Mafia 95 - "Mayor's Mansion" (The Play)

jpappy789 said:
Does it not seem risky to place a vote on a teammate which ties it up and then assume that one of the two people yet to vote would break the tie? Pir had been a no show all day.
Click to expand...
Yes, unless they are on the same team.
 
mostlycichlids said:
Yes, unless they are on the same team.
Click to expand...

Well, if they are on the same team and wanted to save Spencer as per your original theory then they obviously failed in doing so as it still came down to a coin toss.
 
jpapp, I would like to hear your thoughts on who might be mafia and innocent....and why as well as everyone else's thoughts. So far I am the only one to vote and it seems if I have had to defend my choice of voting the whole day...

We cant afford to loose more innocent players this early and the vigilante has already been hit. I would suggest some more posting and would like to hear from a few who havent been posting much to aid in finding some scum.
 
jpappy789 said:
Well, if they are on the same team and wanted to save Spencer as per your original theory then they obviously failed in doing so as it still came down to a coin toss.
Click to expand...
Obviously, so what else do you want me to say? Do you have any other suspects in mind if so please share?
 
mostlycichlids said:
LG, papp always plays his roles good either mafia, PR or townie, is he always someone to watch yes but I never said he wasn't innocent but he hasnt said anything to make me think otherwise. Why would you come in with limited computer time and ask me this of all things? Has papp said anything to make you lean towards mafia, am I missing something please let me know?

I guess it don't really make sense why she would and I guess that she could of placed a vote somewhere else. But what if chill or our UD would of came in and placed a vote on FF then DD would not of looked too guilty at all as others placed a vote on Spence.

I would also like to know?

Are you saying you helped lynch an innocent really?

Dawg (481) Wizard (600) Chill (733) DD (645) Ok, so wizard, chill and dawg voted to lynch DD in the first night. Today has turned up some suspicion on wizard and chill, we will get to that later. Look at the final votes on DD minus dawgs vote, Wizzards vote was late and then chill was last to cast a vote. Neither of them had much to say about DD beforehand. Those votes to me were safety votes, dawg may also of been playing safe.

I am not going to repeat myself over and over again.

How is it scummy please elaborate?
Click to expand...

Maybe I am just slow but according to what I am reading, you have repeated that DD voted spence to save him.

In the above post you are looking at Dawg,Chill and myself for voting DD.

Correct my if I am wrong here. Your hypothesis is then that DD is scum and voted her scum teammate spencer. Dawg, Chill and myself are scum and voted our scum teammate DD.

Is that what you are trying to get us to believe?
 
mostlycichlids said:
jpapp, I would like to hear your thoughts on who might be mafia and innocent....and why as well as everyone else's thoughts. So far I am the only one to vote and it seems if I have had to defend my choice of voting the whole day...

We cant afford to loose more innocent players this early and the vigilante has already been hit. I would suggest some more posting and would like to hear from a few who havent been posting much to aid in finding some scum.
Click to expand...
Why were you so quick to vote DD, right after nightfall?

At this point I don't know who is scum and who is innocent. I am not sure where my vote will fall. One person I'm thinking of voting for is Chill. I do not like how he wanted a tie. I will wait for his answer on why he wanted a tie so badly before I vote.

I also have no idea what Kash is up to with this whole blackout thing.
 
Zaffy said:
Without quoting all the times Wiz said this, I think this one sums it up well enough. I think I see what you mean. I've had this thought in previous games, especially on day 1 the status quo favors scum. I admit that I skimmed a lot of what happened before nightfall, but 16 of us piled onto two players(myself included). In retrospect that should be a huge rad flag, especially on day 1, that the scum is going to win the night. I don't want to clear spencer, but after having some time to think about it I certainly have to lean him towards innocent.

It's food for thought at least.
Click to expand...

You are the only one to quote me from yesterday and not throw me on the BBQ........ you must be scum.

:grinyes:
 
mostlycichlids said:
jpapp, I would like to hear your thoughts on who might be mafia and innocent....and why as well as everyone else's thoughts. So far I am the only one to vote and it seems if I have had to defend my choice of voting the whole day...

We cant afford to loose more innocent players this early and the vigilante has already been hit. I would suggest some more posting and would like to hear from a few who havent been posting much to aid in finding some scum.
Click to expand...

I'm not pretending to know anyone who's role has not yet been revealed.

So far my focus (for lack of a better term) has been on you, Chill, and wiz. Your theory made no sense from the beginning. I still do not like Wiz's "leaning innocent" list and Chill's vote and subsequent explanation has not made me feel well about him.

Spencer still screwed up big time yesterday so he is up there and I do find the point that NPR (and then Lab) made about UN's vote interesting but he has disappeared too.

mostlycichlids said:
Obviously, so what else do you want me to say? Do you have any other suspects in mind if so please share?
Click to expand...

MC, this was your theory...not mine. You used your thinking to place a vote that is still official. I, and others, have questioned your thoughts because they do not make sense even though you seems to be modifying them every time you post.
 
As you all know, I usually place my vote before work on a day with nightfall because I can never be sure if I can get on prior to nightfall to vote any other way.

I am not sure where to vote this time. Yes I voted DD for what I read as a contradiction and a gut feel. However, what I have been reading from MC today seems questionable at the very least. With him so unsettled in my mind I don't think I would feel comfortable voting along side him on DD.

I would like to see more from him before I vote.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom