Mafia 94: When Gingers Attack; the play

[TwoHobbies]

I am attempting to find out why Rich has been defending you. I n order to do that you need to pull things together. Any thoughts as to why only 2 people voted for both of the innocents that got tested?

Any thoughts on why their reasons for voting that way seem suspect at best?

Care to address why you have been reading the thread but didn't answer my question of why you didn't switch off Plant and vote Chill since you thought the same as Kashta about him?

Nope

Nope

At the time Plant was the bigger risk to the town.

 

[the wizard]

Nope

Nope

At the time Plant was the bigger risk to the town.

So then if I understand you correctly, the player that D2 stated with certainty that there weren't any gingers on the chopping block D1 and also got the town sidetracked with a discussion about why the serum didn't get used by the scum team (that took up an entire day) all of a sudden has no thoughts and thinks that someone that was trying to get the town to post and discuss was a bigger threat to the town than someone that he feels was not helping the town.

Not the confident charge in and kick butt attitude you have shown up to this point in the game.

Is the scum den getting a little nervous that maybe connections are being made between team mates?

 

[the wizard]

Looking through today's posts it really looks as though Rich has been defending 2H. I would really like to hear from Rich about this.

Rich, why have you been defending 2H?

Do you have any thoughts as to why there were only 2 players that voted both of the innocents that got tested?

Do you have any thoughts as to why their reasons for their votes seem suspect at best?

 

[jpappy789]

Guys, I'm here, reading through everything now.

Had to go pick up my aunt from the airport. (she's flying in from New Zealand)

Got those quotes from last night yet?

Nope

Nope

At the time Plant was the bigger risk to the town.

Can you further explain this?

 

[the wizard]

From what I have seen I would say that Rich and 2H are my top suspects.

I need to go through and see if I can try to find another (original) ginger. It is too early to try to figure out who the turn was but I will be watching for a change in posting.

 

[RazzleFish]

Looking through today's posts it really looks as though Rich has been defending 2H. I would really like to hear from Rich about this.

Rich, why have you been defending 2H?

Do you have any thoughts as to why there were only 2 players that voted both of the innocents that got tested?

Do you have any thoughts as to why their reasons for their votes seem suspect at best?

From what I have seen I would say that Rich and 2H are my top suspects.

I need to go through and see if I can try to find another (original) ginger. It is too early to try to figure out who the turn was but I will be watching for a change in posting.

Just out of curiosity, do you really think two gingers would get that close? It wouldn't be very smart to outright defend a scummate in the game thread.

 

[the wizard]

I'll be working late tonight and then have to work a 12 hour shift tomorrow so will be missing nightfall, which sucks. Here are my thoughts at the moment...

Razz- it bothered me a bit when he kept saying the scum should use the vial on a known PR but other than that I haven't gotten any other bad vibes
DD- she's been pretty absent, not sure either way although she did seem to be the only one who went after Lab
AAF- seems to be progressing slowly but it is still hard to ignore some things said earlier in the game, at the same time I would have a hard time bringing myself to vote for him right now
Chill- no idea on chill, he's been pretty focused on Kash so I would like to know more of about his current suspects
LG- I flat out think she is scum since the sudden change of heart moments before nightfall after pushing all say for 2H
Rich- I do think it is interesting that he was pretty convinced 2H was innocent yesterday without seeing him work through any posts as 2H wasn't exactly straightforward
2H- I can see why he was on the chopping block yesterday
Wiz- I'm not one to get a read on Wiz although it looks like he is going to be doing the same thing as LG yesterday, which is worrying me at the moment
Kash- Her vote on Dawg was scummy, simple as that
Pir- he was non existent yesterday after getting A LOT of heat D1, should be interesting to see what posts he pulled before they mysteriously disappeared...

So I'd say my current "list" is...

LG
Kash
Rich
Pir?

I dunno really who the fourth would be since the turn just happened last night. Right now I think any of those could fit into the original three mafia spots. But I do have to vote now in case I cannot get online again before nightfall.

I vote to genetically test LG

Today is the first time since the game started that I have been able to dig through the game with a clear head.

Everything I have seen thus far has pointed to a connection between 2H AND Rich.

Looking at the post 2H made about Rich does it not read as though Rich was defending 2H and trying to take some of the heat off of him?

 

[Piranha86]

Here we go...

Look at anyone you want. After giving it some more thought. I believe everyone voted for an innocent last night. I don't think there was a "ginger" on the board anywhere.

I don't think it's ever safe to say there was no scum on the board, especially D2.

Your right Jpap. I made that post after quickly looking at nightfall, and being very surprised that the cartoon syrum wasn't used. After looking over nightfall this morning I'm thinking everyone up was innocent. That makes this the list

Razzlefish
Dangerdoll
Allaboutfish
Jpappy
Lady G
Rich 311k
Wizzard

From that list I'm going to remove Allaboutfish, and Rich. AAF I'll still give more time, and Rich because If I'm right there would be no reason to risk a late vote move like he did.

Now AAF is innocent, suggesting a connection.

too much disscusion on the syrum. we wont get anywhere talking about it.

He hears LG and 2H talking about how they wish the syrum weren't being discussed, and decides to act on it.

This is the post that (I think) got Labby killed.

JB, hope everything is ok. Zaffy, me thinks you should zombie hitman mod kill whoever put the hit on you. :thm:


Why do you want to dismiss all the discussion about the serum? You don't see any value from the discussion about it?


Idk why he didn't mention me, but I would hardly call it giving advice to the scum team. My real interest was in trying to figure out Razz's intentions.

Both 2H and Dawg have been acting off, but I can't say that either are scummy enough for my vote. To me, I think 2H seems more frustrated trying to get his point across than anything, but I'm not quite sure how to take what he's been saying. Dawg has said some things that raised my eyebrows at first, but after thinking about them more I'm not convinced he's scummy.

The two players on the top of my suspect list are LG and Razz. LG is there because she is the one who thought Jessica Rabbit's serum could backfire on her. This would make total sense as to why the serum was not used night 1, when it would make the most sense to use it. LG was pretty confident sounding in that post, about Jessica possibly getting killed. It would not surprise me if she was confident enough in that thought to not get clarification from JB. Razz's insistence on the serum being better used on a PR makes no sense. I see he is now retracting his argument, but he fought pretty hard for it. As I said earlier, I'm thinking this may be so he can say that he wouldn't have used the serum on a townie in the event the serum is used and hits a townie, trying to clear himself as scum.

Right now, LG is more scummy imo than Razz. I vote to genetically test LG, aka Jessica Rabbit.

I think the fact that she used the specific role got her killed. Labby was a PR (the doctor.) I'm really thinking that the investigator checked out LG, and she came up as Jessica Rabbit. The scum saw that Labby knew the exact position, so they assumed she was detective (or at least a PR). They acted on this...

CRAP! I VOTE TO TEST DAWG.....I RETRACT MY TEST fROM 2H

This is interesting to me... I think this was planned in the den. THey figured if someone thought that was scummy, they would say, "If we were team-mates, we wuold tell eachother in the den! Therefore, we can't be team-mates." The fact that the same thing happened yesterday is what set me off.

uhuh they "disapeared"

Coming from the grand-king-vet of mafia....

And we'll hold you to it...

I'm glad you did

I think pretty much everyone agrees that LG is scum. so... I vote to genetically test Lady G.

 

[the wizard]

Just out of curiosity, do you really think two gingers would get that close? It wouldn't be very smart to outright defend a scummate in the game thread.

It really depends on who the gingers are. They have taken out 3 townies and 2 PR's so far. They have increased their number by one and managed to distract us with our discussions from D1.

If they are getting cocky enough, they might get a little too close in the game thread. I could be wrong but as I said this is the first time I have been able to dig through this with a clear head and everything points that way.

 

[TwoHobbies]

Can you further explain this?

It was meant to be a joke Jpap. It was Wiz's reason for voting Dawg yesterday. I don't see why I should have to answer a question like that. I asked Chill one question. Why should I changed my vote?

Wiz is just trying to keep me talking because if I talk enough I screw up. Is that not painfully clear.

If I was one of three scum would I be talking this much? Does anyone think I'm that stupid? Am I chuck? Wouldn't one of my teammates have told me to shut up long ago?