I would Vial John test sploke and invest myself or Pir
No, I think Sploke is most likely scum.
I said to test JL because if he is scum you get one and if not you lose an innocent
If you vial Sploke, who I believe to be scum then you get an innocent back, provided the vial doesn't kill them. If Sploke was scum and the vial doesn't kill him then you get an innocent back and remain neutral ( gain one to the one you lost ) and the scum loses one.
These two posts are at odds with each other?