MAFIA #5 The Play.....

[ZSandmann]

Not sudden and hopefully not crazy. Please note that I voted for Sploke and Max yesterday and you today. The mee-mee post, just made her look more guilty IMO (I did point a finger at her or even use the "M" word). Are you defending a completely random vote that holds no reasoning or explanation behind it? Ice to me is a wild card at this point and the possibility of an unknown 5th mafia member needs to keep us all from focusing on just a potential 4.

I'm not protecting a thing. Look at my list I just posted you'll see I have fair suspicions of mee-mee, and Ice, Ogre as well, for now I'm assuming Coler Innocent but that's not stone. I'm just thrilled the conversation has picked up, every time I popped in at work today it was a ghost town. I guess I'm not the only one that works.

 

[KingOfTheDeep]

For what it's worth here is my current list.

judgemax - 3
joander123 – 3
bkw1982 – 4
Dangerdoll - 4
jpappy789 - 4
OgreMkV – 4
IceH2O - 5
mee-mee - 5
Cory Lover - 5
johnlarson66 - 5
KingOfTheDeep - 6
Jensons - 6
Malbri - 7
sploke – 7
Hooked Newbie - 7
Coler – 9 Assumed Innocent??, Botched Mafia Hit Night 1
ZSandmann

Clown-lover – 10 DEAD Night 1

what exactly do the numbers mean?

 

[Hooked Newbie]

I'm not protecting a thing. Look at my list I just posted you'll see I have fair suspicions of mee-mee, and Ice, Ogre as well, for now I'm assuming Coler Innocent but that's not stone. I'm just thrilled the conversation has picked up, every time I popped in at work today it was a ghost town. I guess I'm not the only one that works.

LOL, no unfortuntely I work for a company that believes in "big brother". Only specifically authorized non intranet sites are allowed. I agree it's not stone, but it seems pretty solid. Maybe petrified wood? If it was a mafia tactic why choose a strong player?

 

[IceH2O]

Zman I WISH I had access at work. It kills me not knowing what is going on lol.

I work on the road so unless I buy a laptop and steal wireless signals I can't be here.

 

[ZSandmann]

what exactly do the numbers mean?

1 - Mafia
10 - Innocent
5- Neutral

 

[ZSandmann]

LOL, no unfortuntely I work for a company that believes in "big brother". Only specifically authorized non intranet sites are allowed. I agree it's not stone, but it seems pretty solid. Maybe petrified wood? If it was a mafia tactic why choose a strong player?

Believability. Why would the Mafia hit a less experience player on Night 1? Would we follow a Newbie as we would follow Coler?

How about coquina, it's not so much a rock as conglomeratic seashells.

 

[IceH2O]

LOL, no unfortuntely I work for a company that believes in "big brother". Only specifically authorized non intranet sites are allowed. I agree it's not stone, but it seems pretty solid. Maybe petrified wood? If it was a mafia tactic why choose a strong player?

Only thing I can think is that if it did work why not have the strongest player pulling the strings?

I think the plan was for 1 mafia player to try and point fingers and the others lurk in the shadows aand place votes where needed,be it to help a train start rolling or place votes on people that it doesn't matter if they have a single vote on them as long as it doesn't push them over the edge of who they want out.

If the plan fails and the stronger player is lynched the rest of the mafia hide in the shadows, make no waves and just go with the flow.

Almost worked for you HN last game.

 

[ZSandmann]

For the record Day 1's vote was a tie, rb just didn't mention the coin toss in the Narration.
Day 1 Votes:
joander - (6) judgemax (59) IceH2O (164) Cory lover (172) DangerDoll (308), KOTD (335) clown-lover (390)
judgemax - (1) Hooked Newbie (222)
clown-lover - (6) johnlarson66 (296) ZSandmann (324) joander123 (338) jensons (373) Coler (381) IceH2O (382)
jpappy789 - (1) sploke (336)
Malbri – (1) mee-mee (380)

 

[IceH2O]

For the record Day 1's vote was a tie, rb just didn't mention the coin toss in the Narration.
Day 1 Votes:
joander - (6) judgemax (59) IceH2O (164) Cory lover (172) DangerDoll (308), KOTD (335) clown-lover (390)
judgemax - (1) Hooked Newbie (222)
clown-lover - (6) johnlarson66 (296) ZSandmann (324) joander123 (338) jensons (373) Coler (381) IceH2O (382)
jpappy789 - (1) sploke (336)
Malbri – (1) mee-mee (380)

Nah it has me voting Clown and Jo and shows Coler on clown

I voted clown and coler pulled his to no one

 

[Hooked Newbie]

Believability. Why would the Mafia hit a less experience player on Night 1? Would we follow a Newbie as we would follow Coler?

.

No we wouldn't follow a newbie as we would Coler, BUT on a very risky ploy I think they'd settle for having someone, ANYONE that was "above suspicion". If the same had happened and it was a botched hit on one of the newbies, I'd probably be more suspicious.

Only thing I can think is that if it did work why not have the strongest player pulling the strings?

I think the plan was for 1 mafia player to try and point fingers and the others lurk in the shadows aand place votes where needed,be it to help a train start rolling or place votes on people that it doesn't matter if they have a single vote on them as long as it doesn't push them over the edge of who they want out.

If the plan fails and the stronger player is lynched the rest of the mafia hide in the shadows, make no waves and just go with the flow.

Almost worked for you HN last game.

You give us too much credit (No offense here KOTD), we were not nearly organized and had no cohesive plan. We kind of each played our own game (as evidenced by CL, mee-mee, and NJ). And again, that would be too big a risk on night one so I will naturally suspect those who lend alot of credence to that remote possibility. Especially when stated so closely in time AND defended in following posts.