So Rb said it had 1400+ posts (a rather specific number), was an earlier game (how early?), and simple. I'm wondering if he's referring to Mafia #4?
That would be fun...was my very first game I think. I had just as much of an idea of what was going on at the time as I did all of this game...
I think you're right. #4 fits the bill for the timing, number of players/roles, and total posts. It looks fun too.
If we really want to drum up some new players I could do a one-time invite through my work's social network. There's a lot of hobby and personal interest stuff there. I would just have to explain what mafia is and how to play.... it would help promote the site overall too for anyone interested in fishkeeping.
The only thing is what if we get 20-30 noobs showing up with an interest? Someone would have to explain this to them. And we'd have a game full of players no one knows who are just learning it themselves. Plus, I doubt newcomers to the site would be willing to read an old game just to play.