Mafia #98: The Grinch Returns -- The Play

Excuse me while I think out loud. If LG is telling the truth, then she would have had to use her power after night fall D2. That then brings up the question of why she voted Kashta D3 instead of JP.

We also have the question of when did Santa invest JP was it D1 or 2? Could it have been D3?

Was Ice allowed to continue communication after he was hit?
 
LG went after Kashta D3, much too hard for it to be distancing IMO. I have seen her vote team mates when scum, but I have not seen her go after them in the game IIRC. I do need to review D3 all over again. It seems as though, the only thing LG said D2 that I was able to agree with is that JP could also post as he was doing when scum.
 
Current vote count:
Wiz (0) - AAF (#725), FF (#740)
FF (1) - Dawg (#785)
Dawg (1) - FF (#789)
Pappy (2) - LG #790, Bally (#802)
LG (1) - Pappy (#809)

No votes: everyone else.


Nightfall in 2 hours and 38 minutes. PMs as needed!
 
Yes, I was nipped. Sorry it's been hectic with everything going on...I had just skimmed over nightfall and then the posts beforehand when I did post last and just wasn't thinking straight after seeing Bally RC and name me. I don't see any reason for people to not believe Bally now. I do expect people to not believe me entirely, but I'd rather not leave it in the dark at this point in the game.

According to Lab's PM I cannot reveal any info on specific roles, which I assume means I cannot name scum or any roles we previously investigated.

Now to explain my behavior:

Me picking to vote Bally at first was to stay consistent. As you can see above I could not come out and state I knew Kash was scum and I was going after Bally quite a bit the day before. I tried to make it seem like I really was torn between choosing Bally or Kash because I didn't want to break the rules and because I didn't want to seem like I was doing a 180, which would be just as suspicious. It's also hard for someone to be working with a team for the whole game and then suddenly be told you have to switch allegiances. I will honestly say that I thought about still trying to help the scum team, regardless if I would have technically lost or not.

I will say with Rudolph gone and with all the innocent RCs (which I hate) that I don't doubt the scum are close to finding Santa. I don't think scum expected Rich to step in with the hit either and for all we know that may have saved us another day. The town cannot afford to lynch an innocent tonight.

My vote will come shortly. I need to figure out how to say this without breaking any rules but also in order to give the town info.

It seems to me JP that if you were switched by the nip, you would have been able to switch your vote and not cause and issue with the town winning or losing even if you were communicating scum. You are one of the best in the game. It also seems to me that if a players role causes one to switch sides, then their new team is who they should be playing for.

Why would you not have voted for LG with the argument I had put out there? If she is scum, as you are stating now we still would have lynched scum.
 
It also doesn't say that it was successful. This will require some thought. Time to dig some more.

I read it with the intonation that it was successful, but I also had a biased opinion because I wanted it to be successful.
 
I read it with the intonation that it was successful, but I also had a biased opinion because I wanted it to be successful.

I am not sure which way to think right now. All I know for sure is when scum, JP is dam near flawless with his posting.
 
Well we lynch him he's the grinch we win we lynch him and he's innocent then scum get 2 innocents but only win if they get Santa..... I have no clue. My gut doesn't seem to like lg though.
 
Then that brings up the question what is AAF, he tied it up iirc because he was confused, so he made a choice in the most indecisive way
 
Ooops, to LG's first post I wanted to say that I went back and checked my roles and the only one for the innocents' that would make sense is this...

Sugarplum Mary- if given to an evil elf they are no longer in communication

But no mention of "sugar cookies" in my notes. Also Lab could have easily changed those around.

You stated that the name LG claimed to have did not exist in your game. In light of the above statement do you not think it possible that LR might have made other changes?
 
AquariaCentral.com