MAFIA #5 The Play.....
- Thread starter Rbishop
- Start date
Ah, no guts, no glory.
I remove my vote for jpappy, I vote to lynch Ogre!
I've just found out I am going to be buried in a project at work for the rest of the week. I was wanting to wait but there ya go, Ogre is my favorite for Mafia right now. I DO still think jpappy may be one too though.
Others I think are Mafia: bkw1982, DangerDoll, IceH2O. I think the Vigilante is Mafia but I hope I am wrong about that. Time for me to head home, I will post more info on Ogre when I get done with dinner and before I go watch Ghost Hunters.
I remove my vote for jpappy, I vote to lynch Ogre!
I've just found out I am going to be buried in a project at work for the rest of the week. I was wanting to wait but there ya go, Ogre is my favorite for Mafia right now. I DO still think jpappy may be one too though.
Others I think are Mafia: bkw1982, DangerDoll, IceH2O. I think the Vigilante is Mafia but I hope I am wrong about that. Time for me to head home, I will post more info on Ogre when I get done with dinner and before I go watch Ghost Hunters.
Bkw has always been on my screen, but my craziness of you guys always had it pushed back
Post 235
Here he thinks JM is mafia, but he never votes for her, actually no vote at all on Day 1
Post 429
Leaning innocent(due to consistent paly from last game)
judge...it took her a day and a night to catch most of the mafia. she is posting the same way she did last game
[/QUOTE]
Here he thinks she is innocent
Post 662
Defending JM and then voting Jo
Post 672
Still on Jo as mafia
Nothing else since. Very Very protective of JM while trying to get Jo out. I admit I thought Jo was mafia the 1st day but since then I'm convinced they are innocent.
Not much help on other players, doesn't really give a list for us to look at.
KOTD
Post 441
This is in response to Joander saying "People who i think need further watching, are DD and KOTD. They both seem to be laying back some-what, but also seem to be jumping on what ever lynch wagon arises. They just do not seem right to me."
One of the dangerous shadow mafia? Trying to distance himself from DD? I'll get to her in a bit.
Post 450
Covering his tracks? Or just really paranoid. I know I'm not looking to see if anyone PMs. That boat had sailed when JM and Rb told how its done. Anyone getting a PM is making sure no one will see it.
Post 470
He is consistent here. But waited for 3 others to vote Jo, is he bandwagon jumping or did the train stall and he was trying to get it back started?
Post 505
Again making sure we know he is laid back, Also that he is still on Jo
Post 530
Still on Jo,starting to doubt JM...I can understand it though, I still didn't see it in JM and still don't lol.
Post 583
Again needs to let us know how lazy and laid back he is.
Post 677
Still on JO. Matter of fact I can't see where he has named anyone else except a slight doubt of JM but not enough to switch off Jo.
Post 682
Coming up on the end of day 2 which is in reality 3 days of posting and still his only proof of Jo is the newbie mafia slip. Wouldn't you have more on someone then that after 3 days of posting?
Post 684
He is more sure of Jo being mafia over 1 post then I was of Coler.
Post 691
This is in response to Joander. KOTD is positive that Jo is Mafia. Why wait this long to try and convince us. He hasn't tried to convince anyone. Just sits back and watches.
Post 737
Still on Jo....let go already or show us more proof because we aren't seeing it.
Throws in a I knew something about JM was fishy. Distancing?
Theres a few more but they basically are Jo is mafia I know it and thats why I'm voting him.
DD, I tried to give her the benefit of the doubt. I could never pick if she was innocent or mafia in other games. This game she seems very defensive, when asked for a list she pulls up garbage posts. Its almost like she knows who is innocent and can't find a way to make them look bad.
Jpappys one mistake was the post also. I can't hold that against him.
Jensons a lot of bandwagon jumping. Sit back see which way the vote is going and join as to not look conspicuous.
Mee-mee last 10 minutes of day and throws a nonsense vote in a close match Then 2nd night she throws another worthless vote.
Sploke Had no real opinion, was to stuck on Coler, when he buddied up with Coler I started to suspect. Back to a 5.
Coler I'm convinced he is innocent, after all the accusations I threw he didn't answer any of them defensively
Zman Vote jumping had me worried,still does to an extent,will watch him
Mal,CL,Jl not much from CL or Mal (less from Mal) Jl vacation slows his vote understandably. Mal not voting though is a sign that needs watching
Jo I believe innocent, so must at least half of us or he'd be gone. Becomes a Mets fan and I'll throw my body in front of a car to save him from a hit lol
Ogre sick wife and kid makes posting hard, when he does its usually informative but lacking this game. I blame the sickness, its hard to take care of a sick kid. Hope once everyones healed up to see some good info.
Thats my take on everyone, think I got them all.
Obviously Bwk,KOTD and DD are the top of the list. Unless they start pulling some reasons why we should look into numerous people and have good reasons for them they will stay there.
I think we should put up who we think are mafia quiet or not. Quiet mafia IMO are more dangerous. We can counter the loud ones with proof.
Post 235
Here he thinks JM is mafia, but he never votes for her, actually no vote at all on Day 1
Post 429
Leaning innocent(due to consistent paly from last game)
judge...it took her a day and a night to catch most of the mafia. she is posting the same way she did last game
[/QUOTE]
Here he thinks she is innocent
Post 662
Defending JM and then voting Jo
Post 672
Still on Jo as mafia
Nothing else since. Very Very protective of JM while trying to get Jo out. I admit I thought Jo was mafia the 1st day but since then I'm convinced they are innocent.
Not much help on other players, doesn't really give a list for us to look at.
KOTD
Post 441
im just sitting back and reading..thats just how i play the game
This is in response to Joander saying "People who i think need further watching, are DD and KOTD. They both seem to be laying back some-what, but also seem to be jumping on what ever lynch wagon arises. They just do not seem right to me."
One of the dangerous shadow mafia? Trying to distance himself from DD? I'll get to her in a bit.
Post 450
Covering his tracks? Or just really paranoid. I know I'm not looking to see if anyone PMs. That boat had sailed when JM and Rb told how its done. Anyone getting a PM is making sure no one will see it.
Post 470
He is consistent here. But waited for 3 others to vote Jo, is he bandwagon jumping or did the train stall and he was trying to get it back started?
Post 505
lol..this is just how i play this game, im going to wait until i see any signs of mafia, then i will post with a lynch vote, or some observations, jo is the only one i suspect now and i really hope im right about him.
I was mafia last game..so i was defensive when called out..im playing this game much more comfortably since i am not mafia this time around
Again making sure we know he is laid back, Also that he is still on Jo
Post 530
Still on Jo,starting to doubt JM...I can understand it though, I still didn't see it in JM and still don't lol.
Post 583
Again needs to let us know how lazy and laid back he is.
Post 677
Still on JO. Matter of fact I can't see where he has named anyone else except a slight doubt of JM but not enough to switch off Jo.
Post 682
Coming up on the end of day 2 which is in reality 3 days of posting and still his only proof of Jo is the newbie mafia slip. Wouldn't you have more on someone then that after 3 days of posting?
Post 684
He is more sure of Jo being mafia over 1 post then I was of Coler.
Post 691
This is in response to Joander. KOTD is positive that Jo is Mafia. Why wait this long to try and convince us. He hasn't tried to convince anyone. Just sits back and watches.
Post 737
Still on Jo....let go already or show us more proof because we aren't seeing it.
Throws in a I knew something about JM was fishy. Distancing?
Theres a few more but they basically are Jo is mafia I know it and thats why I'm voting him.
DD, I tried to give her the benefit of the doubt. I could never pick if she was innocent or mafia in other games. This game she seems very defensive, when asked for a list she pulls up garbage posts. Its almost like she knows who is innocent and can't find a way to make them look bad.
Jpappys one mistake was the post also. I can't hold that against him.
Jensons a lot of bandwagon jumping. Sit back see which way the vote is going and join as to not look conspicuous.
Mee-mee last 10 minutes of day and throws a nonsense vote in a close match Then 2nd night she throws another worthless vote.
Sploke Had no real opinion, was to stuck on Coler, when he buddied up with Coler I started to suspect. Back to a 5.
Coler I'm convinced he is innocent, after all the accusations I threw he didn't answer any of them defensively
Zman Vote jumping had me worried,still does to an extent,will watch him
Mal,CL,Jl not much from CL or Mal (less from Mal) Jl vacation slows his vote understandably. Mal not voting though is a sign that needs watching
Jo I believe innocent, so must at least half of us or he'd be gone. Becomes a Mets fan and I'll throw my body in front of a car to save him from a hit lol
Ogre sick wife and kid makes posting hard, when he does its usually informative but lacking this game. I blame the sickness, its hard to take care of a sick kid. Hope once everyones healed up to see some good info.
Thats my take on everyone, think I got them all.
Obviously Bwk,KOTD and DD are the top of the list. Unless they start pulling some reasons why we should look into numerous people and have good reasons for them they will stay there.
I think we should put up who we think are mafia quiet or not. Quiet mafia IMO are more dangerous. We can counter the loud ones with proof.
OgreMkV
Father of Earth's Next Emperor
Ogre's List
bkw1982 - no vote day one and then a medium late joander vote, sleeper mafia?, but probably not.
clown-lover - innocent
Coler - innocent, botched mafia hit.
Cory Lover - Final vote for JMax, after a late vote for joander and a joander vote on day 1. Could be mafia, knowing his partner was doomed casting the final vote to make himself look innocent.
Dangerdoll - Voted for Joander day 1 and first vote for mee-mee day 2. Wondering how she feels about me, since it appears that she followed my statements on mee-mee.
Hooked Newbie - innocent
IceH2O - leaning innocent
Jensons - one of my top mafia picks. She was the final vote on Day 2 and a late vote on day 1. My thoughts on her are elsewhere in the thread. Her day two vote for joander makes it seem more likely that joander is innocent in my eyes OR her and joander are teaming up. She knew her late vote in day 2 would make no difference to JMax's outcome, but she didn't want to vote for JMax inorder to keep the mafia votes seperate.
joander123 - Either totally mafia or totally innocent (yeah, I know, duh!), but joander has been in a firestorm of contention for two days and narrowly (by two votes or less) avoided our noose each time. A massive vote change on day 1 saved him and a second vote change on day 2 saved him again. If he's mafia, he's very cool, if he's innocent, then... it's a bad day for us.
johnlarson66 - vacationing. Doesn't imply innocence though. Voting pattern seems strange, but it wouldn't matter if he's mafia because he's not as involved in the game... unless we spend five more turns ignoring him.
jpappy789 - missed day 1 and jumped on the joander train day 2. leaning innocent just cause... kinda same as bkw
judgemax - Mafia - yay us
KingOfTheDeep - Lots of people have him on the list, but I'm not so sure. Voted joander both times. The only other player that voted joander both days was JMax. I'm leaning innocent for no real reason.
Malbri - two no votes. doesn't much matter, no vote tomorrow means bishop will take her out.
mee-mee - either mafia or playing a totally unrelated game. It's almost like she's playing a different game than the rest of us... hmmm... that got me to thinking...
OgreMkV - innocent
sploke - another one that intially peaked my radar with the Malbri/jpappy vote on day 1, but second person to vote JMax. I think a mafia would have switched votes after everyone saw that JMax was doomed. However, the only other realistic candidate was joander... which, if he's mafia means, that a switch wouldn't have helped.
ZSandmann - leaning very innocent. He played like he did last game, getting information. Learning some tricks to find out who wants what to happen.
So there you go. I think a good case can be made for a sploke, jensons, joander, jmax mafia team.
Though, a good case could also be made for replacing joander with one of the sleeper mafia or Cory Lover.
This is current as of now. We still have 25 hours to go as I write this. I won't vote until later, but my top pick will probably be one of the three on that list.
bkw1982 - no vote day one and then a medium late joander vote, sleeper mafia?, but probably not.
clown-lover - innocent
Coler - innocent, botched mafia hit.
Cory Lover - Final vote for JMax, after a late vote for joander and a joander vote on day 1. Could be mafia, knowing his partner was doomed casting the final vote to make himself look innocent.
Dangerdoll - Voted for Joander day 1 and first vote for mee-mee day 2. Wondering how she feels about me, since it appears that she followed my statements on mee-mee.
Hooked Newbie - innocent
IceH2O - leaning innocent
Jensons - one of my top mafia picks. She was the final vote on Day 2 and a late vote on day 1. My thoughts on her are elsewhere in the thread. Her day two vote for joander makes it seem more likely that joander is innocent in my eyes OR her and joander are teaming up. She knew her late vote in day 2 would make no difference to JMax's outcome, but she didn't want to vote for JMax inorder to keep the mafia votes seperate.
joander123 - Either totally mafia or totally innocent (yeah, I know, duh!), but joander has been in a firestorm of contention for two days and narrowly (by two votes or less) avoided our noose each time. A massive vote change on day 1 saved him and a second vote change on day 2 saved him again. If he's mafia, he's very cool, if he's innocent, then... it's a bad day for us.
johnlarson66 - vacationing. Doesn't imply innocence though. Voting pattern seems strange, but it wouldn't matter if he's mafia because he's not as involved in the game... unless we spend five more turns ignoring him.
jpappy789 - missed day 1 and jumped on the joander train day 2. leaning innocent just cause... kinda same as bkw
judgemax - Mafia - yay us
KingOfTheDeep - Lots of people have him on the list, but I'm not so sure. Voted joander both times. The only other player that voted joander both days was JMax. I'm leaning innocent for no real reason.
Malbri - two no votes. doesn't much matter, no vote tomorrow means bishop will take her out.
mee-mee - either mafia or playing a totally unrelated game. It's almost like she's playing a different game than the rest of us... hmmm... that got me to thinking...
OgreMkV - innocent
sploke - another one that intially peaked my radar with the Malbri/jpappy vote on day 1, but second person to vote JMax. I think a mafia would have switched votes after everyone saw that JMax was doomed. However, the only other realistic candidate was joander... which, if he's mafia means, that a switch wouldn't have helped.
ZSandmann - leaning very innocent. He played like he did last game, getting information. Learning some tricks to find out who wants what to happen.
So there you go. I think a good case can be made for a sploke, jensons, joander, jmax mafia team.
Though, a good case could also be made for replacing joander with one of the sleeper mafia or Cory Lover.
This is current as of now. We still have 25 hours to go as I write this. I won't vote until later, but my top pick will probably be one of the three on that list.
nice, guys (Ice & Ogre)
appreciating that you both are on my list (no hard feelings), those are good posts and will help.
Ice, I see we share a common suspicion of DD and bkw
Ogre. I can agree a case to answer in respect of Jensons and of (clearly) joander
Food for thought.
I'm also thinking, very late votes are I think in fact benefecial to the mafia. You need time to assess reactions/patterns...lets not leave it too late to put names in the ring.
appreciating that you both are on my list (no hard feelings), those are good posts and will help.
Ice, I see we share a common suspicion of DD and bkw
Ogre. I can agree a case to answer in respect of Jensons and of (clearly) joander
Food for thought.
I'm also thinking, very late votes are I think in fact benefecial to the mafia. You need time to assess reactions/patterns...lets not leave it too late to put names in the ring.
Hey hey hey!
Well, here is my list of top suspects:
(1) Ice- moves up to my number one mafia suspect....he just seems mafianess.
(2) jpappy-moves down a notch....but still needs to be watched very closely because he was after joander so much right before JM got lynched (but right now I don't trust jpappy or jo)
(3) joander (for reasons stated in my other posts)
(4) Ogre-moves up....just don't trust him.
(5) bkw-stuck up for JM
CL
Well, here is my list of top suspects:
(1) Ice- moves up to my number one mafia suspect....he just seems mafianess.
(2) jpappy-moves down a notch....but still needs to be watched very closely because he was after joander so much right before JM got lynched (but right now I don't trust jpappy or jo)
(3) joander (for reasons stated in my other posts)
(4) Ogre-moves up....just don't trust him.
(5) bkw-stuck up for JM
CL
OgreMkV
Father of Earth's Next Emperor
OK, for now, I vote to lynch joander.
I think that determining joander's innocence or mafianess will tell us more than just about anything else about several players.
I think that determining joander's innocence or mafianess will tell us more than just about anything else about several players.
Hmmmm...doesn't work for me as a team...if that's them, and that's all of them, I have been owned.
