MAFIA #5 The Play.....

[mee-mee]

Hurray for game 5...Lets get it on....so now I am on the regular path, and I already see a pattern forming in the game right away....So, I will just sit here and watch very carefully....

Kim's Pastry shop is up and running again...and this time she IS not going to let anyone stay in her shed behind her shop....So, if anyone (except Mafia) wants a pastry, feel free to stop on by...got some new ones to try out...and they are delicious...and her trusted guard dog Mr. Gordita, the ever beloved chihuahua, is still with her...and DD, no more wedding dresses for you either...

 

[OgreMkV]

Geez, 6 pages already.

Remember everyone, over defensiveness is a sign of mafia, underdefensiveness is a sign of mafia, ignoring attacks is a sign of mafia, counterattacking is definitely mafia, and posting too little or too much is mafia.

I think that covers it

Just remember to explain why you think a certain way. Take a look at game 4, if the mafia hadn't attacked JMax, we wouldn't have believed her (at least I wouldn't have). Also, this is the first lynching, unless the mafia screw totally up, it will almost be a random lynching.

In fact, I'm almost considering suggesting that we not lynch anyone tonight and give the detective time to work. But we don't learn anything in the process. Everyone else's thoughts?

 

[judgemax]

this is for JO: well, i fixed that, and i am a female, ..for those of you who didn't know, and you said so in your last small paragraph in your last statement...and in no way to I expect to be considered innocent right away, its ok, if you want to think me mafia, your supposed to, ..I am no different than i was last game, ..iam a lil weird, a lil forward, NO MAFIA THOUGH..and so I voted first, ..I am excited..woot!

 

[joander123]

Remember everyone, over defensiveness is a sign of mafia, underdefensiveness is a sign of mafia, ignoring attacks is a sign of mafia, counterattacking is definitely mafia, and posting too little or too much is mafia.

looks like me know? Surely i have to be a mafia??? Not...

 

[joander123]

ahh, i see what you are thinking judge, that was meant as is he thinking the same way as me, and he is using what i think he may be using as i stated in my above post, which is simply calling attention to oneself, while trying to make others think that he wouldnt call attention to himself if he was indeed a mafia. So therefore he must be!

 

[judgemax]

ahh, i see what you are thinking judge, that was meant as is he thinking the same way as me, and he is using what i think he may be using as i stated in my above post, which is simply calling attention to oneself, while trying to make others think that he wouldnt call attention to himself if he was indeed a mafia. So therefore he must be!

HUH?..ok, even double talking side stepping, bad typing me, missed that?..lmao, ..maybe you should slow down a lil?...lmao

 

[judgemax]

wanted to add to is this your sad attempt to cover up, the direction from the don?...

 

[mee-mee]

Sweeeeeeet I can actually post this time around, instead of just watching them. Hey, there's only 4 of them now, this should only take what, 2 nights? And for what its worth (probably not too much at this point) I am also an innocent.

All Mafia claim that right from the getgo

haha this game is really confusing me already !!??

And this is only a defense

So much reading last game only to put everyone back to 5. It just isn't fair I tell ya.

What isn't fair

maybe im a mafia!

Maybe you are

lol, are you trying to get yourself killed?

Defending??

no, i say we get rid of that coler guy... lol who just jumps out and is like IM INNOCENT! <<< NO YOUR NOT YOU LIAR!

How do you know he is or isnt..I for one dont know...

lol, coler is strange, that doesnt nessicarilly mean hes mafia

Trying to protect...

BTW...thanx JM for the qouting help...I am going to be watching and reading very carefully...I still have some suspicions about some...time will tell...

 

[Coler]

In fact, I'm almost considering suggesting that we not lynch anyone tonight and give the detective time to work. But we don't learn anything in the process. Everyone else's thoughts?

I've thought about this as well when playing (as now) as an innocent...thing is though we have to get information on day one, and votes = reactions = information...having said that, as the day goes on, there is nothing wrong with voting no one at the end of it (I know everyone says 'that only helps the mafia' but think about it; how does it help the town if you don't have a least a probably suspect in your mind to vote for, and you end up lynching a fellow innocent.)

It is very likely that a lynching on day one will be an innocent. If it's me, all I ask is that you all learn from the experience

Classic mafia play : day one, rely on the statistics, hide your votes around the place as long as the town have picked an innocent, day two blame one or two of the innocents for the lynching and try and get them killed. Its then only on day three that the mafia have to actually try, if that all works out for them and they would hope to be 4 townies down by then.

I tend to find that mafia, especially new mafia players, cannot resist a lynchwagon early on day one though.

Now, having said all that, my mafia meter is perked by 4 people since my first post, and we'll all continue on learning as we go during the course of the day.

We might end up with a great suspect for a lynching yet.

 

[joander123]

you may vote for me all you want, but you'll only find that im innocent.