MAFIA #5 The Play.....

[mee-mee]

I am going out on a limb, (just because I have to go to bed)...

I vote for Johnlarson66...

he is the one that voted for CL2 first and then same for night 2 on Jo...

 

[ZSandmann]

Ice if you're looking for a Triad that includes me, you got it all wrong. I still believe there is a 50% chance Coler is Mafia, the botched hit proves A) Coler is Innocent or B) Coler is Mafia As I said earlier it is entirely possible the Mafia risked the hit in hopes of effectively planting a Mafia in our ranks. Right now I don't think he is but he's squirrelly so who knows for sure. On sploke, yup I really thought him Mafia, so I called him out, the response I got seemed like genuine Innocent Newbie to me. Could I be getting completely jerked around? Absolutely, look at Day 1, I'm as guilty as you of lynching an Innocent, order be danged. I'm hoping it doesn't happen again because until we lynch a Mafia we aren't going to have a lot to go on.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

This is what it says about the Botched Murder...

The “Botched Murder”. On the first game night, I will flip a coin. Either the Townies lynch or the Mafia hit will fail. Nothing will be revealed about this person’s special roles, if any.


So maybe he was almost lynched by the Mafia...Not that I am covering up anything for I most certainly am not...and it was a random the Mafia lynching failed on Coler...not unless they threw him up for a lamb...it was a 50-50 chance and we lost CL 2,,,but Coler was saved, maybe he is telling the truth...

Ummm... hasn't this already been stated like 20 times? Not that I counted, but why would you bother pointing that out at this point? As far as I can see, if the botched hit was a mafia ploy we might as well pay protection money and quit. I really don't beieve they'd risk a player as experienced as Coler on the aforementioned coin flip. Must go back and read the rest of your posts....

 

[Hooked Newbie]

Ice if you're looking for a Triad that includes me, you got it all wrong. I still believe there is a 50% chance Coler is Mafia, the botched hit proves A) Coler is Innocent or B) Coler is Mafia As I said earlier it is entirely possible the Mafia risked the hit in hopes of effectively planting a Mafia in our ranks. Right now I don't think he is but he's squirrelly so who knows for sure. On sploke, yup I really thought him Mafia, so I called him out, the response I got seemed like genuine Innocent Newbie to me. Could I be getting completely jerked around? Absolutely, look at Day 1, I'm as guilty as you of lynching an Innocent, order be danged. I'm hoping it doesn't happen again because until we lynch a Mafia we aren't going to have a lot to go on.

If the mafia wanted to "plant" someone in our ranks, I don't believe they'd choose an experienced player to do it with. I find the fact that you and Ice posting this same "possibility" so closely together a bit alarming. You folks just get out of a team meeting?

 

[Hooked Newbie]

I am going out on a limb, (just because I have to go to bed)...

I vote for Johnlarson66...

he is the one that voted for CL2 first and then same for night 2 on Jo...

Any reasoning behind this vote? This randomness actually makes JL look more innocent and you more guilty IMO.

 

[ZSandmann]

If the mafia wanted to "plant" someone in our ranks, I don't believe they'd choose an experienced player to do it with. I find the fact that you and Ice posting this same "possibility" so closely together a bit alarming. You folks just get out of a team meeting?

lol, I just got off work and was replying to Ice's allegations of a Coler, Sandy, sploke triad. HN I'm 90% you are Innocent this Round but why the sudden crazy finger pointing? In five minutes you've pointed at mee-mee, Ice, and myself. If we're all Mafia there ya go you're almost home. But I think your hunt would end in tears as I it's a bad list in my opinion.

 

[ZSandmann]

For what it's worth here is my current list.

judgemax - 3
joander123 – 3
bkw1982 – 4
Dangerdoll - 4
jpappy789 - 4
OgreMkV – 4
IceH2O - 5
mee-mee - 5
Cory Lover - 5
johnlarson66 - 5
KingOfTheDeep - 6
Jensons - 6
Malbri - 7
sploke – 7
Hooked Newbie - 7
Coler – 9 Assumed Innocent??, Botched Mafia Hit Night 1
ZSandmann

Clown-lover – 10 DEAD Night 1

 

[OgreMkV]

I'm guessing that no one remembers my posts because they were some 20-15 pages ago. I said the same thing mee-mee.

I'd also like to point out that mee-mee is doing the exact same thing she did night one, to vote to lynch someone that has no real chance of being lynched... thereby keeping herself off the radar.

I agree that JLarnson is one to watch... but is he vote worthy now?

I'm almost tempted to vote for mee-mee and do the same thing she did

Malbri still hasn't voted nor has bkw. Talk about lying low.

I'm telling you, I really think the mafia is in stealth mode and laughing there tails off at all of us pointing fingers at each other.

 

[IceH2O]

Ice if you're looking for a Triad that includes me, you got it all wrong. I still believe there is a 50% chance Coler is Mafia, the botched hit proves A) Coler is Innocent or B) Coler is Mafia As I said earlier it is entirely possible the Mafia risked the hit in hopes of effectively planting a Mafia in our ranks. Right now I don't think he is but he's squirrelly so who knows for sure. On sploke, yup I really thought him Mafia, so I called him out, the response I got seemed like genuine Innocent Newbie to me. Could I be getting completely jerked around? Absolutely, look at Day 1, I'm as guilty as you of lynching an Innocent, order be danged. I'm hoping it doesn't happen again because until we lynch a Mafia we aren't going to have a lot to go on.

See I almost fell automatically to the he was hit therefore he is innocent side also.

But now I'm not so sure. He jumps on a lot of people. His "lists" are hardly ever the same. Why cast so much indecisiveness on so many people at once except to get votes strung out so the mafia can gain the upper hand on who they really want out?

Sploke I've never trusted and will probably throw my vote that way.

You I believed innocent for the longest but then you jumped in with Coler and Sploke and that made me wonder.

Of the 3 you are lowest on the radar.

My top 3 are IN NO ORDER

Jpappy
Sploke

and I'm going to list someone not posting much but for some reason when they do its a vote for no one that has been really standing out and thats Mee-Mee

 

[Hooked Newbie]

why the sudden crazy finger pointing?

Not sudden and hopefully not crazy. Please note that I voted for Sploke and Max yesterday and you today. The mee-mee post, just made her look more guilty IMO (I did point a finger at her or even use the "M" word). Are you defending a completely random vote that holds no reasoning or explanation behind it? Ice to me is a wild card at this point and the possibility of an unknown 5th mafia member needs to keep us all from focusing on just a potential 4.