Mafia 92: Night of the living Mafia... the play

[IceH2O]

I think that Noods is an innocent and that Ice and Doom are going out of their way to try and force us to think other wise. That fact that we were wrong last night does not change the feeling I had about Noodles. She changes votes often so the one switch during the day does not bother me much.

I think the hit on 2H was to just get us off track or more confused than we are.

I'm leaning her innocent until proven guilty. Its something I've been thinking about only and not a case built against her. If I thought my idea was very likely I would have voted her.

 

[noodles62]

As I read through the posts last night and saw the results of night fall, I keep getting this nagging feeling that I am being fooled by one or more of the best players we have. I just cannot figure out who and it is driving me nuts.

This is exactly what I was talking about last night before nightfall. Something stinks in Denmark. The way Day 2 went down just feels bad to me.

In other news - I love how several of you state that "noods will pop when squeezed if scum." What am I, a zit?!

Someone (I think it was Dawg, maybe Ice) is curious about my vote for Tank on nite one and stated that I had not even mentioned him before. I am certain I mentioned Tank during that record breaking eventful day 1. When I have the time I will look for the post.
Also, the other player I looked into and considered posting a "case" on was Wiz. I read through and then had my doubts; hence no "case." I still am not feeling really good about the way Wiz commented several times about "wishing he know how many scum there are", but I am willing to accept his explanation for now.

 

[Lab_Rat]

I'm not sure what to think about anyone. DD's flip-flopping has me quite concerned. Tomorrow I should have more time to re-read, once my family leaves.

 

[noodles62]

I really like this post. I think the conclusion is far fetched, but it may have some nuggets in it. When we take a razor to the theory and cut out all the fat, I think it comes down to this.

Noods caught Razzs slip. When a teammate catches someone else there are two options 1. Hope nobody else catches it. or 2. Call them out.

1. This is a big game, almost 20 players, with many vets. Hoping that none of these players sees what Noods saw is a risky play. It's possible to lose your teammate on day 1 with no gain.

2. By calling them out, you assume the same risk in potentially losing a teammate, but you gain the potential to be cleared as a townie in many peoples eyes.

If Noods calls razz out on the slip, then she is obligated to vote him. She'd look very scummy if she didn't. When the town starts to take hold of the idea she drums up a story that something "piqued" her interest but she doesn't have time to explain or prove it. She then retracts her vote. For some reason that I don't think is ever really explained, she posts her vote on Tank and leaves it there until near nightfall.

30 mins before nightfall Noods is actively posting. At 20 mins untill night I switch my vote form JM to Razz, this takes JM off the block and puts Razz there instead. Noods posts again. With 9 mins left Mad calls noods out and shows that she can break the tie, and save the town from a no lynch all by switching her vote to one of her "suspects."

With 2 mins left she finally switches her vote and we kill scum on night 1, Noods is a Hero!

What bugs me, is why wait until so close to nightfall. She could have switched as soon as I made my switch. If she wasn't thinking about it, no big deal. But she went back and forth with Mad over it.

Maybe she was hoping someone else might come in and break the tie and lynch Cnote instead?

Or Noods is really a townie and actually caught a legitimate slip! Perhaps a first in her mafia game career, but stranger things have happned! Can a girl get come credit please?

 

[[AC] Doomsday998]

Or Noods is really a townie and actually caught a legitimate slip! Perhaps a first in her mafia game career, but stranger things have happned! Can a girl get come credit please?

Yes, that is also possible. If so... :cheers:

 

[noodles62]

Here is where I mentioned my suspisions of Tank on Day 1.

I am confused (no snickering!) Tank, first you say doomsday started a train on JM (which consists of a whopping single vote) but then you state he switched over to FF and forced him out of the game. not seeing a vote switch here, nor seeing how any one player forced FF out of the game. Can you explain?

Well, I have to get back to work. I would like to see responses from Razz and Tank but at this point my vote would go to either one. Will have to read over one more time before I vote..........

I never said you believed that mafia turned into zombies. I said (perhaps not clearly) that you insinuated that you did not have the option of taking a zombie hit if you were lynched. Ihe only people that do not have the option of a zombie hit are mafia - which indicates that you are mafia.

I am still on the fence with Tank. his explaination seems confused at best, but willing to watch for now. That being said, I vote to lynch Razz.

Now I am done defending myself, I have more important things to tend to.

 

[[AC] Doomsday998]

Here is where I mentioned my suspisions of Tank on Day 1.



Now I am done defending myself, I have more important things to tend to.

Now I'm the one who's confused. You thought that case on tank was stronger than the case against Razz for the slip.

 

[noodles62]

Not necessarily stronger. I was second guessing myself on Razz, due to jpap's "interpretation" argument and tank was my next suspect.

 

[noodles62]

Addition- it was day one. While unusually active, it was all I had to go on.

 

[rich311k]

Just read all of this again. I am not liking the exploration of Nood's just don't buy the argument she tossed a buddy under the bus and I don't trust the people who are throwing it out there.

I can see the miss trust of Ice he just begs to be suspected.

I am not sure at all about Wiz, or Kashta right now. they seem be helping, but cant really see that they have said anything.

C-note, Ratty and Tanker I have not seen enough today from them to get anything. C-note is still high on my radar from the first two days. He is just not adding up to me.