Mafia 79:Bio Badlands Game Thread.

Lady G said:
WOW, never mind...itwas FF that said it, not Pir!!!!

UMMMM, FF you can't do that what do you mean YOU set up a trap?
Click to expand...

According to the rules, the testing would take place before the lab worker's vials. We voted to test the lab worker (UN), on the same night UN told FF he wanted to use one of his vials. Now, as *I* understand it, the vial would never have gotten used, because of the order of deaths, UN was dead by the time the vial usage would have come around. However, as FF stated, he felt bad for UN, so he made up this story about how UN actually set a trap to use the vial before he died, so even though the rules clearly state the order of deaths, he was able to use his "special power".

game off

This is exactly the kind of monkeying with "clearly stated" rules by GMs that caused me to stop playing these things in the first place. In this case its not much of an issue since the vial used was the babble and really had no effect on the outcome of the game, but on principle its still a load of BS in my opinion.

/game on.
 
Chill said:
So what does everyone else think of JL's plan?
Click to expand...

I think it is more of Ballyhoo's plan, but I understand it.

I would much rather be tested than turned. I would like Sploke turned (or killed). I think investigating Ballyhoo would be best.

If I am innocent, turning me creates another scum. The down side is that if Sploke is innocent, then another scum has been created. I think it can be safely assumed that neither of us are BE, so even if the town looses an innocent - it will not be a PR. After nightfall the town will know everyones status. I think it can be assumed that at least one of us is evil.
 
Razzlefish - dead, evil, tested D1
User_Name - dead, innocent, tested D2
Jpappy - dead, innocent, killed by evils D2
Rich311k - dead, innocent, killed by Dr. Gene

Lady G - innocent, BE
Chill - innocent, BE?
2Hobbies - innocent, investigated by BE

Ballyhoo - ?
Sploke - ? (innocent)
Johnlarson - ?
Piranha - ? (presumed innocent, late addition?)

Correct me if I'm off anywhere in there. I don't care between Bally and JL which one gets tested and which one gets a vial as I'm pretty certain that it will end up as a win for the town either way, unless Pir came in as evil which would be pretty crappy.
 
Of course I would rather be the one getting investigated, but I seem to be a top suspect of LG, who is confirmed innocent.

LG, I know you think I would hit you day one, so I understand why I am a suspect. I would not have hit you, rich or jpap on day one. Take that for what it is worth. Now day two, is a different story, but day one I would have went a different direction.
 
Bottom line for me is that I do not want another vial.
 
Lady G said:
WOW, never mind...itwas FF that said it, not Pir!!!!

UMMMM, FF you can't do that what do you mean YOU set up a trap?
Click to expand...

I mean I looked into the future and decided i would let him still use the vial by setting up a small trap. In the end it came down to a coin flip.

Sploke said:
According to the rules, the testing would take place before the lab worker's vials. We voted to test the lab worker (UN), on the same night UN told FF he wanted to use one of his vials. Now, as *I* understand it, the vial would never have gotten used, because of the order of deaths, UN was dead by the time the vial usage would have come around. However, as FF stated, he felt bad for UN, so he made up this story about how UN actually set a trap to use the vial before he died, so even though the rules clearly state the order of deaths, he was able to use his "special power".

game off

This is exactly the kind of monkeying with "clearly stated" rules by GMs that caused me to stop playing these things in the first place. In this case its not much of an issue since the vial used was the babble and really had no effect on the outcome of the game, but on principle its still a load of BS in my opinion.

/game on.
Click to expand...

sorry, too late now.


Vote count:

Sploke(1):JL
JL(1):Sploke

Nightfall tonight at 8 pm. No one else has voted.
 
johnlarson66 said:
I think it is more of Ballyhoo's plan, but I understand it.

I would much rather be tested than turned. I would like Sploke turned (or killed). I think investigating Ballyhoo would be best.

If I am innocent, turning me creates another scum. The down side is that if Sploke is innocent, then another scum has been created. I think it can be safely assumed that neither of us are BE, so even if the town looses an innocent - it will not be a PR. After nightfall the town will know everyones status. I think it can be assumed that at least one of us is evil.
Click to expand...


There is a 3rd Pr, the person with the vials and there are no safe assumptions on that.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom