Mafia 86: The Wolfman Game Thread

[Ninja Pigs Rock]

I think Piglet means that you were telling people to stop trying to come up with ideas and now your complaining because no one is talking. I don't get it either, but he seems to know what he's talking about... sort of...

thats is correct. he seemed rather defensive to me. and complained about the questions being asked. but then you decide to state that no one is talking. you cant put down input and then complain about the lack of input.

 

[jpappy789]

thats is correct. he seemed rather defensive to me. and complained about the questions being asked. but then you decide to state that no one is talking. you cant put down input and then complain about the lack of input.

That would make sense if I was talking in terms of the same person or people. I was "complaining" about Pir trying to make something of what UN said and made an observational comment about a lack of input from the town as a whole.

 

[Fishfriend1]

Ok, I'm going to be using some point Pir made in this post. It has little to nothing to do with Un's post. So don't say I'm using the Mods posting for anything, k?

That kind of got me thinking.

Ohh, haha got it now.

JPap tries to be funny or something.

UN, bored with an empty thread, decides to be funny back.

Then, he realizes "Oh ****, JPap actually is scum!"

I kind of think "wow." wouldn't be an appropriate answer. Just seems a little too non-joking compared to the "darn, innocent again..." The whole thing was just a little off IMO.

Remember, there isn't much to go on, and it's about the best I could come up with, but hear me out.

JPap starts out as the scum. He would probably be a good choice for D1 scum. He gets to pick someone to have as another scum. Looking at the player list, if I were JPap, I would probably choose Lady G or 2H. Both are experienced in mafia, just as JPap is, and would be a good 2nd scum.

If I had to vote now, I would probably vote JPap. But seriously, it's the best I can come up with. I just want the actual gameplay to start.

If the evils saw this, they would be able to hit/turn 2H and make Pappy look bad. Hey look who got hit? 2H. Why would Pappy hit 2H after what Pir said? He obviously noticed it, so who in their right mind would then go and do exactly what Pir said they would? No one, thats who. I think the evils are trying to set pappy up. The Un/Pappy thing was just an extra, IMO, for the evils to try and work with.

That said, i do not think pappy is evil, not right now anyway.

This is the first of a number of posts i am going to make in an attempt to see who is evil and who isn't. Wish me luck

 

[Ninja Pigs Rock]

Well... Jp is vocal,

2H has made a few mistakes.

FF is quiet as is his brother

G is her silly self

Piranha seems to be helping the town

I have to place a vote before I go to bed invade I don't get up in time and the scummiest things I've seen so far are 2Hs mistakes and JP defending him. On a team? Maybe. Something to ponder.

I vote to lynch 2H

May be wrong but my most informed decision thus far

Night all.

this is the only semi-protown post i have seen by hay. he doesn't seem to really be helping the town much if at all. he seems to be lying low, jumping in and out. seems kind of scummy to me.

Wow that's a hard nightfall I guess I was right about pir. JP and ninja, I would like to hear your explanation for the vote on pir.

again a in and out post. he comes in for one post and then leaves. this is his first and only post so far after night fall. it seems like there would be more to talk about.

hay's just not sitting write with me.

 

[Fishfriend1]

Cooool game. Lol.

Jp, why were you so keen to defend 2H after his little mistake...?

hay casts doubt onto Pappy without making it look like much, doesn't really mention it again, but i do think LG does, need to check that.

Well... Jp is vocal,

2H has made a few mistakes.

FF is quiet as is his brother

G is her silly self

Piranha seems to be helping the town

I have to place a vote before I go to bed invade I don't get up in time and the scummiest things I've seen so far are 2Hs mistakes and JP defending him. On a team? Maybe. Something to ponder.

I vote to lynch 2H

May be wrong but my most informed decision thus far

Night all.

Makes no real comments on anyone except 2H, votes him. Gives no reasons for anything he said about the rest of us.

FF if you read the thread you would see where I'm coming from

Yes 2Hs mistakes may of been just mistakes but that's all I had to go on and FF, I just woke up hence not answering questions.

As far as Pir goes, it's the fact that he is putting in effort and actually putting ideas out there. What has screwed mafia over had been people not posting, piggy backing and getting away with it. Yes, maybe some of his thoughts are wild or wrong but at least he's putting in the effort unlike others whom I'm not going to name. If your not going to play with 100% effort don't play at all.

End of rant.

He even notes that 2H's mistakes could be just mistakes. If he thought that, why vote him?

Wow that's a hard nightfall I guess I was right about pir. JP and ninja, I would like to hear your explanation for the vote on pir.

The only post since, and an entire night to post though. Where did he go? Is he letting the thread seep a little to see what we townies end up dishing out on each other? Or does he have a valid reason for not showing up?

All in all, I still think hay is evil, on to the next fella. Oh, I vote to lynch Haydn.

 

[Ninja Pigs Rock]

this is the only semi-protown post i have seen by hay. he doesn't seem to really be helping the town much if at all. he seems to be lying low, jumping in and out. seems kind of scummy to me.



again a in and out post. he comes in for one post and then leaves. this is his first and only post so far after night fall. it seems like there would be more to talk about.

hay's just not sitting write with me.

hay casts doubt onto Pappy without making it look like much, doesn't really mention it again, but i do think LG does, need to check that.



Makes no real comments on anyone except 2H, votes him. Gives no reasons for anything he said about the rest of us.



He even notes that 2H's mistakes could be just mistakes. If he thought that, why vote him?



The only post since, and an entire night to post though. Where did he go? Is he letting the thread seep a little to see what we townies end up dishing out on each other? Or does he have a valid reason for not showing up?

All in all, I still think hay is evil, on to the next fella. Oh, I vote to lynch Haydn.

My for the reasons i stated above, and the one FF did, I vote to lynch hayden

 

[Ninja Pigs Rock]

Well... Jp is vocal,

2H has made a few mistakes.

FF is quiet as is his brother

G is her silly self

Piranha seems to be helping the town

I have to place a vote before I go to bed invade I don't get up in time and the scummiest things I've seen so far are 2Hs mistakes and JP defending him. On a team? Maybe. Something to ponder.

I vote to lynch 2H

May be wrong but my most informed decision thus far

Night all.

Also hay gives decent thing to think about to all of us. yet he neglects to say anything about LG besides she's being her silly self. this is after the turn so maybe LG and hay are on the same team.

 

[Ninja Pigs Rock]

can't think of anything else to say at the moment. I have stated my cases, hay, and possibly LG.

 

[Fishfriend1]

The statement took me back also, I know he explained what he meant to say but it still doesn't sit well with me either. I completely get the whole if they go after a CI they wont get a turn, but to hope they do instead of hoping they just don't get the turn...I just don't know

Agrees with Hay (who I think is evil) about the 2H thing, which we all know wasn't valid as 2H turned up innocent.

So, how exactly is voting someone b/c they UDed last game and most likely isn't WW NOT a crap shoot?

Adds to the case against Pir, who we now know was innocent.

Well... Jp is vocal,

2H has made a few mistakes.

FF is quiet as is his brother

G is her silly self

Piranha seems to be helping the town

I have to place a vote before I go to bed invade I don't get up in time and the scummiest things I've seen so far are 2Hs mistakes and JP defending him. On a team? Maybe. Something to ponder.

I vote to lynch 2H

May be wrong but my most informed decision thus far

Night all.

Makes absolutely no comment on LG except to say she is acting normal. Neither saying she is innocent or evil, maybe to allow him to be flexible with her, in case he has to vote her later on...?

Well, so far there isn't much to base a vote on (never is on day 1) and I hate it.

We have 2H "mistake" which I'm really not sure was a mistake, as I do see his point of what he was trying to say...the thing is, is that REALLY what he meant or was it a easy cover up of a mistake.

Pir, attempting to draw attention to what UN said after Pap claimed "innocent"-He say's it was just a silly post and meant nothing, but the fact he put it out there doesn't sit well with me.

Ninja, posting then stopping after the change...that does seem odd to me also.

FF, with only one post...wow, just wow that is very unusual.

Adam, with no posts at all?

These are the only things that remotely "stand out" to me at this point and none of them are much of anything, but on day one we never have much to go on. The big difference in this game though from other day ones, we really can't afford for mistakes..... I HATE THIS!!!

Hay, I was wondering where/how you see Pir as being helpful?

They both posted lists on other players, Hay first, cause he's up sooner, LG second as though she had seen it in the chat. Why, on day one, would you do this?

Nice of ya to show up FF :clap:

I hate answering for someone else, but since I don't think he will be back before nightfall (he said he was going to bed).
The "mistake" was saying we hope "to" get a CI for the bite, instead of saying "hope the WW get a CI". He did explain, he was meaning if the WW bite a CI they will not get a turn.
The defence by Pap i believe was the fact Pap answered for him.

Defending Hay???

How is it piggybacking when I questioned you first? Just because LG voted before me doesn't mean I am following. All that points too is that she got online before I did...

Voting for a UD is a cop out. Always has been and always will be in my mind. What can we possibly learn from that? D2 becomes D1 all over again.

So LG piggybacked too... interesting.

There is a difference here FF, when Pir suggested it..his reason was because he UD LAST game, nothing to do with this game and it was still rather early...he DIDN'T say it was to try and only loose 2 instead of 3..his ONLY reason was because he UDed last game, adding to it he didn't think UN would let Adam be WW

Continues to go after Pir, who we know is innocent.

I am confused as to why 2H died though, if he wasn't a CI...shouldn't he still be with us?

With US? Why US? Why not, with the evils, or with the town? Slip of the tung, maybe?

Also hay gives decent thing to think about to all of us. yet he neglects to say anything about LG besides she's being her silly self. this is after the turn so maybe LG and hay are on the same team.

You noticed too? Cool, I'm not just seeing things after all.

So, right now my list of the two evils would be LG and Haydn. I also think that LG was the first evil, and that she turned Haydn, probably because they had no one accusing them at the time.

So, what does the rest of the town think of that? I'm off to look into the next guy now.

 

[jpappy789]

FF and NPR...

Savesd by the sister! She wants a "girls day out" so i don't have to go! Halalua!



missed this...

I think Piglet's just getting distracted with COD (call of duty). Foolish child, so easilly distr... ooh, a butterfly.

Ok, so my reasons for voting hay are as follows:
1. Accusing 2H for some "mistake" that I totally missed.*
2. AFAIK, hay never actually answered why he thought Pir was innocent.
3. Where did Jp defend 2H?*

*Can someone point it out for me?

In response to Tank saying something about NPR, FF covers for him.

Ok, so after re-reading the game (again...)
I still think that Hay is a good choice.
But I also think that Pir is not evil, he does seem to be trying.
Piglet still seems innocent to me, mostly a gut feeling though.
Pappy... well, he's neither evil nor innocent, i don't have a major read on him.
2H- Hasn't done anything i see as scummy, yet.
Tank- Well, besides that confusing bit about #2, I have no opinion of him, good/evil, yet.
LG- Always worth watching, IMO. Nothing scummy yet.
AA- Doesn't seem to be trying at all.
FF- a confused and distracted 17-year-old who is nonetheless awesome

Un, your comment with Pappy, and Pir's thought process afterward is really screwing with my head. I curse your for all eternity to stand there as the Bala statue, unable to leave the town square. May your boredom be eternal.

Anyway, thats all I've got for now. Any questions?

NPR had barely posted anything to this point yet FF has him as innocent based on a "gut feel"

<snip>

This is the first of a number of posts i am going to make in an attempt to see who is evil and who isn't. Wish me luck

FF says today that he is going to look at previous posts...

this is the only semi-protown post i have seen by hay. he doesn't seem to really be helping the town much if at all. he seems to be lying low, jumping in and out. seems kind of scummy to me.



again a in and out post. he comes in for one post and then leaves. this is his first and only post so far after night fall. it seems like there would be more to talk about.

hay's just not sitting write with me.

A couple minutes later NPR pops in with some things on Hay.

<snip>

All in all, I still think hay is evil, on to the next fella. Oh, I vote to lynch Haydn.

FF then returns, also with some stuff on Hay (cut out for length) and votes.

My for the reasons i stated above, and the one FF did, I vote to lynch hayden

NPR votes Hay as well, a couple minutes later.

This is after NPR already gained a couple of votes today. Seems far too coordinated IMO.