Mafia 96 Who Are You? Game Thread

What did I gain to benefit by pushing for a tie?

I only know UN is scum because of the lynch, I didn't know beforehand same as I don't know AAF is scum or not right now. Only that his actions are scummy and at the time was one of the main places to put a vote. I voted DD for something I think scummy and because AAF isn't a main threat, not as much as DD can be at least. Also at the time of my vote I was hoping for a more spread out vote. But the situation changed so the thought pattern also had to change. Since both were thought scum, thought being the operative word, then there was no reason not to take the chance at the coin flip. If one was innocent and the other scum without any hard proof then I'd rather the coin decide then choose wrong on our own.

If I thought AAF was more likely scum then UN or vice versa I would have just followed the rest onto them and had them hang. AAF already was in the lead and if not hadn't been pushed back would be the one lynched. UN made a bad choice and got piled on only because night lasted longer.


Since you aren't smart enough to figure out the strategy on your own I'll spill some.

At this point there could be as many as 3 communicating players per team. They will not defend one another but if you are innocent and someone comes out and says I think you are innocent then there is a good chance they investigated you and know your innocent, so you can conclude they are on the scum team. Doesn't work as well if they come after you because you can't tell if they are innocents reading you wrong or not unless you see a "team effort" trying to get you lynched.
 
I didn't say that we would have learned something had everyone voted for UN but in your own words "his obviously scummy move" should have made it a definite vote for him. I don't get why you would risk not having him lynched after "his obviously scummy move" just to have the tie with AAF. I would much rather everyone vote for they think is scum rather than "go for a tie" especially when you can't learn anything from the tie.

While I didn't say I thought the tie idea was bad at the time I did start questioning you about it:

to which you never answered my question, you only said I never thought about not knowing what time nightfall was. Had I said I think it's a bad idea about the tie at the time I believe you would have responded with something to the extent of "oh are you nervous about losing one of the people up there and trying to save them?"

Have you forgotten you said this:

Yeah I almost started thinking he had to be innocent to pull something soooo scummy right during the whole debate about that happening on the last lynching. glad i kept my vote with my gut after he did that.
And you're right, I would have questioned your motives if you said it was a bad idea...but since when are you worried about being questioned? Have something to hide?
 
Sorry, it's a holiday weekend so my time is going to be limited. I also have quite a bit to do this weekend already so I don't screw myself over during the week.

I vote to lynch AAF

I'm comfortable with that vote and not sure I am going to have a whole lot of time tomorrow to do any serious digging.
 
That makes no sense.

I retract my vote on Zaffy

I vote for User_Name

The final vote tally doesn't show it but you voted Zaffy 1st then UN after his UD vote. At the time AAF was still in the lead, what good was your vote change going to do when you switched to make it a 2 person race.

If you thought being spread out was best then you should have stayed on Zaffy who I moved to also to make a closer 3 way race until I saw the tally was wrong and a vote on Zaffy did no good anymore since you moved?

Your vote on UN just made it a tighter 2 person race so there was no reason or capable way to keep it spread out when 9 of 14 votes were already on 2 players.
 
I'm not going to argue it anymore, if you like your vote on me then great. Just understand I couldn't and didn't benefit by pushing for a tie. There is no strategy in it at all. I don't look any better that UN showed scum so I can't take any credit for it. If anything I'd be more screwed if he came up innocent. So tell me where you see strategy and how I benefited from it?

Kash if you'd pull the posts for me since I can't find them.....where did the majority of the town decide it was best not to spread out the votes?
 
a 3 person tie isn't likely with people who are willing to switch to save themselves.
 
AquariaCentral.com