MAFIA #5 The Play.....
- Thread starter Rbishop
- Start date
Well....joander is still on the top of my list...followed by cl (the other one lol) and sploke.
I vote to lynch joander. He acted just like me in game #4 and I was mafia then. My vote may be changed if in the next little bit if some one starts really tingleling my mafia radar (more then jo...which would take alot lol).
CL
I vote to lynch joander. He acted just like me in game #4 and I was mafia then. My vote may be changed if in the next little bit if some one starts really tingleling my mafia radar (more then jo...which would take alot lol).
CL
I know what you meant, lmao, it just read funny, and had to point it out, ..cause i almsot spit soda on my computer, lol..
and, is that a new line in your sig?..lol
OK townies, if you wanted my advice on what to do next, its not to let a snowball of votes develop around joander...someone needs to come up with another good suspect, in order that we can see how the voting goes there (note my vote has remained on myself)
Point 1 - on day 1/night 1, unfortunately, statistically we are likely to vote an innocent, we should still of course try and pick out a mafia.
Point 2 - the game is won and lost on processing information, the more the better. Identifying a second suspect and having a slightly more complicated vote will draw more people out. This works because it gives more chance of actually identifying a mafia, and it gives more information which could be very useful as the game progresses.
I would advise joander to start making a case against somebody else at this stage as well.
Point 1 - on day 1/night 1, unfortunately, statistically we are likely to vote an innocent, we should still of course try and pick out a mafia.
Point 2 - the game is won and lost on processing information, the more the better. Identifying a second suspect and having a slightly more complicated vote will draw more people out. This works because it gives more chance of actually identifying a mafia, and it gives more information which could be very useful as the game progresses.
I would advise joander to start making a case against somebody else at this stage as well.
Therein lies the problem. If you sound like mafia, people think you're mafia. If you try to not sound like mafia, people think, well he's trying not to sound like mafia so he must be mafia. Catch 22.
I posted 3 times so far and they were fairly different, but its only 3 posts...hardly a proper sample group. I actually think some of the "senior players" are at somewhat of a disadvantage because you can gauge how they are playing with regard to previous games. Newbs, like myself, have no track record, so everything is going to seem suspicious until you figure out an individual's style. In other words, I wouldn't call someone inconsistent because they haven't established a style yet, only if they had a style that they began going against at some point.
Good observation. I'm not attempting to be something I'm not..
Secondly.. I stated this was an initial list. In fact this is exactly what I posted..
1. DangerDoll - simply due to the finger pointing right away with nothing to base it on.
2. JoAnder - While he is a newbie like myself, but the proposed slip up does indeed need further investigation.
3. Ice - Sorry but you were the detective last game so it would be concevable that you would be mafia this game.
4. Corey Lover - due to his lack of posting.
5. Judge - She was a great innocent last game, and as stated would make a great mafia this game.
But as you said everyone needs watching..
Notice that those are on the bottom of the list. The top two I have what is my reasoning for my list, which is what you all wanted posted correct? Was it not you who even requested that we post our lists? Now have I posted anything different up to this point? Have I waffled on anything up to this point?
No what I have done is watch everyone else and have been drawing my own conclusions.
You for instance are playing completely differently from last game, but that doesn't mean that you haven't learned your lesson from last game as I would say that is what singely got you pegged as mafia. But that still doesn't mean that you aren't mafia no matter what you have previously stated. As of this point everyone in this town should be on everyone's radar..
I wish people would stop saying things like this...the status and special roles of each person are assigned by RANDOM NUMBER GENERATION. To state that "you were such and such last game so its possible that you're such and such this game" is completely misleading. Unless, of course, you know something we don't. Based on that, its conceivable that everyone in the game is mafia, since assignments in that game have nothing to do with this game.
well, if you guys want other suspects at this point, I guess that malbri would be my second guess, she has constantly stuck up for everyone else..Most especially jo, and I feel strongly that jo made a newbie mistake.
I am also looking at Clown lover, ..not only is it hard to have two CL's, lol, its awfully early to act so serious IMHO..I can't help but think, one that comes on that strong, and hasn't played before, ..maybe needing ti hide something, hes either a very smart person, or very dangerous,
as always, i will be on the watch of all the ones I consider stellar players, Just like sploke said, you guys have an advantage, I tend to agree, and if any of you are mafia, You need to go quick, ...
anybody else notice that RB didn't answer the question on the appears thing?..if we are dealing with more than 4 mafia, i want to know...
i would show you the mafia, but i have no idea who they are... no one can tell at this point and if you think it is me, then you will vote me. But like i said... im only an innocent.
dangerdoll and coler seem suspicious to me.... danger doll for the early finger pointing with no reason... and again, coler for reasons i've stated above.
