Mafia 87: The Play, Basic Game

[Ballyhoo]

<snip>

Good job on genetics. Does this mean you'll be able to tell what color/variety everyone's baby fish will be? :grinyes:<snip>

I just might be able to!!

NPR in Pink! I know this was pointed out already, but it really does strike me at odd as well. It's in past tense, but rich was still alive at this point. I think the 5th vote was on so he was dead scum walking, but does this indicate that NPR had already abandoned rich?

Good point.

what was happening was us arguing about weather it was a set up or not. he was set up when the hit happened then it was pure discussion. so the set up was in the past and the argument was in the now.

is the set up in the past though ( well at this point it is obviously ) but at the time was the actual hit the set up or the subsequent discussion?

Starting at your vote.





I agree!

This feels helpful, but it could also be planting a seed of doubt in someone who was going pretty hard against scum.

:woot:Congratulations!!:woot:



I think this is pretty much a defense of Rich. Saying that the hit was an attempt to set him up. I think it's an attempt to seed more doubt.



Backpedaling, it's looking like the heat on Rich isn't fading.




I think Lady G said it best.

Also, you were #2 on him, which is the best place to hide according to Rich. By the time others piled on, you had no choice but to stay. Rich took one for the team.

What say ye?:hitting:

I could have changed my vote, but either way it was darned if I do and darned if I don't. If I changed my vote the questions that followed would be that I moved my vote to prolong nightfall. I went with what I believed true.

So, it looks like I logged off a little early last night, and missed the hit.

Based on the rules and the order of nightfall, I thought the hit came after the lynch. Ah well.... it is a FF game. Expect the unusual.

So at 10:30 FF tells everyone the evils can hit whenever they want and it will go though as soon as he see's it. At 10:40 Rich votes Haydn, and twenty minutes later the scum hit Haydn.

That changes my top three.

Rich: Either someone wanted to set you up, or you wanted to say "why would I hit my vote" I'll place the lynch vote if you get one more.

Zaffy I pulled this quote to also answer you question, it was said that the second vote was a good place to hide, but you said that rich can't be trusted. This by 2H is interesting, he said that if Rich got 4 votes he would be the lynch vote. This seems like the best place to hide for a team member.
Also I find it odd that he had logged off early and missed the hit.

g/o Off topic, but I wanted to share.

I had a terrible genetics class. On our 2nd of 4 exams the prof decided he wanted to "try something new." The average among all of his classes on the exam ended up being somewhere around 25% (it was multiple choice, 5 answers, so a drunk monkey would be expected to score 20%). It was an awful experience, I remember when I turned in my test and I was walking out the door there was a girl just sitting at her desk crying. Luckily he curved the scores, I had the 2nd highest grade at something like 45%. It was terrible.

So, really, great work on the A!! I mean it

g/o

Thank you and everyone else for the congratulations!

 

[TwoHobbies]

Also I find it odd that he had logged off early and missed the hit.

It's not that odd if you consider that I post during the day from work, and log off when our office closes. Just so happens that last night I didn't go directly home.

 

[Ninja Pigs Rock]

Then right after the vigilante hit G we get this post. Maybe I'm reading something into it that isn't there but he almost seems pleased.

Note to the vigilante: You were not in risk of being lynched and the town had numbers. What were you thinking?

And once again, he seems almost giddy.

If there are two scum left I still think it's likely NPR & PIR, but if we are down to one I believe we are looking for Ninja.

Now Ninja, I know I've been saying you haven't been playing a good game, but I'm here this morning saying I was wrong. I really believe you were playing a poor innocent game, but that's because your not innocent. You have actually played a very good scum game.

um if i recall the post i said rich is being set up is post 413 and the post were the hit on LG is is 457. there for there is no way that my post that you qouted was "right after the hit on G" because that post was before the hit. get your facts right before you make accusations.

Ninja: Are you serious? Rich being scum of course.
Please look back at my post to Pir. G gave me enough to believe she was innocent.

then you should have quoted it in your post would of been easier to tell what you were talking about. On the note of 2H's recent false accusations i vote to lynch 2H

 

[Ninja Pigs Rock]

darn forgot to retract. i retract my previous vote and vote 2H.

 

[TwoHobbies]

um if i recall the post i said rich is being set up is post 413 and the post were the hit on LG is is 457. there for there is no way that my post that you qouted was "right after the hit on G" because that post was before the hit. get your facts right before you make accusations.

Read the whole post Ninja. My comment is before the quote not after it.

 

[TwoHobbies]

darn forgot to retract. i retract my previous vote and vote 2H.

So, moving your vote from one innocent to another huh. Can't say I did see that coming. :22_yikes:

 

[Piranha86]

This is becoming a bit of a stalemate...

 

[Ballyhoo]

Good job town, I'm thrilled to see that went our way.

This quote is just a little too off..
I vote to lynch 2H

 

[Fishfriend1]

Vote Count:

2H- 4 - Willard, Pir, Ninja, Bally
Bally- 0 - Ninja
Ninja- 1 - 2H

Votes locked! PMs as required. Nightfall will occur when all PMs are in and votes needed have been met.

 

[Fishfriend1]

NOTE: If i do not receive PMs within 12 hours I will continue with nightfall with or without them.