Mafia 94: When Gingers Attack; the play

[Lady G]

Still getting caught up here:



I stopped posting Tues night around 9ish and had that thought after. By the time I logged on Wed morning Kash had already commented on it.

Yes I said "likely", Is the number of Gingers really that important? How about you tell me exactly how many to you there are?

Yes, it is important 2H...keeping the town "guessing" is a way of distraction IMO. I would say there are EXACTLY 3 at this point with a possible 4th when they use their syrum. Since the RULES state 3 evils and JB confirmed the roles are in the rules.

 

[Lady G]

No G, I was re-hashing an earlier post were she stated I hadn't posted, but missed that Wiz hadn't either. I believe Zaffy and others commented on it. I'm surprised you missed all those posts.


Funny that you would say that here, because back in post 253 you corrected Wiz about her, pappy, and I.

I didn't miss post's 2H..you commented a couple times yes, rehashing what others had already said pretty much...but I never saw anything that looked like a "case"...your agreement with Kash about Chill actually had me thinking you were looking more at CHill then anyone.

Funny to me you didn't pull the post, instead you make others go back to see what is said (which wasn't much of anything)...

Sure it wasn't Plant and 2H or Pap?


Thanks Wizard...yeah, it's ok.


Welp...that does it, you go to the mall instead of home to play mafia...YOUR EVIL!!
In case someone does not get it....that was SARCASTIC.


AWWWW, you remember (this game I think calls for a little better though LMAO "Crown sounds good" for this one!

Here is the post you were referring to...as you can see, it wasn't really a "correction" it was more a joke to him about all the back and forth stuff that had been going on at the time.

 

[TwoHobbies]

As opposed to those that voted a innocent off...Oh yeah, your name was there...why would we look at those votes?

Look at anyone you want. After giving it some more thought. I believe everyone voted for an innocent last night. I don't think there was a "ginger" on the board anywhere.

 

[RazzleFish]

Look at anyone you want. After giving it some more thought. I believe everyone voted for an innocent last night. I don't think there was a "ginger" on the board anywhere.

And what exactly made you come to this conclusion?

It's a pretty bold statement to make early in Day 2...

 

[TwoHobbies]

i was on your side. saying why would we look at the people with low votes while there must be a reason for the high votes on the other players.

The reason for high votes is bad play (been there done that). Don't want to sound rude, but you could have easily been up there. It's only your second game, folks are letting you play so you can learn.

 

[TwoHobbies]

There seemed to be a lot of inconsistencies from Plant from the beginning. The shorter day 3 thing, then implying JB told us roles were hand picked. The post of Kash's really bugged me and made me wonder if it was a post meant for the scum den. If it was a post meant for the scum den, that meant that Plant was scum as well. I went with Plant because in the case I was wrong (which I was, at least about Plant) I wouldn't vote off Kash. No offense Plant, but Kash, if innocent, is very valuable to the town (of course if she is scum she's very dangerous). Since I don't know Plant's level of play, I felt it was safer to vote her over Kash. That may sound stupid, but that's how I made the decision. It was either that or flip a coin.

That being said, I don't know who my top suspect is. I think we need to figure out who would see Zaffy as the greatest threat.

Not sure he was the greatest threat. Possible someone had a hint/feeling he was a PR?

 

[TwoHobbies]

So basically anyone remaining but Pir, or Kash...way to narrow down that list 2H!



Jessica Rabbit has a 50/50 turn-kill vial. I think that was what he was referring to...

Your right Jpap. I made that post after quickly looking at nightfall, and being very surprised that the cartoon syrum wasn't used. After looking over nightfall this morning I'm thinking everyone up was innocent. That makes this the list

Razzlefish
Dangerdoll
Allaboutfish
Jpappy
Lady G
Rich 311k
Wizzard

From that list I'm going to remove Allaboutfish, and Rich. AAF I'll still give more time, and Rich because If I'm right there would be no reason to risk a late vote move like he did.

 

[dirtydawg10]

I went back to look at the voting close to night...

I have work in an hour and therefore will be gone for nightfall...and need to vote now, unfortunately.

I vote to genetically test Plant

I do not like the "low post" (for lack of a better term) angle she is trying to play and she has been building up to the vote by mentioning it over, and over that we need to post more.

Normally I would have waited for a reply first but I dont want to UD either...

JPap with the first vote on Plant for "low post" theory which turns out was not exactly Plant's theory. This was determined prior to nightfall. At least by me anyway. Then 2H followed up shortly after JPap with another vote on Plant.

I vote to lynch 2H

2H, you came on saying how there could be more then 3 evil (after someone else mentioned it), you questioned Plant even telling her to "re skim" the rules after she said something about 3 PRs, after JB even said the roles are in the rules you still said it is "likely" 3, then followed Kash's thought on Chill not adding your own thoughts, then after Pap votes Plant, you do?

I need to reword my vote....I vote to genetically test 2H


It is 8 central


It's annoying as heck!! After the last upgrade to the site, it just does that now

Then LG "lynches" 2H and comes back 1/2hr later to change her wording to "genetically test". I point this out because no one else voted in between LG's 2 posts. It made me wonder if someone told her she needed to reword her vote.

I retract my vote vote to geneticaly test Pir

and I vote to genetically test Kash

This change in vote from Chill caused a 3 way tie between Pir, Plant & Kash. Good strategy usually to see where votes fall when players are tied up for the lynch (Gen. test)

I retract my vote on AAF and vote to genetically test Plant. Maek it a little more interesting and the vote on AAF is a waste.

Rich puts Plant in the lead by one vote.

Nope, I haven't voted yet but I guess I am going to have to.

I have been having mixed thoughts about Plant and Pir. While I disagree with Lab about this latest conversation with Kash, I don't like her pushing for posting. In addition JB's green letters are making me think.... As much as I try though, I cannot bring myself to vote her over Pir. While he is usually this way, his "I just didn't bother to look at the list" (or somehting like that) doesn't sit well with me. So for that reason, I vote to genetically test Pir.

Razz ties it up between Plant and Pir.

I wanted to get this out for everyone to look at and comment on.

Look at anyone you want. After giving it some more thought. I believe everyone voted for an innocent last night. I don't think there was a "ginger" on the board anywhere.

2H so you have 8 people on your innocent list already? Sounds like you have this all figured out...but I highly doubt you are right.

 

[dirtydawg10]

Just for clarification I did not comment on all the posts between JPap's and the final vote. Just the ones that caught my eye as critical votes close to nightfall. The other one which isn't in there is LR's sudden change of heart from voting Pir to voting for Plant because of a comment Kash made. That one still doesn't make sense to me even though she explained her reasoning.

 

[dirtydawg10]

posts in the first sentence should be *votes