Mafia 101 - Blarney Castle: Return of the Leprechauns - Game Thread

[Lady G]

im not even on old3toes. im on HI IQ

LOL...face palm to self!!! Sorry AAF, I read your post as to mean you are voting them and don't want to move because everyone else is on them also. I see what you meant by your post....again, sorry about that.

 

[jbradt]

sorry guys... my internet is being obstinate. i'll be around when i can

Sent from my MB865 using MonsterAquariaNetwork App

 

[the wizard]

O3T's last post was on page 16, #162, reads

"You're right, my mistake. For some reason in my head I thought Lab said that Chill was the non communicator but he could have been with the team.

That does lower LG on my list then."

I find this post and the silence following incriminating, but the post by chill everybody keeps linking is #158 which reads


"I would say that LG's vote doesn't do anything to make me learn her one way or the other at this point. No one except Chill [would've] knew he was scum."

I find this post to be pretty much common knowledge but its the one that everybody is talking about. The only thing is that the lack of the word [would've] leaves out the sense of doubt that we should all have. I've read all of the posts but there are lots of opinions based on fairly subtle things, it takes some time for a fella to process and whats so bad about a little ambiguity?

I am commenting as I go along playing catch up so if this has already been addressed forgive me.

The reason everyone jumped on that post is that we don't know that Chill was the lone leper in the woods. For someone to state that only one scum player knows his role reads as if the poster was in communication with the scum team and not with the individual. Thus the "slip".

 

[the wizard]

Ok, not that it is a big deal but actually I think you are both wrong. Chill and I mess with each other quite often yes...but I don't think either of us vote the other very often on day one unless there truely is something behind it. I actually was worried others would question me about my vote simply because we really don't vote each other often in a "random" vote and Chill is a bad one to loose if innocent. The only reason I actually did it this time was because I did actually have a "feel" from his posting, yet I wasn't sure and didn't think he would really get voted off on day one so it was a way to let him know I had that feeling, but if I was wrong he wasn't really threatened.

Now, I do find it interesting that both Kash and Dawg are saying we often vote each other day one.


This question is to Dawg also...did either of you feel Chill would come on and break the tie?

For now I vote to lynch O3T I just can't over look them saying Chill was the only one who knew he was evil.

Please explain to me which of his "game related" posts before his UD gave you this "feeling" I could be wrong, but, I don't recall seeing anything out of charachter from Chill except the lack of hospitality(he didn't offer me a single drink) and he UD'd.

 

[Lab_Rat]

Current vote count:
O3T (8) - Dawg (#164), JB (#168), Hi Iq (#171), Zaffy (#180), Kash (#195), Wiz (#209), Fozzy (#211), LG (#219), Driver (#221)
Hi Iq (1) - AAF (#185)
Kash (2) - O3T (#217), LG (#235)


PMs as needed. Nightfall in 24 minutes.

 

[Lady G]

Please explain to me which of his "game related" posts before his UD gave you this "feeling" I could be wrong, but, I don't recall seeing anything out of charachter from Chill except the lack of hospitality(he didn't offer me a single drink) and he UD'd.

Wizard, I can't explain to you an exact post that gave me a feeling, all I can say is when it comes to Chill (along with a few others) when I read their posts I just get this knee jerk reaction that they are scum. I normally do not play on it until later after seeing more from them...but it is just something that happens there is no way I can say exactly what does it or why...sometimes I am wrong, but many times I am right and I end up kicking myself for not playing on it because I am to afraid that I am wrong. I will say I did not vote him in hopes others would follow, because I didn't but I did get a feeling from his posts that he was not the sweet, innocent (I use that term loosely LOL) Chill I have come to know and love.

 

[Lady G]

I still would like to know if Dawg or Kash thought Chill would vote to break the tie and what they would of done had he not

 

[the wizard]

Slow day I see. Not a lot to read through or catch a slip or real importance...kind of puts folks in the position to ride the "wave" on O3T (can't see it as a train right now), throw another random out there since there wouldn't be any quotable justification for it. I think AAF's vote on HI Q is really their version of an OMGUS vote over the previous banter. I'll take the wave for now...subject to change...not that I see enough new input happening to do so...

I vote to lynch O3T...

I have read this post three times and all I can say is ????????????????????????????????????????

What exactly are you trying to say?

This post reads to me like you don't see the slip as a slip. Now I could be wrong, I spent all night reading this thread looking for questions to pose and it took all night because all I could see was O3T saying only Chill knew his role. I cannot imagine even a newb if on the towns side saying anything like that when the person in question flipped scum. A non communicating scum, IME, is a rarity.

So it almost seems to me that you are reluctant to vote Toes but want to blend in.

 

[the wizard]

Not much to catch up but this caught my eye.







I think its interesting that both of you wanted the coin toss to go the other way to see if it told you anything about Toes but neither of you moved to AAF to find out. If someone piques your interest and its Day 1 with not much to go on,never mind the fact innocents usually go first, why not vote a person that would in the end tell you more about another suspect?


Wizard, I didn't take over where Toes left off. I wanted more clarification and to be sure, I couldn't just write it off as ok I believe you. Just because Toes was happy with his answer I was supposed to accept it? Anything after post 182 was just messing with him because I was bored and he was making me laugh by getting frustrated.

I have to wonder if you guys didn't move to AAF and are targeting those who question him because you are protecting him? Besides Toes. He was already screwed before you came on. Is this a plan to attach him to me and get me lynched next?


At this point I'm not getting a warm fuzzy feeling about either of you and one of you will likely be my vote tomorrow.

First and foremost, I didn't switch to AAF because, he doesn't have the experience of others in this game and if scum will likely slip up and we will find him. Second, he was being for lack of a better term seriously attacked by more than one person past the point where he usually gets confused because he is flustered and lynches himself. This time he didn't "change" his story when trying to explain it multiple times and I applauded the growth that it showed.

You think I am scum for not switching to a lesser player that is being attacked by a better player on D1 when the only reason was to learn about the alignment of the attacker?

Fine. Vote me. If you get me lynched it will leave, to quote Will Smith in I Robot, "bread crumbs".

 

[Lab_Rat]

It is night!

Vote count:
O3T (8) - Dawg (#164), JB (#168), Hi Iq (#171), Zaffy (#180), Kash (#195), Wiz (#209), Fozzy (#211), LG (#219), Driver (#221)
Hi Iq (1) - AAF (#185)
Kash (2) - O3T (#217), LG (#235)