what I have read so far it would most likely be a coin flip between Rich and Chill. I have gotten a little defending Ice vibe from their posts and Rich with his "Shoot Lady G post". I haven't gotten much of a scum vibe from Lady G so far but I do know in the past she has a tendency to mistake scum for innocent.

 

[Dagamoth]

No crap guys, between the 4 of you there are 28 posts and 16 of them are Pirs.

Makes a good team to look into if we start picking off innocents, possible they are just laying back and letting us take one another out.

I'm not 100% sure that you realize it is the weekend and has been since this game started. I have been enjoying my weekend and haven't been around a computer the whole time. I just finished reading what has happened since yesterday afternoon and I will comment on what I see that has been important more in depth when I get back from the store. But for now I just want to ask the question are you looking at the big picture?